Currency.kg: Cards, money, terminal
Kyrgyz authorities are trying to switch the country to the cashless payments. The idea is good. Increasing the share of non-cash payments it\'s possible to bring business out of the shadows, which is extremely important for the poor budget. Such a system will also spend on printing of the money. There is still the need to move with the times. However, in the end, all this can turn into additional costs and problems for ordinary people.
House of cards
The number of bank cards in Kyrgyzstan is growing every year. At the end of 2015, services on issue and acquiring (service) of payment cards were provided by 22 out of 25 banks. At least 13 banks of them were issuers and acquiresr of cards of the international payment systems, and 18- of the national \"Elcard\" system.
Totally, there are 1, 198.5 million cards in circulation. Compared with the third quarter of 2015, their number has increased by 7.2 percent, as compared with 2014 - by 31.9. At the same time, most of the credit cards refer to the international systems: 891,176, or 74.4 percent. The leading positions are taken by the Russian \"Golden Crown\" (477,180, or 39.8 percent) and the Visa system (391,976 cards, or 32.7 percent). A small share of the market is occupied by China Union Pay International (11,559 cards, or 1 percent) and the Master Card (10,461 card, or 0.9 percent). One can use the services of Visa and MasterCard international payment systems with the help of 419 ATMs and 2,680 terminals. \"Golden Crown\" has 363 ATMs and 1,710 terminals.
Holders of \"Elcard\" national payment system cards are 307,332 Kyrgyzstanis (25.6 percent of the total number of bank cards). Note, its services are used by mainly government employees and pensioners. At the same time, the national payment system has 454 ATMs and 1,664 terminals.
In general, bank payment cards in 2015 were serviced by 1,236 ATMs and 6,054 terminals, installed in the country. Compared to the beginning of the year, the growth in ATMs number amounted to 23.8 percent (238 units) and terminals - 29.5 percent (1,379). Indicators are not surprising. To increase the share of non-cash payments, the state released the banks from VAT on imports of banking equipment. In return, they had to install ATMs and terminals throughout the country. The state \"RSK Bank\" and \"Aiyl Bank\" are leading so far.
Dynamics of the volume and number of transactions with the use of payment cards at the end of 2015 is estimated at 29, 16.9 billion soms. Compared with 2014, there is decline by 0.5 percent. However, don\'t celebrate just yet. As before, the main share of card transactions is accounted for cashing of funds - 27, 965 billion soms, which accounted for 96.4 percent of all transactions.
Unfriendly terminals
While the authorities of the country dream of a cashless future, Kyrgyz business experiences all the \"charms\" of such calculations. And it once again convinced that today \"cash\" is more appropriate. Why? The answer is simple: too high service fees when using POS-terminals.
The lowest fee - 0.8-2 percent - is taken from a customer when the POS-terminal and a plastic card are of one bank. But further it is much more expensive. At least 1.8 to 2.5 percent is the service fee in payment by a card of one bank through terminal of other. This explains the presence of a number of POS-terminals in major retail chains and other popular places. In this case, the fee amount can be revised for businesses whose turnover is quite high.
The country\'s commercial banks explain that services on the installation of POS-terminals for entrepreneurs are absolutely free. To do this, you must register in the Ministry of Justice and open a checking account. Maximum term of installation of a POS-terminal is five days.
If to analyze the POS-terminals market of the country, it turns out that the leader today is Demir Bank. The fee for \"its\" cards and \"Elcard\" system - 1.5 percent, for the third-party bank card - 1.8-2.5 percent.
Service fee of Commercial Bank \"Kyrgyzstan,\" which ranks second in the number of terminals, comprises 1-2 percent. The higher the number of customers in an institution, where the terminal is installed, the lower can be a percentage of the fee. In KICB bank, the third in the country in the number of POS-terminals, for holders of \"its\" card the fee is 2 percent, third-party - 2.5. \"RSK Bank\" when paying through \"its\" card takes 0.8 percent, from payment systems \"Elcard\" and \"Golden Crown\" - 1.2, from other banks\' cards - already 1.8 percent.
Now the country is actively promoting a program for mass installation of POS-terminals. Every entrepreneur, whether large, medium or small businesses, should use the achievements of progress. The local authorities are responsible for this. The levers of pressure are simple: didn\'t put the POS-terminal - no trade permit.
However, all may turn sad. The experience of neighboring countries shows that a massive shift to the POS-terminals leads to higher prices. Small and medium businesses don\'t have sufficient income to not paying attention to deductions of 2-2.5 percent from each transaction. This means that they simply raise prices for the goods in order not to ruin on a transition to non-cash payments. It turns out, ordinary Kyrgyzstanis will pay for the fight against the shadow economy of the state.
Another controversial point - how necessary such measures are today. The country is still not using cash registers everywhere, not saying about such curiosities for regions as POS-terminals...
Expensive \"cash\"
Even the government employees in the regions, who receive salary on cards, not hurry to pay with it in the store. Once the funds are transferred, the people hurry to cash. They got used to handle cash. That is to say, for reliability. And the commission for them is also additional costs.
For example, Bank \"Kyrgyzstan\" takes for cashing from \"its\" cards 0.4 percent of the amount of cards, other banks - 0.6 percent. If the client decides to take money from the card, issued by \"Kyrgyzstan\" at an ATM of another financial institution, he will give 1 percent of the amount. In this case the minimum commission is set to 150 soms.
Withdrawal of money from \"Gold Crown\" in the national currency may be free, but taking of dollars, euros and rubles id possible with the fee of 0.3, 0.5 and 0.7 percent. It will cost in the ATMs of the inner processing systemt 1 percent of the amount, regardless of currency.
Bank \"Bai-Tushum\" takes 0.4 percent when cashing from \"its\" VISA cards and 1 percent (the minimum fee is 200 soms) from \"strange\" cards. Withdrawal of money from \"Elcard\" can be a little cheaper: 0.3 percent for \"its\" cards and 0.6 percent - in the third-party ATMs.
Approximately the same system is operating in the other banks.
Between promising and performing, a man may marry his daughter?
The Government has identified an increase in the share of non-cash payments and settlements as one of the main tasks. Necessary measures have been taken. For example, instead of exemption from VAT on imports, till 2017 the banks must bring in the KR 499 ATMs, 3, 225 POS-terminals, 445 payment terminals and 70 banking kiosks that will be placed predominantly in regions of the country.
The past year has shown that the banks are ready to install in the country advances of civilization. In 2015, it imported 218 ATMs and 1,389 POS-terminals instead of 193 and 1,213. National Bank of the Kyrgyz Republic noted that the installation of the equipment and its use will contribute to the growth of the financial culture of the population, the development of retail payments market and the growth of non-cash payments and settlements.
Analysis of existing tariffs on cash withdrawal and use of POS-terminals by entrepreneurs shows that a benefit is still only a dream. Businessmen are likely to add the commission of the bank to the price of the goods. The owners of bank cards, as well as those who pay in cash will pay for the progress. The difference in fees for cash withdrawal at ATMs of different commercial financial institutions also doesn\'t inspire confidence in the public and doesn\'t add comfort. And no one wants to pay 150-250 soms fee if withdraws 200-300 soms.
The need to move to non-cash payment is really dictated by time. However, one can\'t bring and install the equipment for it and expect everybody to immediately abandon the paper money. We must convince people that it is really beneficial, safe and comfortable. So far, neither the government nor the National Bank of the Kyrgyz Republic, nor commercial banks have succeeded in this.