Constitution as conscience detector
Debates on the forthcoming referendum on amending the Constitution are still tense in the Parliament. One day the deputies are eagerly trying to prove practicability of the amendments, the other day they can not chose the date of the nation-vide voting, and then flounder about the terms that they have invented by themselves.
What we will vote for?
The next meeting of the Committee on Constitutional Legislation, State Structure, Judicial and Legal Issues, Regulations of the Parliament started with the already familiar accusations \"you are fool - no, you are fool.\" Deputies were unable to figure out what wording of the bill on amendments to the Constitution to adopt. The confusion arose from the fact that in the first reading there was adopted the document with the word \"bill\", and it was transformed into the \"law\" in the second reading.
A member of Bir Bol faction Cholpon Dzhakupova noted that previously, including the plenary session, the deputies approved the wording that a bill on amending the Constitution is submitted to a referendum. \"Today, the wording of Article 2 was changed. It goes like this: to submit a law to the referendum. Will we stick to that we have adopted in the first reading? What should we do now? Should we return back to the first reading?\" she asked the head of the committee Asel Koduranova (SDPK).
She explained that in the first reading the Parliament considered the concept of law. One still can make changes in the second reading.
The head of the Social Democratic Party Isa Omurkulov said that there is a need to write a \"bill\", as the document has not yet been adopted.
The leader of Respublika - Ata Jurt faction Omurbek Babanov also put in his two cents, explaining the colleagues ( maybe they have forgotten) when a bill becomes a law, \"Parliament adopts a law on a referendum. We are now preparing it, will send it for voting as a draft, and after the third reading it will become a law. There is should not be any confusion.\"
MPs argued for more than two hours, made personal remarks and voiced the mutual accusations. As a result, they decided to adjourn and to consult with lawyers.
Constitutional Chamber vs. Constitutional Chamber
Meanwhile, member of Ata Meken Almambet Shykmamatov reminded the audience about the decision of the Constitutional Chamber of the Supreme Court, which as far back as in 2014 decided: it is prohibited to amend the Constitution until 2020.
Recall, in 2010, a civil activist Toktaiym Umetalieva addressed to the Supreme Court with a claim for recognition of the norm, imposing a ban on the introduction of amendments and additions to the Constitution, unconstitutional. However, the court denied her request, thus confirming that the Basic Law does not need amendments.
\"The Supreme Court issued a final decision, and it is not subject to appeal. The Constitution was not replaced, it can not be changed. This is an official document. Or whether there can be exceptions in this case?\" Almambet Shykmamatov said.
During the same meeting, the deputies read out the conclusion of the Constitutional Chamber, which, incidentally, did not find the reasons for complaints of the being prepared referendum. But then the question arises: how the same body can first say that it banned changes, and two years later to declare that the document \"is not contrary to the fundamental rights and freedoms of citizens\"?
Let\'s return to the confusion in the wording. The same statement says that amendments to the Constitution can be made through a referendum. However, the Basic Law does not contain a direct rule who can initiate its holding.
The question of holding a referendum on amending the Constitution should be resolved by analogy with the third paragraph of Section 3, Article 114, according to which the law on amendments can be brought to a referendum at the initiative of not less than two thirds of the total number of deputies of the Parliament.
Yes, exactly the law, but not the bill. But the conclusion states also that the draft law \"On Amendments to the Constitution of the Kyrgyz Republic\" was initiated to be submitted to a referendum without violating the procedure, established by Article 114 of the Constitution.
One question, one answer
It is clear that the Parliament, despite all the contradictions, will nevertheless put forward the bill. Opponents have already reconciled with this and offered at least to give the citizens of Kyrgyzstan an opportunity to decide for themselves whether they entrust development of amendments to the Basic Law to the Parliament.
Ziyadin Zhamaldinov (Onuguu-Progress) proposed to put exactly this question to a referendum. But his proposal was stabbed, like the observations of other deputies- lawyers.
It should be noted that the Parliament wants to change more than 30 articles of the Constitution. Cholpon Dzhakupova insisted on making every amendment a separate question in the ballot paper.
For example:
- Do you agree that the state could bring people to criminal liability for non- fulfillment of civil law obligations?
- Do you agree that the statute of limitations should not be applied to the crimes of genocide and ecocide?
- Do you agree that the state should have an opportunity by the law to deprive of citizenship of the Kyrgyz Republic under compulsion?
- Do you agree to strengthen the powers of the Prime Minister on control over the Parliament in adoption of the national budget and tax laws?
The proposal also has not found support among the deputies.
Myktybek Abdyldaev (Bir Bol) stated to the members of the committee that Parliament must first adopt a law on amendments to the Constitution, and then, by the second law, to appoint a referendum. He has twenty times read out his counterparts the conclusion of the Constitutional Chamber, but they have not understand it or understood, but did not admit their mistakes.
The two-hour break also did not help to understand the legal issues. Cholpon Dzhakupova told 24.kg news agency, why the committee has violated the procedure. \"Each bill would have taken two months. They realized that they had made a blooper. They were afraid that violated the procedure and adopted the wording of the draft law by the majority vote. From a legal point of view, we should comply with the ruling of the Constitutional Chamber and the current Constitution. If it says \"the law\", so it is as it should be,\" she explained.
\"If we demonstrate the population that ignore the provisions of the Constitution and the decisions of the Constitutional Chamber, why there are Parliament, courts and legislators then? Let us live by the rules,\" Cholpon Dzhakupova said.
The leader of the Social Democratic Party and the initiator of the amendments Isa Omurkulov had to settle the dispute. However, he firmly said the referendum would take place, despite the fact that some of the opponents did not like it. And exactly on December 11, rather than December 4, as it was previously voiced. He did not want to hear about the decision of the Constitutional Chamber on the current ban until 2020: \"We will hold a referendum regardless of decision of the Supreme Court. That is all. The Constitution has a direct effect. So write: Omurkulov has said.\"
So we write: nobody in the \"White House\" and among the deputies intends to comply with the laws. They decided to rewrite the constitution - so it is rewritten. That\'s all.