Timur Suleimenov: Excise duties should be harmonized in order to combat smuggling in EEU
The countries of the Eurasian Economic Union are slowly but surely coming to the creation of common for each participant rules and regulations. In the last year the state was actively working on the harmonization of excise policy. The Minister of the Eurasian Economic Commission (EEC) for Economy and Finance Timur Suleimenov told to 24.kg news agency about the process and ways to combat illegal cross-flow of goods within the Union.
- Russia introduced the excise tax on palm oil. It refers to a series of so-called excise taxes on harmful products. If Russia continues the practice of introduction of excise taxes on harmful products, considering that in the EEU all excise duties should be harmonized, will other partners in the alliance introduce them?
- One should look at the decision of the president, the Russian government from the point of view of the obligations under the WTO . Obviously, this is aimed at the health of citizens, observance of technical regulations. But, on the other hand, many disputes often arise in the WTO when protectionist principles are applied under the guise of such measures. For example, when the country doesn\'t produce anything like it itself, but introduces a high excise tax only on imports. The same palm oil is not produced here, and therefore, the excise tax would apply only to imported products. I think that our colleagues from the Russian Federation examined the issue well enough, including in terms of risk on the part of the WTO. Nonetheless, the question remains.
Will Kazakhstan or other EEU countries introduce excise, for example, on the same palm oil or soda? Tax sovereignty is included in this issue . We are not required to impose those taxes that any EEU country applies. We make harmonization of excise duties on standard products that we have: alcohol, tobacco and cars. Petroleum products, we don\'t touch, because there are a number of bilateral agreements.
- Will Russia raise an issue on introduction of excise in other countries?
It may happen. There will be the wording again that the product can be smuggled into the Russian Federation. Excise duty is paid on the country of destination. When we talk about \"white\" turnover, even if to bring palm oil from Malaysia and Indonesia to Kazakhstan, and then deliver it to Russia, all taxes will be paid on the territory of the Russian Federation in the right size. Here I don\'t see any problems. Especially if to consider that now the issue of traceability of goods is being studied. Therefore, following Russia, other EEU countries has no need to introduce such taxes. If the countries decide to introduce such excise taxes, it will be a sovereign tax decision.
- Kazakh businessmen complain that the entire wholesale market of Almaty and the southern cities is full of smuggled goods from Kyrgyzstan. In the north there are many such Russian products. How to deal with it?
- Harmonization of excise taxes - is an inevitable obligation that the EEU countries must take on by themselves. If we have open markets and the free movement of goods, we should look at the price competition of goods. We can\'t control the cost of goods, but for excise goods, where the share of the excise tax is high and the final price is largely determined by the state excise policy, it is necessary to harmonize excise duties.
Kazakhstan was the subject of criticism, when its individual entrepreneurs imported goods to Russia without paying the required VAT and excise, which caused problems for Russian businessmen. Now we are in the reverse situation, when similar products are imported from Kyrgyzstan. One can\'t say that only Kyrgyz colleagues, who sell this, are to blame. There are Kazakhstani businessmen who buy, somehow import and sell. We shouldn\'t divide into the countries and blame each other. Clearly, the ears grow on both sides.
- Will transition to the euro worsen the situation?
- We need to find a common denominator for all countries. And it is very difficult to do. It is impossible to use the Russian ruble as the currency\'s biggest economy. There are certain pseudo-political moments. It is difficult to use the currency basket because it will vary all the time and depend on the movement of currencies that are in it. Therefore it was decided to set excise rates in euro. We proceeded from the fact that we already have tariffs with the rates in this currency. There are ad valorem, which are expressed in a percentage of the cost, and there are specific - euro per kilo, the euro a piece. It is usual for us system. It doesn\'t bother anyone.
We laid one cost six months or year ago, but after our currencies depreciated, had to revise the rate of the euro. Here one needs to be extremely careful. The rate in the euro over the last year reduced due to the devaluation all the time. I urge not to worry. The excise duty rate will be derived from the amount that we are laying in their budgets in the national currency. We offer a mechanism for changing the rate at prime ministers of the Union countries. They gather together and decide if there is economic and social base. This system also provides a flexible mechanism.
- When agreement on excise duties with all the EEU countries will be reached?
- We have two agreements - separately for tobacco and alcohol. Tobacco, we almost have already agreed - on the rates and deflection factor. The only unresolved issue is the allocation of the first price category in Belarus. They have their own manufacturers as opposed to all the countries of the EEU. And on them - to support its producer - Belarus has lower excise rates. We want to remove this differentiation, because it is clear: it is a measure of protectionism. But they can penetrate into the Russian border areas. If we continue to raise excise taxes on other categories of cigarettes, then this product will can penetrate in Kazakhstan and Kyrgyzstan, because it is easily transportable and money capacious product. The stumbling block is the speed with which this first price category will link up with the first group. There are problems, but they can be solved.
- What is the situation with the establishment of common excise duties on alcohol?
As for alcohol it was easier to work on the three (Russia, Belarus, Kazakhstan), because there is a comparable level of economic development and income. We know how to negotiate with each other. In Armenia and Kyrgyzstan, the situation is somewhat more complicated, they just joined. For them it is a new process and additional commitments. Well and, accordingly, the economic situation there is somewhat more complicated. Therefore, they are afraid to increase excise rates at the same rate as Kazakhstan, Russia and Belarus, because the smuggling of cigarettes and alcohol from Tajikistan, Uzbekistan, and China can go to them. We hold consulting. We agreed that a separate meeting on this issue will be at the vice-prime minister\'s level.
- Each country of the EEU has a sufficiently powerful lobby, which somehow affects the decision-making process, including on excisable goods. How big is the influence in making decisions about raising excise taxes in the EEC decisions?
- It is clear that we don\'t take decisions on our own. This is tax policy, the tax sovereignty of each country of the Union. We tried to put them all together, harmonize and ensure equal application of the rules everywhere. All decisions are coordinated with national governments. Influence of ministries of health, tobacco companies is large. It was and is everywhere. Nevertheless, it is fiscal policy. All the factors of influence should always be taken into account, including public health. On the other hand, simply raising the excise tax, making not enough at the national level to reduce tobacco and alcohol consumption by other methods (through sports, promotion of healthy lifestyles) - an ineffective measure. Therefore a balanced approach, which the Finance Ministry or the Ministry of Economy EAEC countries have, is being implemented in the framework of the EEC.