USD87.45EUR95.90RUB1.07
24.kg

Transplantation. Second chance for life

14:05, 15 February 2016, Bishkek - 24.kg news agency
Anastasia BENGARD

Passions are running high again around organ transplantation in Kyrgyzstan. Amendments to the laws are being discussed for the fourth year in a row. Its initiator - the former MP Igor Gusarov- offered to give private clinics the right to recover, purvey and transplant organs and tissues of close relatives.

 

Who is behind the amendments?

 

In November of 2015, the Parliament adopted the law, but the President has not signed it and offered to work out its agreed version. The Ministry of Health Care agreed with the comments. But battles erupted again at a meeting of the parliamentary Committee on Social Issues, Education and Health Care. Deputy Ryskeldi Mombekov said the bill is promoted by interested persons, by a large lobby.

 

 \"It is not to say that we need the law, but we are not ready for it. Tajikistan, for example, has adopted such law in 2007, and in 2009 the government has created the National Research Center for Organ Transplantation. Only 20 percent of patients in need of transplants leave Tajikistan. This shows that they have achieved good results. As for Kyrgyzstan, the first law was adopted in 2000, 16 years have already passed, and the things aren\'t moving. There is a large number of kidnappings for the purpose of organs sale in Turkey. I fear that it may happen also in our country. I believe that the law is not just crude, but it is not necessary, otherwise people will be just kidnapped and killed for organs,\" deputy Aisuluu Mamashova said.

 

Having heard a lot of criticism, the Minister of Health Care Talantbek Batyraliev, who was so favorable to private clinics, became sad. \"I did not initiate this law and do not defend it. If you give me enough money today, I am ready to organize a modern state transplantology. If not, then support public-private partnership or at least invite investors. Medics started transplanting organs more than 50 years ago, we also had to train the transplantation specialists, but woke up only in 2000 when the patients began to go abroad. But there are no specialists so far,\" he said.

 

 \"Let them work!\"

 

The National Research Institute of Heart Surgery and Organ Transplantation has performed such operations as with the participation of foreign experts, so by its own. Are these not the specialists? \"You think so! - Talantbek Batyraliev said to me. - I guess I\'m an idealist. Let them work, I did not close them! And my vision of transplantation is quite different.\" But he did not describe it. But it is not difficult to conceive the mood of surgeons after such an assessment of their abilities by the minister, who has a priori to care about the development of national health care.

 

Meanwhile, the number of patients with transplanted organs is growing in the country. According to recent reports, there are about 170 of them, including 10 with liver transplants, the other - with kidney transplants. According to Health Care Ministry, only 15 operations have been carried out in the republic. The remaining patients were operated in foreign countries (Pakistan, Turkey and China).

 

24.kg news agency contacted with the patients, who were operated in Bishkek. Aynazik Imankulova (name changed) was operated in 2014. \"The financial situation does not allow me to go abroad. Apart of surgery cost, there are a lot of spendings on expensive drugs and tests. And I often had to order drugs in Moscow. I wish that other patients did not suffer as I did when looking for required medication. People with Transplants Association regularly has to go and ask for the drugs. The state can provide us with them only few months a year. Now I feel myself much better than at the time when I was hemodialysis- dependent. It is necessary to support the state transplantation, our doctors are talented, but it seems to me they are disappointed.  They do not feel special support from the Ministry of Health Care,\" the woman told.

 

\"Today there is a lack of nephrologists who are engaged in postoperative supervision over the patients. There is only one person for all the patients, and we need at least two or three. In addition to the operations, the patients have to travel to Turkey for medical examinations,\" Aynazik Imankulova added.

 

Take care of health from an early age

 

 Almaz (name is changed) was one of the first patients who was transplanted a kidney in Bishkek. The surgery took place in 2013 with the participation of Belarusian specialists. The young man went first to China and Russia. \"But I could not be operated there:  there was a long queue, and other problems. Organ transplantation is not appendicitis. Only one test- to check the organs for compatibility- costs up to $ 1,000. And there are also much more tests that a patient has to pass after surgery. Operation is only 20-30 percent of the problem, the remaining 70 percent- the transplant should take root. Many people think after surgery that it\'s done. No. We need to take medications lifelong, keep a diet, take regular tests, to determine the dosage of drugs. Some do not pass the tests, do not go to the hospital, not dieting, drinking alcohol, and even brag about it. They do not appreciate what they have been given a second chance. They just do not care about their own health,\" he told.

 

\"Organ transplantation topic is being actively discussed in our country. Many fear illegal transplantation. I would agree with their arguments, if we had not lived in Kyrgyzstan. Our country is small, everyone knows each other. And I can not imagine that someone was made drunk and stolen a kidney ... It would just become known, the more so, such operations are not carried out at home. As for the development of private hospitals, I think their work will not be entirely controlled by the state. We should support our medics in public hospitals in order they were sent to gain experience abroad. Whom would you have entrusted your life: someone who is theoretically prepared and practiced on animals, or someone with great practical experience? I think it is a rhetorical question. Our doctors have not much experience so far,\" Almaz told.

 

But they will require it for sure. Number of patients with chronic renal insufficiency in terminal stage is growing. There is a lack of dialysis places. Around 1,500 patients are in the queue for hemodialysis. Public hospitals have only 8 \"artificial kidney\" units and 74 dialysis machines (14 of them do not work).

 

\"A person can live maximum a week without dialysis. After the procedure a patient is simply dried out, because not only poisons but also nutrients are washed away from the blood. I saw a man died, his body could not survive it. Not a pleasant sight. At that time, when I was getting dialysis, the machines were working in two shifts, now there are three shifts already. Devices depend on electricity and water supply. What I experienced when there was no water or electricity! - Almaz says. - It is better to develop transplantology. And we still need to educate the population from the school age to take care of the health, to visit doctors. The kidneys may fail, for example, because of the complications of influenza or quinsy. I realized the price of health only after the operation. Now I strictly take care of myself. \"

 

 Laying on a shelve?

 

After the law was rejected, the head of the Ministry of Health Care decided to form a working group. \"I will study the experience of Kazakhstan, Tajikistan, why do they succeed in it, and we got stuck. The current law is not good. If it is not changed, we will not change anything in transplantology. There must be created departments, clinics, modern facilities. Carrying out an operation is simple. The most difficult thing is postoperative supervision over patients, prevention of complications, feeling early signs of organ rejection. And, unfortunately, there is too little means for development,\" Talanbek Batyraliev said.

 

\"I will continue working on the law. People can not constantly go abroad. I can be in their place one of these days. Someone says that people earn on transplantation. It is not true. Nobody can earn on this,\" Talantbek Batyraliev assured.

 

\"The health care system should not become a hostage of its own problems and unrealizable obligations to a patient. No one has repealed the principle of medicine - to save lives, reduce suffering, observing safety under the eternal motto \"do no harm\". To achieve the objectives, the doctors need a modern law on transplantation, which guarantees safety and compliance with the rights of the donor. The public should be informed about the risks. Now there is not even a law that would protect the voluntary-forced relative donation of organs. The Ministry of Health Care can not supervise over the ordinary, primitive diseases. Advertisements say about the sale and purchase of kidneys, and the police do not care! As long as the state does not provide security guarantees, there cannot be talked about medical progress at all,\" the expert of the evidence based medicine Bermet Baryktabasova believes.

CONTACTS

SOCIAL MEDIA

TelegramYouTubeWhatsAppFacebookInstagram

© News Agency «24.kg» - News of Kyrgyzstan. All rights reserved. All information posted on this website is intended for personal use only and may not be distributed without the written permission of NA «24.kg». The editorial team is not responsible for the content of reprinted materials and statements of individuals. +18