Kubat Rakhimov: It\'s time to forget pretty EEU pictures, come down to earth and work
Kyrgyzstan is a full member of the Eurasian Economic Union for a year and a month. However, the country does not feel relieved for 13 months of the integration. Why did it happen? What conclusions should the officials draw? Expert in infrastructure development of Central Eurasia, former Assistant Minister of Energy and Infrastructure of the Eurasian Economic Commission, an economist Kubat Rakhimov told about it to 24.kg news agency.
- If we get rid of thinking about necessity or uselessness of joining EEU, what is the bottom line?
- The direction towards the Eurasian integration was chosen correctly, I have no doubts about it. But I will ever repeat: any integration is not a magic wand. Any unions between the countries with different levels of economic development always take time, adjustment. This is normal and inevitable. Only cats are born quickly.
- That is, it is too early to speak about mistakes, it is necessary to be patient and wait?
- No. There were mistakes. The main drawback of the Kyrgyz politicians of 2012-2015 is that they were so enthusiastic in positive description of the future EEU that they themselves fell in love with a fictional image. And then we began building facilities, detached from reality. Therefrom is the main defect of our policy - the almost complete absence of strategic planning and risk management.
-What were the mistakes of officials?
- They have been painting everything in pink. I was particularly impressed by Mr. Sariev. He said to citizens as the Minister of Economy: \"Buy the cars, then you will sell it to the Kazakhs!\" He urged Dordoi merchants: \"Buy everything, then you will sell it with a skim when border is opened!\"
Several hundred million dollars of investment resources have gone nowhere in our country - were spent on Japanese scrap and tasteless Chinese clothing.
We are in a vicious circle. Kyrgyzstan became an ouroboros - the snake that bites its own tail. We were promised the moon. But in the end, when we have entered into the union, not counting all the risks, our own investment resources went into speculative capital. It is even difficult to count how much money the people have lost. Their money just disappeared, and many of them borrowed it at high interest rates. Those who invested in the cars, a product that rots, incurred huge losses. The entire integration structure was built on the external aid, and some comrades just were sitting in the chairs and said that everything would be fine. The ability of politicians to answer for their words and for their populism is also a problem. Everything is built on populism in our country.
\"Delusiveness of EEU idea was largely created by the upper structures. And no one had to pay for business fraud. Several hundred million dollars have been invested in unsaleable goods,\" Kubat Rakhimov said.
- And what should have been done?
- Why the same Prime Minister did not come out and say: \"Guys, a market will be opened there, you need to establish production. Do not buy cars, unnecessary stuff. It is better to organize production cooperatives, and we will help. We have state RSK Bank and Aiyl Bank, the Russian-Kyrgyz Development Fund is created. While it is being created, we\'ll help you. Let\'s organize the sites, freeing manufacturers from taxes, from inspections for five years, will give them the opportunity to get to their feet, so just produce. We will check only the added value.\" That\'s what had to be done. This is the only thing that was needed to be done to restart the economy of Kyrgyzstan in these missed two or three years.
- But now the businessmen can not export the goods they have...
- This is another important step that Kyrgyz authorities have missed. We had to turn on the boosting of laboratories and the entire certification infrastructure. Somehow, our officials did not understand that EEU is a cut above the Customs Union. This means high level technical regulations which impose ban on the import and production of low-quality products. These standards define the level of production, the minimum added value level, and so on.
- And what about the promised rich life in EEU?
- They should not have promised that everything would be in chocolate. It was necessary to say that the worst scenario is also possible. They had to say it. People believe the truth. They are not afraid of it. And the officials were so enthusiastic that now we have disappointed society. Why have we entered EEU? - such a question is now raised by the representatives of business, who imagine only unctuous picture, painted by the politicians. No one wanted to explain the small and medium-sized businesses the real-life scenarios that take into account a number of development factors and the world crisis tendencies. We are all the humans, we all see and understand - if our partners in the alliance have problems, it is necessary to solve them together. And some officials and politicians, on the contrary, began stirring up the topic - they say, we are good, our internal policy is good, and it is the fault of the integration.
- And what about the help of the Eurasian Economic Commission?
- We should not think that a supranational body, which is the EEC, is that a magic wand that will help us. This is a working body. It has practical tasks. It has its own Eurasian hierarchy. It is not so simple. They have no ability to influence directly on the national policy of the states. The Commission works out the general legal solutions, unifies patchy right of five countries, but can not directly influence the activities of economic entities of EEU countries and many of the elements of national economies - they all have the tax and monetary sovereignty. Economic Court of EEU is also in the process of establishment - although there is a critical mass of cases to be considered. But its powers are limited.
- Should not we really rely on the allies?
- As long as there is a formation of supranational bodies, our large diplomatic mass has to actively work on bilateral relations. And, of course, 90 percent of the efforts in the integration block should be focused on Kazakhstan. Not relying on the fact that we are close in language and are like-minded countries. This should be a daily work. And we have focused on Russia. At least 80 percent of the problems that we associate with EEU - are our problems with Kazakhstan.
- Is it the fault of Kyrgyzstan?
- In many ways the case. There was supposed to be a Eurasian Institute of Commissioners. And this is a mistake of Moscow and Astana. We have not to rely on the working groups since the beginning of the active integration processes. We had to agree that every ministry and department of Kyrgyzstan would have deputy ministers- representatives of Belarus, Kazakhstan and Russia who will work there on a permanent basis, having successfully completed the integration process. Of course, Kyrgyzstan is afraid of giving access to administrative arrangements to someone from the outside. Maybe it\'s logical. On the other hand, our offices have thousands of consultants from Western countries. Not a single decision of the Ministry of Economy now is made without representatives of many international donor projects. Why not to apply this practice to the representatives of EEU countries? The founders of the Union have missed the opportunity.
- Many employers complain that they can not take out the goods because of the high export cost...
- It is not surprising. It has happened so that the active phase of the integration has coincided with a parade of EEU countries\' currency devaluations. There are many factors, it is a separate issue. Everyone says that the Kyrgyz som is the strongest in the union. But is it good? Prices of food products in Almaty are lower than ours. And this applies not only to products, this applies to almost everything.
- What exchange rate should we have?
- Not so long ago there was more or less comfortable som to ruble exchange rate - about one and a half soms per ruble. I\'m not talking about the dollar. We do not live in America. We have trading partners - Russia, Kazakhstan. Som should be pegged to currency basket, which is formed according to trade shares: Russia, China, Kazakhstan and the Swiss franc, because we sell gold to Switzerland. And we have a projection on dollar and euro through the Swiss franc.
\"Now som exchange rate is equal to the Russian ruble, that is, our competitiveness has fallen at times, particularly in the light of increased competition with the same Kazakhstan, which has twice devalued tenge and thereby supported it\'s manufacturers,\" Kubat Rakhimov said.
- Well, if you talk about today\'s reality, where foreign trade is pegged to the dollar?
- If we are pegged to the dollar, the current exchange rate should be not less than 95-100 soms, to the ruble - 1.3-1.4, KZT - 0.27-0.3. The Kazakhs do not come to us, because it is expensive and not profitable to buy goods there. Some Russian tourists come, but they say that it is expensive here and it is cheaper to fly to Turkey. We are losing tourists from traditional countries who were loyal to our market. With regard to the fall in real exports, it is a separate issue. The general situation is unique this year - perishable food is supplied from Kazakhstan because it is cheaper. But this can only be achieved by exchange rate differences. We have overvalued som.
-Why, then, som does not fall?
- We took a lot of soft loans, which were spent on everything, except for production. In recent years, we have sharply increased the state external debt at the expense of the Chinese Eximbank and became hostages of legal restrictions on the amount of debt to GDP.
Saving for the exporters devaluation dramatically increases the national debt up to 80-85 percent of GDP, which is unacceptable for the international donors who are seriously worried by insolvency of Kyrgyzstan.
- It turns out that there is no way out at all?
- Now we have to look for some opportunities to restart the economy, having strong currency. In order to live normally with overvalued currency, it is necessary to make great efforts. Or to apply for grants again, so they will not be a heavy burden for the budget or to pray for restart of the real sector through the RKDF means, or wait for a miracle or technical default. If you look at re-industrialization model of development of Kyrgyzstan, the technical default, cleaning devaluation coupled with a focus on the breakthrough in two or three sectors of the economy is not so awful scenario.
- Is strong som the only problem of the exporters?
- Of course not. We do not have the positioning of the country within the integration association. Who are we for EEU? What is the potential market share? What do we export? What products or services? Have we managed to take a place in terms of sanctions and anti-sanctions? We have won only one so far. At present, the only growing share of Kyrgyzstan in EEU is the labor market. The wise countries regulate labor migration, without limiting it but encouraging. They encourage the exit of those who receive knowledge and skills. We need to create a fund for the support of our workers, who receive education abroad, in order they to return as specialists in the new industrial and agricultural projects of Kyrgyzstan.
- How Kyrgyzstan can \"swim\" out of the swamp of Eurasian problems?
- It\'s time to reboot, to look at the situation with new eyes. We have to stop thinking and acting from \"give\" position. Now Russia and Kazakhstan have a crisis. They strongly pursed, looking carefully at potential requests. In this coordinate system we need to pay more effort and attention to the actual integration, rather than the ideal picture, painted sometime. We have to see where we are weak, where we have won. To strengthen the position where we have won and to analyze what resources we have not used, and continue working where we are weak. The real result of integration can only be in two or three years. But it is almost impossible without restarting the country\'s economic model, and it is a sovereign issue, automatic integration will not help there. We can do it only by ourselves, putting at the forefront the real economy, rather than political fuss.