Batken: not by bread alone…
One of online editions reported recently that an old woman \"is guarding\" the Kyrgyz-Tajik border in Batken, who is alone in her village and actually lives there only her house not to be occupied by citizens of the neighboring country. They are ready for a lot of money, by local standards, to buy her a house or move into empty premises.
Doubtful glory
There has been said a lot about border conflicts in Batken region, creeping migration, economic backwardness of the region. The events, occurring in the youngest region of sovereign Kyrgyzstan, are being from time to time discussed by the whole republic. Alas, it is known not for its famous apricot, mountain flower Aigul or Lyailyak carpets, but rather for \"stones throwing\" contest between the residents of the border villages of the two countries or exchange of fire between the border guards.
The sad trend: the local residents slowly leave the region, and their places are gradually taken by the citizens of the neighboring country.
\"Creeping migration\"
The notorious \"creeping migration\" is not a rumor, emanated from a local resident, but quite a specific and tangible thing.
The fact that many homes in the border areas with the surrounding areas have been unofficially (it is officially forbidden by the Constitution) sold to citizens of a neighboring country was confirmed by the ex-deputy Tokon Mamytov. The government, according to him, has revealed such facts in Lyailyak (about 60 houses) and Batken (25-28 houses) districts.
The former official told that the sales reached their peak in 1990 before the collapse of the Soviet Union as well as from 1995 till 2000 and in 2005. One of the reasons for such facts, as the politician believes, were advantageous offers: neighbors gave twice more money than villagers.
To resolve this issue in 2013, the government allocated 10 million soms to buy the houses back.
As the Special Representative of the government on border delimitation Kurbanbay Iskandarov told, the back buying of previously sold homes is moving gradually, each fact requires careful checking.
\"Houses, where citizens of Tajikistan actually live, formally belong to our citizens, and the State Registration Service has not registered the sale facts,\" special representative said. According to the official, some residents in the border areas are relatives of the citizens of the neighboring country, they sell them their homes, as they offer a lot of money, but the houses officially owned by Kyrgyzstanis.
According to the representative of the government, the local authorities have been instructed to keep track of every fact of buying and selling homes and land. \"If a resident decides to sell his house or piece of land he must, in first place, inform the rural council, and the local authorities should not allow sales to foreigners,\" Kurbanbay Iskandarov told.
To this end, the plenipotentiary representative of the government in the region in May 2011 has even issued a decree On prohibition of sale, renting of houses and land plots to foreign nationals.
The regional administration has provided no specific figures on the number of returned houses, and whether all the foreigners, who settled on our land, were expelled to their territory.
It only gave a response, saying that the allocated 10 million soms have been used, and the houses have been transferred to the balance of Batken Department of Internal Affairs, border detachment and Ak-Say rural districts of the same region. Although this is questionable fact: the border guards deny that the homes were taken to balance of their detachment.
The fact that the decision of the regional administration is not implemented in full is confirmed by a dispute on February 8, 2016 in Maksat village of Lyailyak district between the border guards of the two countries caused by the Kyrgyz flag on the roof of one of the houses. According to official information of the State Border Service of Kyrgyzstan, the flag was hanging on the house of a local resident, who rent it out to citizens of Tajikistan. Apparently, the \"neighbors\" decided that our flag was hanging on the house of a citizen of their country.
Thus, the government has taken some steps to prevent \"a quiet and gradual seizure\" of our territories. Alas, the restrictive measures set out on paper are not properly implemented in life.
It\'s not about the economy
As for the economic backwardness of the region, the government pays serious attention to the creation of conditions for its development.
According to the authorized representative of the government, at least 4 out of 34 rural areas and two towns of regional importance have switched to self-financing. In 2016, it is planned to transfer two more rural areas.
To improve the social and economic infrastructure of border rural areas Suu-Bashaty, Ak-Sai, Kyshtut in 2013, there were allocated 371 million soms, which have been used in full.
There are also the projects of national importance, involving the development of unwatered areas through the construction of canals, water reservoirs.
In addition, in 2014 the region got $ 16.1 million of foreign direct investments, while the figure in Osh region amounted to $ 4.8 million, and in Naryn - $ 5 million.
The government\'s efforts, apparently, bear its fruit, because the migration analysis shows that in general, the outflow of people from the region is stable, it is not decreasing and increasing.
According to the National Statistical Committee, 884 people have left the region in 2014. And if we look at the dynamics of migration for the past 15 years, from 1999 to 2013, we will see: more than 14,000 inhabitants have left the region. That is more than 900 people leave the region annually. For comparison, during the same period more than 28,000 people have left Naryn region, the annual outflow there made up almost 2,000, which is two times more than the number of emigrants from Batken.
Coming closer to the border ...
The situation is somewhat different in some rural areas, located closer to the border. For example, Ak-Sai area had population growth. If in 2007 there were 6,133 inhabitants, in 2015 this number reached 7,500. There is a slight hitch. In 2014, the population of the rural area was 7, 833 people, that is, for the year it reduced by 333 inhabitants. And in the same year there were 32 conflicts on the Kyrgyz-Tajik border, which is two times more than in the previous year. It turns out that despite the close attention to the region\'s economy, the population of the border villages still tends to reduce.
What they have lost there
The following data indirectly, but quite clearly, show the realness of \"creeping expansion\" from our southern neighbors.
Firstly, the citizens of the neighboring country are not the Arabs from the Emirates or the Swiss, who have money to burn. The question is where ordinary villagers get the money, if they try to buy the homes of our citizens, offering two or three times more than their real market price? And even move to the region, which our citizens are leaving in fear of permanent border conflicts.
In addition, it is unclear why these people are renting homes of our citizens in the border villages. What is the sense of renting a house in backward, with constant border conflicts village where there is neither work, nor land? Hence, the natural suspicion: perhaps these people wish to settle on our territory at all costs.
But we can assume that they are moving to us for quite a different reason - because of land shortage at home.
Comparative analysis of the population and area of two neighboring regions is revealing enough.
The population of Sogd region of Tajikistan, whose residents buy homes in Kyrgyzstan, is 2.5 million people. They live on an area of 25,200 square kilometers, and the population density per square kilometer is 97.4 people, which is almost twice more than the average density rate in Tajikistan (50 people per 1 square kilometer).
The population of Batken region, the area of which is 17,000 square kilometers, was 480,700 people in 2015, which is 5 times less than the number of inhabitants in the neighboring Tajik region. At the same time, the population density in this region of the Kyrgyz Republic is 22.5 people per square kilometer, which is 4 times less than the density of population in Sogd region and even lower that the average population density in Kyrgyzstan.
Returnees will not solve the problems
That is the opinion of many experts. One argument is that, firstly, the government has no funds for their accommodation. Secondly, from 2010 till 2015 at least 2,400 people got the status of returnee in Batken region versus 1,700 in Chui region.
However, according to experts, most of the returnees use Batken region for adaptation and in the future they are moving to Jalal-Abad and Chui regions. This situation is understandable, because the state has created all the conditions for concessional obtaining of citizenship and access to social and health services. It is not about any economic support.
So, the new state program for 2016-2020 on support of the ethnic Kyrgyz returning to Ala-Too has only one line: \"Depending on capabilities of the regions to settle them in the border areas.\"
The capabilities of a subsidized region are clear without words.
Moreover, the program has no specific funding sources other than the vague \"at the expense of donor funds, budgetary funds of state agencies and at the expense of the budget funds, the use of which is not prohibited by the laws of the country.\"
The issue of settlement in this sparsely populated region of the Afghan Kyrgyz, even if hundreds of millions of soms are allocated, is impossible for a fairly simple reason: people who are accustomed to the high mountains just can not live there.
In other words, to resettle the returnees to the border areas the country needs a special program with a real and powerful financing, allowing creation of all the prerequisites for economic development.
Thus, the only way of preserving the integrity of the region is resolving the demarcation and delimitation of borders issue. As the ex-deputy Tokon Mamytov said, one should not haste in matters of borders, their solution should be approached very carefully.
Economic weakness and as a consequence - the lack of political will in matters of foreign policy for the past 25 years has not helped to improve the situation on the southern borders of Kyrgyzstan. Only thanks to the lack of population on the borders with China and Kazakhstan and serious territorial concessions we somehow managed to mark the boundaries with two large neighbors.
The situation in the south is completely different. We only have to unravel the Fergana knot, tied by the Bolsheviks in the 1920s of the last century, which was then again tangled by district and farms officials. The country failed to completely carry out the complex processes of delimitation and demarcation up to now, and it looks like we will leave it as a dubious legacy to our children.