Government of the Kyrgyz Republic went to the aggravation of relations with the big foreign investor.
Interrupted conversation
The Cabinet of Ministers of Kyrgyzstan informed Centerra Company about unilateral withdrawal from the negotiations on the implementation of the Agreement on the restructuring of Kumtor project, which has been approved in January 2014. The government considered the existing agreement on implementation of the project in the current circumstances not meeting the interests of the Kyrgyz Republic.
\"Therefore, there will be initiated a new version of the project restructuring, stipulating for an increase in financial flows from the mine to the republic, complex solution of environmental protection issues and improvement of the mechanisms of corporate management at Kumtor,\" the Cabinet noted.
At the same time, according to the Prime Minister of the Kyrgyz Republic Temir Sariev, the government is still deeply interested in ensuring smooth production at the mine and hopes for reciprocal constructive steps from Centerra to reach mutually beneficial agreements that will ensure further effective implementation of Kumtor project in accordance with the best international practices, standards and requirements of the Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative.
And now blackmailing?
Experts said that the move was expected and there was nothing surprising in such a scenario. The sides, involved in the negotiations on Kumtor, have too much claims to each other. Notably, the dead-end situation is largely caused by the position of Kyrgyzstan: no concessions to the investor.
Think, for instance, of environmental charges issue. According to the Prime Minister Temir Sariev, the Kyrgyz side insisted on increase in payments from $ 310,000 to $ 3 million. But Centerra agreed to raise the charges up to one million only. Investor can be understood: the price of gold on world markets is going down few months in a row, and there is, alas, no sign of a change towards increase. And the costs of gold production at Kumtor are growing. In 2016, they will expectedly amount to more than $ 300 million.
According to the economist Asylbek Yusupov, this \"ecological blackmailing\" should be stopped. \"We will not get more from the company than we get now. Any mining activity involves damage to the environment in one amount or another. It is impossible to completely minimize it. But Kumtor is doing a lot to remedy the negative consequences of its activities. There is hardly someone else in the country who does so much - treatment facilities at the enterprise, and various projects in the region. This is about pure water, revival of the soil, and a lot of other things,\" he explains.
Stable is not bad
By the way, this has been said many times, so we will not repeat the words of experts. The government still does not listen to them. Let\'s go back to the withdrawal of Kyrgyzstan from the negotiations and consequences of this step. What should the Kyrgyz side do and what it would do? The opinions of experts and politicians on this subject vary.
According to the Member of the Board of the Kyrgyz Mining Association Valentin Bogdetsky, it would be right to give up creation of a joint venture at the stage due to the decline in gold prices on the world markets. \"Kyrgyzstan and Centerra have nothing to share amid the fall in gold prices. What variant of relations with the investor is favorable to the republic? The one that was. It is necessary to leave everything as it is,\" he believes.
Advisor to the Chairman of the Board of Kyrgyzaltyn Georgy Glukhov agrees with this view. \"We have to agree with the Canadians on the distribution of excess profits. We have to negotiate it. I would have left everything else as it is. At present, there is no excess profit because the price of gold is low. But who knows what it will be tomorrow? Excess profits may appear, so it is necessary to agree now not to change the conditions of work later on,\" he said.
Leave everything as it is means to adhere to the agreements, reached in 2009. According to them, Kyrgyzstan owns about 33 percent of Centerra shares. In accordance with this, the republic gets its considerable piece of the pie. Another question - how to manage this piece - is left without answer.
Do you have a plan?
Domestic politicians (exactly they, in the end, will make a final decision on Kumtor) have a different opinion. Some of the deputies, for example, still have denunciation of the agreement of 2009 and the subsequent nationalization of the mine on the agenda. Others realize that compromise can not be found in such a way.
\"I think that we must denounce the agreement. In this case, the Canadians will have to negotiate with us. They can file a lawsuit, of course, but we also have claims on environmental and economic issues. We can legally justify the denunciation. We have been proving the mistakes of the company for five years already. If it does not want a new agreement, we can take the field, to nationalize it,\" Dastanbek Dzhumabekov (Kyrgyzstan faction) said.
\"Nationalization is just one of the solutions to the problem. It\'s a bad way to go. Kyrgyzstan may lose large amounts of money as a result of international lawsuits. Professionals, who can offer the most optimal variant, should work there. The only thing that I can say, that the issue should be resolved and the sooner the better. Most importantly, the issue shouldn\'t be politicized but resolved on the basis of the economic interests,\" SDPK deputy Osmonbek Artykbayev told.
\"I do not know what conditions will be proposed by the government, and I can not speak for them, but it is clear: now, when the budget deficit amounts to 25 billion soms, the unilateral withdrawal from the agreement threatens with the loss of 6-8 billion soms. This is a very substantial amount. Now we are the largest shareholders of the company, and when we speak of Kumtor, we must understand that it is our company and its ineffective work means our ineffective management,\" Igor Chudinov (Bir Bol) explained.
All these is doubtful
Decision of the government of Kyrgyzstan and its solutions to the problem is still unknown. So far, the Cabinet intends to extend the work of Kumtor by its order until amendments to the Water Code, permitting strategically important for the budget enterprises to work near glaciers, will be adopted.
But what is next? Centerra is skeptical about the \"successful resolution of the issues with the Government of the Kyrgyz Republic.\" \"The company can not give assurance that the ongoing negotiations will eventually lead to a mutually acceptable solution on Kumtor project, any agreed proposals will receive the necessary approvals within the Kyrgyz and Canadian laws, and the Government and the Parliament of the republic will not take any actions which are not consistent with prior commitments,\" the company said.
This means that the Cabinet and the Prime Minister Temir Sariev will have to work hard to find a common language with the largest foreign investor in the country, because it is primarily in the interest of the country.
P.S. In 2015, Kumtor produced more than 16 tons of gold, the press service of the company reported. According to it, in 2016 there will be produced from 15 to 16.5 tons of the precious metal.