Oktyabr Abdykaimov: Prior notification will protect Kyrgyzstan from flow of unaccounted goods
Kyrgyzstan joined the Eurasian Economic Union almost seven months ago. With all its pros, integration added problems and headaches to officials and businessmen. Mainly - due to the huge flow of contraband, that poured to us immediately after the opening of the borders. To combat this, the Tax Service came up with a new system - prior notification of export and import. However, the business reacted to the idea with hostility. The State Tax Service believes that this is in vain. The deputy chairman of the State Tax Service Oktyabr Abdykaimov told to 24.kg news agency about contraband flows and practices for combating it.
- What has changed since customs borders between Kyrgyzstan and Kazakhstan have been removed?
- For us changed the mechanism of indirect tax administration (taxes on imports - VAT and excise duty) in mutual trade with the EEU countries. Before joining the Union, the administration was made by Customs, after joining the function was handed over to us. Now there are no customs posts on the border, but that doesn\'t mean that the importers exempted from paying taxes. They must do these procedures in the State Tax Service. After the import before 20th day of the month, following the date of import, they must submit a report on indirect taxes and to pay them. In fact, importers are provided a respite from 20 to 50 days to pay taxes. The base of taxation of imported goods also changed. Previously, customs levied taxes basing on the value of the goods plus transport costs, now the VAT is calculated basing on the value of the goods specified in the invoice. After Kyrgyzstan\'s accession to the EEU, the procedure of trade and movement of goods has much simplified.
- So, the movement of goods at the border is left without control?
- Not exactly. The control at the border is carried out through the exchange of information between union countries on transported goods. It also allows managing taxes. It was assumed that border control will be replaced by the exchange of information. That is going on now. But unscrupulous taxpayers took advantage of the opening of the customs borders. The number of facts on import of goods without paperwork and reporting, a special pass border control increased. One copy a taxpayer gives to the border service, then it is submitted to us for analysis, and the second copy is kept by an entrepreneur.
- A flood of goods without registration began with the opening of borders. So, this tool doesn\'t work, right?
- When filling in tickets, individual subjects indicate unreliable data about the recipient of the goods. When the Border Guard Service gave us them, it was found that we can not process about 20 percent of them, and to find the recipients, because they simply don\'t exist. Those that are filled in correctly often understate the volume or value of the imported goods. And the number of such cases grows.
- The same flour for three soms?
- Yes exactly. The volume and cost of flour is still underestimated - the price indicated from 3 to 5 soms per kilogram, instead of the market 20-25 soms. The same with sugar. Its price in the ticket indicated at around 5 soms per kilo when it costs 45-50 soms at the market. Last raid control showed the import of timber cargo with understating volume and cost. The specified wood price was 2-2,500 soms per cubic meter, but in the market it is not less than 10,000 soms. Now one began to import large quantities of fish. For example, recently we detained a truck with trout, the price of which the entrepreneurs indicated as 15 soms, but in fact it costs 300-400. As a result, the budget doesn\'t receive taxes, unfair competition is being made for our producers and those entrepreneurs who import goods legally, with the payment of all taxes.
There is another moment. Kazakhstan joined the World Trade Organization in 2015. It was given the opportunity to import certain goods from third countries at reduced customs duties. At the same time Kazakhstan has made a commitment that these products won\'t go into the territory of other countries of the Union. Nevertheless, there are serious risks of their entry into our country. To prevent getting these goods on our domestic market, each EEU country received the right to impose protective measures.
- Kyrgyzstan has decided to introduce a procedure for prior notification of import...
- Exactly. The mechanism of prior notification, in our opinion, will help to minimize these risks. To import goods of this nomenclature in Kyrgyzstan from Kazakhstan, it is necessary to submit an invoice, which will be certified by the Kazakh tax authority. This verification will confirm that the goods haven\'t been imported at reduced duties in due time, but either produced in Kazakhstan or imported on the EEU duties. Only with such an invoice one can import goods of this nomenclature from Kazakhstan.
- As for the notification, there are a lot of negative reviews. In particular, about the timing. For small and medium-sized companies it is simply unreal to order some products one month before, because they work on the customer\'s wishes...
- Many have misunderstood the norm. Prior notification norm stated that it is to be made within 30 days before the proposed date of import. This means that the owner can receive notification during 30 days prior to import, for 15 or even 1-2 days, perhaps a few hours before the import.
- And how are you going to check the taxpayer?
- You come to the tax authorities, file a notice in triplicate. Then a tax collector will verify only two things - the presence of tax registration and the absence of debt reporting. Although the notification states that it must be issued within one working day, we were instructed to do everything more quickly. In practice, the process of registration and certification of the notification doesn\'t take more than 20 minutes, I think.
- And if a person didn\'t know that he should draw up a notice or made it for another type of product, then what?
- We are planning to organize four major positions around the clock of our employees, whose responsibilities will include the registration of notifications on-site. We will give them access to the knowledge base so that they can formalize and notarize the notification.
- Businessmen consider the notification not the best solution...
- I, frankly, haven\'t heard other suggestions to solve the problem from anyone who criticizes. What we offer will significantly reduce the flow of unaccounted import, reduce the occurrence of low volumes and the prices of imported goods. Thus, domestic producers and conscientious entrepreneurs will be in better conditions.
- For example, it will be impossible to underestimate the volume of imports. They can be simply counted. How to control the price? Businessman says, for example, that he really bought the flour at 3 soms, not 20. How will you prove the opposite?
- In prior notification an entrepreneur submits documents confirming the volume of imported goods and its price. At the stage of registration we can ask him exactly where he bought the goods at such price, and we can check. Therefore, there won\'t be such transportation of goods at a low price. Even if the price is a little higher - for example, 15 soms per kilo of flour, we agree with that. This is more real than 3 or 5 soms. We can\'t just sit and wait. If we don\'t block the flow of unaccounted importation, many sectors of the economy will simply die.
- Together with prior notification another innovation was introduced - a list of the number of items that can be moved across the border for personal use...
- Now this issue is vigorously debated. We take claims of people on certain types of goods and the amount allowed for transportation. The same cell phones, headphones, wigs and many other items. The list didn\'t come out of nowhere. The list was taken from the requirements that exist in trade with third countries. Those who go abroad are well aware of what and how much can be imported or exported. And the Customs Service didn\'t always find fault, often turned a blind eye to minor violations, knowing that the man carries goods not for trade.
- But this list has really a lot of discords.
- We don\'t argue, yes it is. It is necessary to reconsider some positions. Somewhere, perhaps, increase the number of allowed for transportation goods, and in some cases - reduce. We accept suggestions, study them and soon will make changes. Now, together with the Ministry of Economy, we are working on this issue. We can\'t completely abandon such a list. Otherwise, problems with unreported imports won\'t stop.
- But it will happen at the earliest the list is approved. What should a person do who carries as present to relatives not one, but two new cell phones?
- I don\'t think that this is a problem or a person will be very meticulously inspected. List is not for those who cross the border in private. It is for those who carry wheelbarrows of goods and argues that all of them are for personal use. But even if you meet a very responsible border guard, who would require a notification to the second phone, you can always fill it on place. You won\'t pay taxes. We will approach this objectively. For tax service a person who carries two or three cell phones, is not interesting as a source of taxation.