Withdrawal of land: why and how
Members of Parliament amend the Housing, Land, Civil and Forest Codes at the instigation of the Justice Ministry. The changes will cancel the ban on withdrawal of land plots for the servicing of residential houses and subsidiary farming. According to the acting Land Code, private garden space is not subject to withdrawal for state, municipal and public needs. That is, the received by the citizens free land plots (gardens, vegetable gardens, plots) may lose their legal protection, and the state will be able to withdraw them or to purchase.
It caused the second wave of indignation. Kyrgyz citizens fear for private property and are afraid of unjustified withdrawal of land. The Minister of Justice Jyldyz Mambetalieva in an interview to 24.kg news agency told what one has to do to cancel the amendments, and why some deputies did not support the initiative.
- Why is there a need to make changes?
- The bill was worked out a year ago and was submitted to the Parliament on September 11, 2015. The discussions were held. They drew close attention, because there were a lot of amendments. Basically, they were developed to bring the law into conformity with the Constitution.
When we switched to a parliamentary form of government, we have to amend many regulations. This work is still ongoing. The Land Code has a norm which prohibits the withdrawal of land for state, municipal and public needs. Article 12 of the Constitution, on the contrary, says: withdrawal of property for public purposes fixed in the Act may be carried out by the court with a fair and prior compensation of the value of property and other damages caused by the alienation. Speaking in legal terms, the Constitution takes the first place and is an act of direct action. This means that if any law is in conflict with it, the Constitution norms are applied directly. It has a higher power.
The Constitution permits withdrawal, but it does not mean that the land will be seized upon the first demand. The list of public needs is fixed by the law. Exceptions when a plot can be required by the society, will be described. Compensation of damages is also calculated, there is provided an opportunity to exchange the land plot. There are different options.
- Was the land seizure included in the Constitution only in 2010?
- No, it always existed. Previously, there was the notion of state and public needs. Then the word \"state\" was excluded. If we do not change this norm in the Land Code, there still will be an article of the Constitution. This is international practice, when the property may be withdrawn if the need arises, for example, to ensure safety. Public needs mean construction of social facilities. The land for servicing of residential houses and subsidiary farming can not be fully used for the construction of public facilities. Perhaps, according to the Site plan, only a part of a land plot will be withdrawn.
- Will evaluation of the property be carried out by independent or state-owned company?
- Procedure for reimbursement is under discussion, several options are being worked out. It is still unknown who exactly will be engaged in the assessment. For example, land plots can be withdrawn for the construction of roads. Owners will be paid compensation. If an agreement is not reached, the problem is to be solved in court. Nobody can just take away a private property. The withdrawal will be linked to the Site plan.
- At what stage the bill is?
- We are making amendments concerning mining. There are problems. We have constant problems with coal supplies. When subsoil users want to develop the deposits, the question of land transformation arises. Coal deposits are often located on forest land. We should not transform them into industrial land. So we decided to facilitate the extraction of fuel not to disrupt the heating season, and suggested the investor to carry out reclamation, to compensate damage and return the site its original state after the development of deposit. Some MPs have opposed it despite the fact that we have asked to make concessions to the investors. They asked to return the bill to the second reading stage.
- Kyrgyz citizens fear mass withdrawal of land in case the amendments are adopted...
- Such cases will arise infrequently. We have to build up in a civilized way and listen to the requests of people, look at the existing problems in land laws. We did not initiate these amendments, they are the aspirations of Kyrgyzstanis. There has long been discussed the issue of planting fruit trees on agricultural land. The legislation does not allow it. Life does not stand still, and laws must keep up with the changes. Earlier, lightweight constructions could not be built on the fields. Greenhouses are permitted to be built there now. Drip irrigation was also considered to be a lightweight construction and was also under the ban. Now we have amended it.
We will clearly define the social needs and the land plots will not be withdrawn left and right. The right to housing is fixed in the Constitution and none can cancel it. Even if we remove this provision from the Land Code, it will remain in the Constitution. What a proposal can be there? In the light of the constitutional reform it is possible to amend Article 12. I do not exclude that it is possible to include the social needs concept in it. The discussion term was extended, and there is an opportunity to submit proposals.