USD87.45EUR95.90RUB1.07
24.kg

Road.kg: against better judgment

17:07, 28 July 2016, Bishkek - 24.kg news agency
Tatyana KUDRYAVTSEVA

The scandal with the tender for the reconstruction of Bishkek - Kara-Balta road is gaining momentum. Hardly had the Ministry of Transport and Road dealt with the problems with the track in Issyk-Kul, again steps on the same rake.

 

Tender for construction of road was announced in December 2015. In mid-June 2016, 16 applications opened. It is reported that the six don\'t meet the requirements, one company is included in the black list of the ADB. Now the applications of nine candidates are being studied. Here some interesting facts are found out.

 

The lowest price of $70 million at an estimated project cost of almost $100 million was suggested by China Railway №5 Engineering Group Co. LTD. Most likely, it will be chosen as the winner.

 

Officials simply turn a deaf ear to the voice of reason, which calls not to fall for suspiciously low price. Even so, let\'s try to refresh the memory and knowledge of high officials. China Railway №5 Engineering Group Co. LTD. is affiliated company of China Railway Group, which holds a significant share of the Chinese construction market and is involved in many large-scale infrastructure projects, mainly in South-East Asia and Africa.

 

It is known that in 2009 it tried to enter the new market of the European Union. Then its subsidiary with two Chinese partners won the tender for the construction of parts of two highways in Poland. The project started well in terms of development and preparation. China Railway Group showed good technical grip, but the work stranded in the later stages because of poor management within tight regulatory framework. As a result, the project failed, China Railway Group was replaced by another contractor.

 

There is another interesting fact. In 2012, the Council on Ethics in Norway conducted a study of the companies that invest the country\'s pension fund. In 2014, it recommended to the Ministry of Finance to exclude China Railway Group from the list of companies invested by the Pension Fund, due to corruption.

 

\"According to the report of the Council on Ethics and data on domestic legal solutions in the Chinese Communist Party of China, published in the media, it is clear that China Railway Group is involved in corruption schemes. It and one of its subsidiaries apparently bribed public officials to secure contracts for the construction of railways and housing. This reflected in the two legal decisions of PRC, concerning bribes,\" the letter said.

 

Doesn\'t the tender commission really know such unpleasant details? Or officials simply don\'t want to see what lies on the surface? Isn\'t the cost of the project, which is 30 percent below the estimate one, alarming? It seems not.

 

However, experts believe that the low cost of the project will lead to the fact that it won\'t be finished in time. Such opinion has the advisor to road construction - a Spanish company Eptisa. Experts believe that additional costs may arise in the course of work.

 

For example, according to the project, asphalt plant and crushing station are situated at about 45 km from the main road. This means that the cost of asphalt and the base will increase due to transportation. Let\'s not forget that in the analysis it turned out that the real prices of construction materials and declared by candidate with the least amount are significantly different. As a result, the country can get the unfinished road and requirements to pay a penalty for failing to make work on time. Don\'t forget that the funds allocated by the Asian Development Bank - for the most part are borrowed. That is failed construction and discontent of the population will fall an additional burden to the treasury. Stunning prospect, isn\'t it?

 

The Ministry of Transport and Roads was formed recently on the basis of Ministry of Transport and Communications. This was done to ensure that the agency is working effectively, particularly in infrastructure projects. However, even a superficial glance at the problem projects shows that the officials of the Ministry hadn\'t draw conclusions from the mistakes. A regular meeting of the tender commission on selection of a contractor for the construction of the Bishkek - Kara-Balta will be held today. In previous meeting opinions of the commission members were divided. Not everyone is ready to neglect quality in exchange for a lower price. But will they be able to defend their opinions and the right of the country not to make mistakes anymore in the construction of large objects?

 

 

The scandal with the tender for the reconstruction of Bishkek - Kara-Balta road is gaining momentum. Hardly had the Ministry of Transport and Road dealt with the problems with the track in Issyk-Kul, again steps on the same rake.

 

Tender for construction of road was announced in December 2015. In mid-June 2016, 16 applications opened. It is reported that the six don\'t meet the requirements, one company is included in the black list of the ADB. Now the applications of nine candidates are being studied. Here some interesting facts are found out.

 

The lowest price of $70 million at an estimated project cost of almost $100 million was suggested by China Railway №5 Engineering Group Co. LTD. Most likely, it will be chosen as the winner.

 

Officials simply turn a deaf ear to the voice of reason, which calls not to fall for suspiciously low price. Even so, let\'s try to refresh the memory and knowledge of high officials. China Railway №5 Engineering Group Co. LTD. is affiliated company of China Railway Group, which holds a significant share of the Chinese construction market and is involved in many large-scale infrastructure projects, mainly in South-East Asia and Africa.

 

It is known that in 2009 it tried to enter the new market of the European Union. Then its subsidiary with two Chinese partners won the tender for the construction of parts of two highways in Poland. The project started well in terms of development and preparation. China Railway Group showed good technical grip, but the work stranded in the later stages because of poor management within tight regulatory framework. As a result, the project failed, China Railway Group was replaced by another contractor.

 

There is another interesting fact. In 2012, the Council on Ethics in Norway conducted a study of the companies that invest the country\'s pension fund. In 2014, it recommended to the Ministry of Finance to exclude China Railway Group from the list of companies invested by the Pension Fund, due to corruption.

 

\"According to the report of the Council on Ethics and data on domestic legal solutions in the Chinese Communist Party of China, published in the media, it is clear that China Railway Group is involved in corruption schemes. It and one of its subsidiaries apparently bribed public officials to secure contracts for the construction of railways and housing. This reflected in the two legal decisions of PRC, concerning bribes,\" the letter said.

 

Doesn\'t the tender commission really know such unpleasant details? Or officials simply don\'t want to see what lies on the surface? Isn\'t the cost of the project, which is 30 percent below the estimate one, alarming? It seems not.

 

However, experts believe that the low cost of the project will lead to the fact that it won\'t be finished in time. Such opinion has the advisor to road construction - a Spanish company Eptisa. Experts believe that additional costs may arise in the course of work.

 

For example, according to the project, asphalt plant and crushing station are situated at about 45 km from the main road. This means that the cost of asphalt and the base will increase due to transportation. Let\'s not forget that in the analysis it turned out that the real prices of construction materials and declared by candidate with the least amount are significantly different. As a result, the country can get the unfinished road and requirements to pay a penalty for failing to make work on time. Don\'t forget that the funds allocated by the Asian Development Bank - for the most part are borrowed. That is failed construction and discontent of the population will fall an additional burden to the treasury. Stunning prospect, isn\'t it?

 

The Ministry of Transport and Roads was formed recently on the basis of Ministry of Transport and Communications. This was done to ensure that the agency is working effectively, particularly in infrastructure projects. However, even a superficial glance at the problem projects shows that the officials of the Ministry hadn\'t draw conclusions from the mistakes. A regular meeting of the tender commission on selection of a contractor for the construction of the Bishkek - Kara-Balta will be held today. In previous meeting opinions of the commission members were divided. Not everyone is ready to neglect quality in exchange for a lower price. But will they be able to defend their opinions and the right of the country not to make mistakes anymore in the construction of large objects?

 

 

CONTACTS

SOCIAL MEDIA

TelegramYouTubeWhatsAppFacebookInstagram

© News Agency «24.kg» - News of Kyrgyzstan. All rights reserved. All information posted on this website is intended for personal use only and may not be distributed without the written permission of NA «24.kg». The editorial team is not responsible for the content of reprinted materials and statements of individuals. +18