Property.kg: trash or treasure?
State is a bad owner and manager. This truth Kyrgyzstan has learned long ago. During the years of independence, almost all state-owned companies have become bankrupt. But there was a time when the factories brought good income to the state treasury. Why once invaluable economic treasure has become a useless trash?
Broken record
Everybody said about the fact that not everything is smoothly in the Kingdom of the State Property Management Fund. But the problem still remains topical. Most recently, deputies touched upon the \"hobbyhorse\". It is not difficult to guess what verdict they made. In fairness it must be said that both sides have the truth in the words. But first things first.
In recent months deputies have taken hard to learn all that is connected with state property. First, Kyrgyzstan fraction almost at full strength visited once forgotten industrial giants, and last week Respublika - Ata Jurt interested in the state of nationalized objects. However, not the head of the State Property Management Fund had to respond to the criticism of deputies, but his deputy Azamatbek Abdybekov. Naturally, there deputies pointed it out to him.
Recall, Almazbek Kadyrkulov voluntarily resigned. However, he denied that he made such a decision, having been offended by the deputies.
The Deputy Head of the Find, of course, couldn\'t say something new. The situation in the department doesn\'t change from year to year. The program for the effective management and administration of nationalized property includes 47 objects. At least 25 of them are included in the list of state property and 22 - in the privatization program. About 15 were transferred from state objects to operational management, two are still in the state ownership, two - are run by the plenipotentiary representation in Issyk-Kul region and six - arein the management of the State Property Management Fund. The majority of nationalized facilities today are administered by the state, they don\'t bring income, but a lot of funds are spent on their maintenance. Deputies didn\'t miss the opportunity to point out errors of the Fund once again.
\"If Almazbek Kadyrkulov resigned, he thereby accepts that couldn\'t cope with the responsibilities. I believe that his deputies should resign together with the head of the Fund. You can\'t answer a single question. Your answers are unprofessional. Free up seats. Let those who have the political will and knowledge of the market to come. It is necessary to finally make an inventory of the property and sell something that is not profitable,\" Omurbek Babanov was indignant.
Useless lumber
Deputies are often accused that they require from the officials too much. But the state property situation case is still different. Deputies, many of whom are former businessmen, simply don\'t understand how to keep negative assets on the balance.
Today, six from the nationalized objects were privatized at 180, 227.7 million soms. Two were sold at bankruptcy (\"Bishkek Distillery\" JSC and \"Zalkar Bank\" JSC) at 263 million soms. At the same time, the money were spent on payment of accounts payable. The process of privatization is suspended at nine sites now due to decisions taken by the President, the Parliament and the Government of the Kyrgyz Republic, as well as due to the presence of judicial and investigative proceedings. Another four objects are in sale procedure.
\"As of today, facilities on the land in the territory of Tash-Dobon rural administration of Alamudun region, Chui region (\"SK Ideal House\" LLC), an unfinished three-storey building of the guest house with an attic, 100 percent of the shares of Alfa Telecom CJSC are put up for auction now. All auctions are declared invalid due to lack of applications. Also, the work on assessing 98.46 percent stake in Transnational Corporation \"Dastan\" JSC is being carried out,\" Azamatbek Abdybekov announced the sad results.
As for profit. Among the nationalized objects there is none which would bring tangible benefits to the state. Maybe Alfa Telecom CJSC. And the government decided to sell it because there are no funds for development of the company. However, the competition is declared invalid. There were no volunteers to buy assets. Don\'t forget that many of today\'s auctions are questionable. The government earned far less than it could.
For example, Bishkek distillery was sold, already being a bankrupt, for 66 million soms. The owner received a huge area in the center of Bishkek. Another controversial auction - sell of \"Petrol Group.\" Private person bought the bankrupt network of filling stations for 137 million soms, and then it was bought by a large Russian company \"Rosneft\" - for $40 million. Now the case is under investigation. Participants of the transaction are suspected of collusion.
Unprofitable tourism
The privatized boarding houses were also mentioned. It would seem that they shall bring profits to the treasury. But no. The state can\'t benefit from this property. Or doesn\'t want to? For example, resort \"Dostuk\" doesn\'t fit into the overall picture of pension earnings. The state budget spends millions soms for the staff maintenance, but the resort is unprofitable. Strange, isn\'t it? Deputies rightly resented that no prudent owner would keep a similar institution on his balance sheet.
Another recent example. The State Property Management Fund proposed to give almost all \"Solnyshko\" resort area of 11 hectares with 41 objects to the ownership of the National Olympic Committee. The International Olympic Committee proposed to build there a large sports complex. It was planned to invest about $30 million in the facility. However, parliament suspended the process, and didn\'t make a final decision.
Deputies advocated that all nationalized property is to be sold. They said, there is no sense to hand over these objects to ministries and agencies. Government agencies have no money to keep them at the appropriate level. And since there are no finance, then one shouldn\'t contrive a story with own boarding for each structure. The idea, of course, is good, but it\'s not the fact that after the sale the same State Property Management Fund won\'t be criticized.
Legacy of the past
Another stumbling block in relations between the State Property Management Fund and deputies - idle Soviet-era industries. The most striking examples - \"Bishkek Machine Building Plant\" and \"Dastan\" TNC. The state can\'t upload them to the full power. Both companies produce very specific products to find them worthy customers and markets.
\"Today, \"Dastan\" is unprofitable plant. Its markets - Russia and India. But still there were no orders from buyers. Negotiations to restart production are underway,\" Azamatbek Abdybekov admitted.
By the way, in a similar situation today is \"Kaindy cable plant.\" In Soviet times, it supplied all the products to allied countries, but fails to survive in the conditions of an independent capitalism. It\'s not that goods are bad. Not at all. It meets the quality standards. But cheaper analogues don\'t allow it to enter the markets.
A lot of examples can be given. Most of the mills and factories of the Soviet past have turned into the burden of the state long time ago. It\'s kind of a suitcase without a handle - hard to bear, but pity to throw. One tries to launch them for many years with the help of foreign investment. Recently, the Ministry of Economy submitted a list of 44 companies which the state is ready to give to investors for the development. Still there is no wishing to invest in idle companies.
Corruption - everywhere
Management of the State Property Fund has become a bargaining chip for Parliament long ago. There are a lot of problems in the office, but not much to boast of. Even the next to nothing success that take place there, are easy to challenge. Given the will. Fund activity has recently been studied by the working group of the Council of Defense. Result - it was recommended to develop a comprehensive program for the management of state property. The phrase bore to death over the last few years. Trying to gather together all the assets of the country for a long time. But it is still unclear what the country really owns and how useful is it. If you add the risk of corruption, the picture is sad.
\"Previously, members of the expert group identified 8 corruption zones and 24 corruption risks in the fund system. The risks of corruption are associated with the privatization of state property, the transfer of state property into municipal ownership, the financial activities of the state joint-stock companies, the implementation of the right to use the state property, nationalization. The Fund was recommended the development of a comprehensive property management strategy to improve the privatization procedure, introduce an automated information system for accounting of state property, to develop an effective system of internal financial control over the state joint-stock companies,\" the Defense Council noted.
Now the agency is actually left without leadership. Almazbek Kadyrkulov is on sick leave, his letter of resignation hasn\'t been signed yet. Recent tenders for the sale of state property were not held.
If the leadership of the State Property Fund still be replaced, the new authorities will have to investigate all the features of the domestic production management, and only then think what to do. And the time, needed to revive the idle enterprises for the benefit of the economy, is rapidly running out. Just as time destroys the once huge production capacities. Skylight in this vicious circle is not seen yet.