USD87.45EUR95.90RUB1.07
24.kg

Seizure of land on principle “divide and rule”

13:39, 11 August 2016, Bishkek - 24.kg news agency
Julia KOSTENKO

The bill on the reconstruction of the central part of Bishkek, initiated by the leader of Ata Meken faction, was only the beginning of a great scandal, and Omurbek Tekebayev - the lightning rod, who took the heat. While the townspeople defended their right to private property, which one wanted to take away by adopting a new law, the deputies had pushed through not less controversial amendments to the Codes of Kyrgyzstan.

 

Without noise and dust

 

Human rights activist Kalicha Omuralieva said that on June 22 parliament adopted in the second reading the bill \"On amendments to some legislative acts of the Kyrgyz Republic in the field of land use,\" which will allow seizing land for public and municipal needs. Amendments to the Housing, Land, Civil, Forest Codes are made by one package. The Ministry of Justice has initiated changes in order to lift the ban on the withdrawal of land plots for the maintenance of residential houses and ancillary services. At present, according to the Land Code the private garden space is not subject to seizure for state, municipal and public needs. That is private garden space of citizens (gardens, vegetable gardens, plots) may lose the protection of the law, and the state will be able to select them or to buy, if required by public needs.

 

\"If the document is adopted, all private garden space can be taken for construction. The manager and the sole master of the land will be the Mayor\'s Office of Bishkek. These changes violate the rights provided by the Constitution. Property shall be inviolable, and no one can argue it,\" Kalicha Omuralieva said.

 

According to her, this method of land acquisition was piloted in 2008. At the intersection of Isanov and Pushkin Streets one began to buy houses for the construction of commercial housing. Three families refused the deal. Municipality appealed to the court for the seizure of land by presenting two expert opinions on the value of the objects. An independent appraiser named a price of $80,000, and the state - of $40,000. The court decided not to in favor of the citizens.

 

It should be noted that according to the project, land intended for the construction of a technical library. The city authorities have decided that in the age of information technology there is no need in libraries. The site was given to the \"Babek LTD\" LLC, belonging to Emil Bekboev, who is relative of the ex-deputy Zamir Bekboev. Previously, he was the owner of the firm, and then handed it to his brother. It is noteworthy that in 2008, when the land was seized for building construction, Zamir Bekboev held the position of vice-mayor of Bishkek.

 

In accordance with Article 12 of the Constitution of the Kyrgyz Republic property seizure is allowed only for public purposes. To resolve the contradiction with the codes, the Ministry of Justice has rewritten some articles, and now the land provided to citizens, can be purchased in the process of withdrawal for public needs. In particular, it redrew article 32 of the Land Code.

 

Mayor\'s offers 

 

Let\'s return to the sensational bill of Omurbek Tekebayev, who openly admits that it is developed at the request of the mayor Albek Ibraimov. \"In order to improve the living conditions of urban residents and the demolition of dilapidated deem housing it is necessary to exclude article 32, article 46, paragraph 2, item 6 of the Land Code,\" the mayor suggested.

 

These articles read as follows: land for the maintenance of residential houses and ancillary services are not subject to seizure for state, municipal and public needs. The plot, located in the common shared property owners of residential and non-residential premises in an apartment house, also not subjected to seizure.

 

Jyldyz Mambetalieva also became an eye sore for the Minister of Justice. She edited the article 32, and now it sounds as follows: a plot of land donated to the property of citizens of the Kyrgyz Republic, may be withdrawn (bought out).

 

The bill describes the procedure of withdrawal of sites. It can be done only on the basis of an agreement between the competent authority and the owner of the land. If the owner doesn\'t agree with the decision of the authorities who wanted to buy land, the authority may sue on compensated seizure of plot for public use. The paradox is that the law doesn\'t protect the land of owner, but officials, who need another tidbit for so-called social needs.

 

Doing old switcheroo 

 

As soon as the package of documents submitted to the Parliament, many deputies raised objections. The members of the Committee on Constitutional Legislation, State Structure, Judicial and Legal Issues and Regulations of the Parliament agreed that the amendment will cause public outrage. \"The fact that you have published a bill on the website doesn\'t mean anything, because people could miss it. Therefore, my colleagues are right: if we take the norm laid down in Article 32, there will be a social upheaval,\" the deputy Cholpon Dzhakupova (Bir Bol) said referring to the Minister of Justice Jyldyz Mambetalieva.

 

The Deputy must have second sight. Civil society activists haven\'t heard anything about the public discussion of the amendments before they were adopted in the second reading. The Committee on Agrarian Policy, Water Resources, Environment and Regional Development provides poor information. An ordinary inhabitant doesn\'t understand \"regulation of relations in the sphere of land\" or \"exception of the contradictions between normative and legal acts, regulating the same public relations, as well as the optimization of the activities of state bodies and local self-government in the management of the lands of Land Fund the Kyrgyz Republic for the purpose of efficient and safe use of the land in benefit of Kyrgyzstan\'s people.\" Nothing is said about changes to Article 32, emphasis is laid on other amendments. Naturally, the public didn\'t immediately crack on the plan of deputies.

 

According to the chairman of the committee on Agricultural Policy, Water Resources, Environment and Regional Development Mirlan Bakirov, the draft bill is at third reading, therefore, only minor editorial changes in it may be made. He says that all procedures were followed, the government held extensive public hearings in the regions.

 

However, the deputy is also dissatisfied with some changes, in particular concerning land transformation. \"The Ministry of Justice proposed that the Forest Fund independently issued lands for mining. We were strongly opposed. The relevant agencies should deal with these issues. As for the withdrawal of land for public needs, then there is a constitutional norm. Thus, we bring the legislation into the line. This doesn\'t mean that the land will be illegally taken, the document provides for compensation, the order is determined. I don\'t know why the activists missed the discussions,\" Mirlan Bakirov said and added that he was absent when the document was almost accepted in third reading.

 

To stop the flywheel is still possible, if the majority of deputies doesn\'t support the project and bring it back for a second reading.

 

The initiative group, which opposes the bill of Tekebayev, threw power to protect Kyrgyz citizens from another attempt of taking private property. Activists intend to hold rally on September 1. If the deputies don\'t hear their arguments, they will appeal to the Constitutional Chamber, the Prosecutor General\'s Office, and the last instance will be the UN special rapporteur on the protection of citizens\' right to basic shelter. Kyrgyzstanis have already learned how to defend their interests.

CONTACTS

SOCIAL MEDIA

TelegramYouTubeWhatsAppFacebookInstagram

© News Agency «24.kg» - News of Kyrgyzstan. All rights reserved. All information posted on this website is intended for personal use only and may not be distributed without the written permission of NA «24.kg». The editorial team is not responsible for the content of reprinted materials and statements of individuals. +18