Sites.kg. The reverse side of blocking
The international community has to act more sharply against terrorism and extremism. Domestic parliamentary body also did the same and before leaving for summer vacation took a number of radical measures relating to national security. The deputies, in particular, voted on the third reading of a draft law on deprivation of citizenship of those who went to the zone of armed conflict, and approved blocking of websites, distributing ideas of terrorism and extremism.
When the reaction is not discussed, but taken for granted
Almost every day the world faces terrorist attacks, which kill hundreds of people and injure dozens. Leaders of countries where terrorists kill civilians, take certain measures: some use public censure and give an order of catching criminals, and someone decides to immediately execute extremists already caught for similar crimes committed earlier. On July 3 - in the midst of the Muslim holy month of Ramadan - the Iraqi capital was hit by explosions near a restaurant in the central Karada district and near the market in the northern region of Al-Shaab.
According to media reports, 213 people were killed and hundreds injured. Terrorist group Islamic State took the responsibility for that. Iraq declared three days of mourning. The reaction of the country\'s leadership to the tragedy that took the lives of civilians was instantaneous. Iraqi Prime Minister Haider al-Abadi instructed the Ministry of Justice to immediately enforce all the death sentences of convicted terrorists. The press didn\'t widely discuss question of the correctness of this decision. The Iraqi leadership has set a world community to the fact that evil must be punished.
Earlier, the attack occurred in the international airport Ataturk in Istanbul and near to the metro station. According to official statistics, the explosions killed 44 people and injured 239. Among the victims there is Kyrgyzstani. Turkish President Recep Tayyip Erdogan said that among the suspects in the attack there are natives not only of Kyrgyzstan, but Tajikistan, as well as the Republic of Dagestan (Russian Federation). He noted that 30 people were detained.
In Kyrgyzstan, fortunately, such large-scale attacks didn\'t happen. Largely thanks to the watchful and careful work of intelligence agencies. No matter how many claims the civil society activists laid to cloak and dagger agents, they work well.
Making fuss not in vain
Deputies throughout the first session not in vain expressed concern about the frequent cases of departure of our compatriots in Syria. Initially, the noise was raised in the media. MP from Onuguu-Progress faction Tazabek Ikramov was the first to propose to attract those who were in Syria to participate in a TV discussion, so that they can tell everybody what to expect. \"Let\'s draw for TV appearance and representatives of muftiat, the Ulema Council, in order they explain to the audience that one shall resist recruitment,\" Tazabek Ikramov stated.
Meanwhile, MIA didn\'t have much report about those who left Kyrgyzstan in search of better life and earnings. The situation reached a critical point after the domestic press reported on one hundred children exported to the war zone. According to security officials, the parents of minors took the children there. Then there were reports that the National Security Committee stopped several illegal attempts of Kyrgyzstanis to leave to a war zone.
After this information to the public were revealed other messages that those who have been in Syria are being prosecuted. For example, a woman, who was in Damascus with her husband and children, has received two years of probation. The mother of three minors accused of complicity in the crime, aiding and abetting and terrorism.
All this time the parliamentary body was discussing a bill, aimed at depriving the Kyrgyz citizenship, those who left the war zone. This document didn\'t cause special criticism in the House. According to the innovations, the citizenship is lost in case of \"participation of Kyrgyz citizen in armed conflicts or military actions on the territory of a foreign state or outside the KR training, aimed at gaining skills of a terrorist or extremist crimes.\"
Deputies approved and the amendments to the Code of Administrative Liability, the Criminal Code and the Criminal Executive Code, according to which citizens of Kyrgyzstan will face responsible for the export of minors in the area of armed conflict. Code of Administrative Responsibility will be added another article, concerning public glorification or praise of terrorist or extremist activities. Lawmakers think that this rule will identify those conducting covert propaganda of extremism and terrorism in the guise of the right to freedom of expression, freedom of speech and religion, and to carry out preventive work with them.
Not the right blocking
Lawmakers approved in the third reading the document on blocking sites that distribute ideas of terrorism and extremism. It was initiated by the government, having proposed to supplement the Civil Procedure Code with a new article, according to which the court decision on the recognition of information materials extremist, calling for terrorist activities or justifying its necessity, will come into effect immediately after the announcement.
The court must consider the claim within three days, and if an additional check is needed - in five days. The statement can be viewed without the participation of the defendants in the case of their absence. It allows the temporary restriction of access to information materials for taking measures to secure the claim.
In her turn, the head of the Public Foundation \"Civil Initiative on Internet Policy\" Tattu Mambetalieva wondered why the deputies were silent earlier, when the blocking of sites was behind the scenes and without judgment. The expert believes that the bill aims not just to legalize, but to make transparent and open the process of Internet filtering, to all data about what kind of content is blocked and why, were published. \"This is the response of civil society, Internet service providers and telecom operators to offer of law enforcement agencies to establish instructions on extrajudicial form of blocking, without publication of a list of prohibited materials, for unknown and unclear procedures, without charge or trial,\" Tattu Mambetalieva said.
The expert added that the bill was \"born\" in the course of long discussions between civil society, business, law enforcement bodies and the government. \"We must understand that blocking took place, takes place and will take place because there are many threats to information security. But it is important that the processes to be legal, transparent and clear, solely on the basis of a judicial act, as international standards require. One can\'t demand from the telecom operator to limit the information without a court decision, recognizing this information illegal,\" she concluded.
We wanted the best, but it turned out as always
Deputies\' decision to block sites for the dissemination of extremist information is possibly correct. But considering that our government acts on a principle \"wanted the best, but it turned out as always,\" there is no guarantee that the law doesn\'t become a weapon against unwanted Internet resources.
In 2014, the portal \"Kloop\" in Kazakhstan was blocked for the distribution of the video of the children, trainees in the camp of the Islamic state. Kloop took the video from the website of the British newspaper Daily Mail. They emphasized that the movie was used \"for illustrative purposes.\" The public fund Kloop then said that it regrets about the decision of the authorities of Kazakhstan to block their site, and urged the Kyrgyz authorities not to succumb to the pressure of the neighboring state, but to protect its journalists.
The Ministry of Internal Affairs of Kyrgyzstan responded to the step of the Kazakh colleagues and handed over the material for the study of the Prosecutor General\'s Office. This wasn\'t about \"freezing\" Kloop in Kyrgyzstan. Experts also note that with the adoption of the draft law the story may repeat itself, and any site, not favorite to high-ranking officials, will be liquidated without judicial order.
\"What exactly to be considered as extremist activity? Let\' take the sensational example with the portal Kloop: the training of children in the military camp of the banned terrorist organization or distribute the video of it? I don\'t see the fact of distributing, for example. Kloop was doing its job. By placing the clip on the portal, journalists signaled that underage citizens of Kazakhstan pass basic training. They didn\'t call the children to study military affairs,\" the lawyer Nurbek Toktakunov said.
Other analysts believe that the restriction of such information doesn\'t solve the problem, as if to suppress such information, the effect can be reversed. And then, who will assess the content of a publication on the subject, if it has a manifestation of extremism or calls or an ordinary information message?
And where to find specialists?
The Ministry of Internal Affairs and National Security Committee assured that they have trained specialists. But what about the statements of employees of the State Commission for Religious Affairs that on the \"island of democracy\" has a shortage of experts-theologians? In the entire country there are only four. Homegrown, couch-based experts are eliminated. Content of information tapes is varied and only a media expert can assess a particular material, but to claim if is valid or not, whether it contains extremism - the prerogative of the court. That is why experts believe that the law will be a tool in the fight against the scandalous information portals.
Attempts of officials and parliamentarians in ensuring the security of the country are welcomed, but first it is necessary to resolve the issue with personnel. There is no personnel and is not expected to appear. And this law will become the sword of Damocles over all domestic online media. Although the deputies, who reported that they took 157 bills for their first session, are unlikely to care about it.