Kara -Kazyk: useless gold?
Book of the former state secretary of Kyrgyzstan Osmonakun Ibraimov The history of the Kyrgyz state tells such a story: \"the Director of Makmal gold plant was invited to the Parliament after the country has gained independence to demonstrate the first bar of gold, mined by a sovereign Kyrgyzstan. When he came to the tribune, everybody suddenly heard a strong crash. The deputies looked around, some thought that a chandelier has collapsed. It turned out, that the director dropped the bar. And then one of the deputies- elders said: a thief has sweaty hands and black thoughts; it is not a good sign.\"
In fact, the country, probably, has not a single large gold mine that would work without scandals, without confrontation with the local population and other problems. One of such fields is Kara- Kazyk in Chon-Alai district of Osh region.
What is the dispute about?
24.kg news agency received a letter from the inhabitants of the region, where they presented their vision of the problem around the gold-bearing land.
As it is known, the precious metals field on the left bank of Kok-Suu river in Chon-Alai district, which is situated at a height from 3,000 to 4,300 meters above sea level, has been explored by geologists in 1977.
Exploration and evaluation works have been carried out from 1977 till 1982. As a result, in addition to gold, there were also found silver, copper, iron, zinc, chalcopyrite, and other known only to specialists minerals among which was also arsenopyrite- a strong poison.
According to the then researches of specialists, the field turned out to be very rich in gold - 14.9 grams per ton of ore. For comparison - the figure at Kumtor is 2.8 grams.
The explored reserves of gold - 43, 599 tons, of silver - 180,105 tons, and copper - more than 38,000 tons- in short, impressive prospects for the high mountain area.
How it all began
As the residents write, in February of 2008 Interbusiness Chinese Company (now it is Kaidi Mining Investment Company) has received a license for gold, silver and copper development from the State Geology and Mineral Resources Agency.
In October of the same year, Kashka-Suu rural district issued an order on assigning the company 170 hectares of land on Levoberezhniy Kara- Kazyk and Kara-Kazyk ore body- 2 sites for 2 years.
The decision of the state bodies and local authorities has been validated by the district department of the state registration service, having registered the land plot and handed an identification code. And in 2010, the district administration decided to extend the term of land use till December 31, 2015.
Thus, the state attracted investors and created all conditions for their work. So, the country has only to wait for large amount of taxes in the budget and social security contributions. And the most important, light in the tunnel, at least theoretically, started looming for one of the most remote and backward areas of the country with very difficult climatic conditions for life.
We tried our best-you know the rest?
Alas, but the modern mining village, which was able to pull out the cattle-breeding region of the donation swamp, did not rise.
According to local activists, since foot of the investor, represented by Interbusiness company, which later became the legal successor of Kaidi LLC, entered the gold- bearing ground, violations were followed by violations.
According to them, \"lapses\" took place even at the stage of documents\' registration. For example, Chon-Alai district administration made its decision on the allocation of the land for temporary use on August 31, 2008. It was the holiday (!). The question is- what\' the rush?
In 2012, the government issued a decree dated January 12 on assigning land to Interbusiness LLC, which transformed the agricultural land into the land for industrial production. And the first gold (178.8 kilograms) the company produced in 2009. So, the LLC has been mining the precious metal illegally for three years, because without land transformation procedure the country\'s legislation permits only exploration works without mining.
The fact that the company had signed an agreement on the export of ore abroad to extract gold there also causes a lot of questions. But if the question about the construction of processing factory has been raised at the very beginning (but not three years after the start of ore mining), the state could earn serious money for the state budget. In 2009, Interbusiness company paid taxes only of 948,500 soms, the calculation was made on the basis of the extracted ore, but not the solid gold. It is easy for specialists to calculate how much taxes the mining company would pay to the budget if all 178.8 kilograms of gold have been processed here.
According to the residents, due to the fact that the gold mining company did not comply with all the rules and regulations of production, there is a threat of toxic substances getting into the river. The deposit contains arsenopyrite (mentioned above), which is 46.6 percent made of arsenic.
Besides, as residents of the area say, because of the violation of rules during construction of the tailings, pollutants went into the ground or the wind carried highly toxic substances, stored in the mine territory, throughout the district. From 2009 till 2012, they were just lying on the ground, and only under public pressure the company had to take actions. And then ... they were just covered with a material.
Not only about ecology...
Alas, but the problems of the enterprise does not end here. As activists say, in addition to environmental violations, the mining company had a number of violations in tax payments, payments to the Social Fund. Among the violations are the concealment of the actual volumes of the extracted precious metals, illegal export of ore, as well as dissemination of false information in implementation of the agreement on the development of infrastructure of the district.
For example, in EITI report (Extractive Industries Transparency Initiative - note of 24.kg news agency) for 2013, Kaidi company stated that it has paid the property tax, which, recall, goes to the local budget, in the amount of 446,300 soms. However, according to the government agencies, it has paid just 99,800 soms. In addition, EITI report for 2013 indicates that the company has paid 6.3 million soms to retain the license for subsoil use, while the state authorities provided information that the payment amounted to 1.2 million soms.
Residents refute data of the company on spending 83 million soms on development of local infrastructure in the form of asphalt laying, construction of bridges, water supply system and other projects. People claim that instead of 83 million there was actually spent only 33. Accusations of the activists base on the fact that the constructed facilities were not transferred to the balance of local authorities, there are not relevant documents on the fact.
The EITI report for 2013 says that the company has spent 377,000 soms on development of social infrastructure of the area, and in 2014 - only 25,000. The amount is very scanty compared to the declared 83 million soms.
And indeed, judging by EITI report for 2013 and 2014, Kaidi was not in a hurry to work transparently. Thus, the website had a table with 31 items, reflecting all payments of mining companies - taxes, customs, social and other payments. Out of 31 items, the report included payments of companies on 29 items, but Kaidi provided information only on eight of them in 2013 and on four - in 2014. But it should be noted that, officially, the company was not working since 2012 till December 2015.
In 2012, violations of the mining company have been widely publicized in the media and discussed at the level of the Prime Minister. The same year, Corruption Control Service of the National Security Committee initiated criminal proceedings against company\'s officials and a number of officials from the Customs, the Ministry of Finance, Ministry of Economy, the Antitrust Committee under such serious Articles as smuggling, abuse of power, negligence and embezzlement of entrusted property. The Prosecutor General\'s Office also opened the case on smuggling. However, we failed to get information from the press service of the National Security Committee about the fate of the criminal proceedings against officials and officials of the mining company.
As for the Customs, citing commercial confidentiality of companies, it did not provide information on the volume of exported ore, although these data could dispel accusations of local activists of the illegal export of unaccounted ore to China.
Version of state bodies
According to the Deputy Plenipotentiary Representative of the Government in Osh region Akhmadzhan Mahammadov, from 2009 till 2015 Kaidi company has paid to the budget 35.5 million soms in taxes. During the same period, it has made social contributions in the amount of 11.9 million soms.
According to the regional administration, the mining company is a great sponsor. So, in 2010 on the basis of an agreement between the district administration and the head of the company, the company has allocated 2.4 million soms for the district development fund. It also presented an excavator worth almost 9 million soms, built the road at a cost of 22 million soms, although the residents say that the company is talking about the road, which has been built as far back as in the Soviet era.
In short, for five years the generous hand of the company gave the district more than 53 million soms in form of charity and support to various social projects. This is despite the fact that from 2012 to December 2015 the company, as we have already mentioned, was not working.
The State Ecological and Technical Safety Inspection, which at the request of the local people checked the activity of the company in late October 2014, did not find any serious violations of sanitary rules and norms. Thus, the agency notes that the company has all the licenses and permits for Levoberezhniy and Ore body- 2 sites; tailings pond is equipped according to all the standards, air pollution is in the normal range, that it is not beyond the boundaries of the sanitary protection zone, and the company has a system that did not allow emission of pollutants into the atmosphere. The agency also has no claims on the wastes. It attributed the bulk of the wastes from production activities to the 4th class of danger - not harmful to the environment.
The state inspection has found only two minuses: the first - fertile layer of soil with the size of more than 91,000 square meters has not been preserved in the construction of the road to the mine, so the company was fined at 193,000 soms; the second - it also was fined of 30,500 soms for unloading of ore in the wrong place, that is, in Aizhan oldu area. In total, if we count on today\'s price of the exchange value of gold, it was penalized for 53.6 grams of the metal. And in fact, the company has extracted 459.6 kilograms of the yellow precious metal.
It is surprising that after some company executives and a number of high-ranking officials were prosecuted on the facts related to the company, it did not work for three years because of environmental problems. But therewith, LLC was not deprived of the license, and even was given the green light to continue the work (!).
What we have in the rest? No matter what the people from the high offices say and what rosy figures, describing the activity of foreign mining companies, they give, but the fact remains: Chon-Alai, population of which is equal to only two microdistricts of Bishkek, has always been a subsidized area. It annually receives 25 million soms from the state budget, and this is despite the fact that 11 mining companies are working on its territory as of today. That\'s about the size of it.