Kubat Rakhimov: Petty-bourgeois way of thinking of elite in Kyrgyzstan results in status of eternal grant recipient
Representatives of the leading geopolitical players - China, India, Japan and the United States recently paid their visits to Kyrgyzstan. The highest political circles of \"the island of democracy\" immediately began talking about the increased attractiveness of the country, especially after the entry into the Eurasian Economic Union (EEU).
The President Almazbek Atambayev, meeting with the Prime Minister of Japan Shinzo Abe, told that we have the most liberal tax regime and low tax burden on business along with the lowest in the region and the EEU electricity tariffs. \"Kyrgyzstan has the most liberal exchange regulations, enabling the unhindered movement of capital. Therefore, we invite Japanese businessmen and investors to actions with the following entry into the EEU market,\" the head of state said.
However, the share of Japan investments in Kyrgyzstan is only $120 million compared to $18 billion in Turkmenistan. However, an expert on infrastructure development in Central Eurasia, economist Kubat Rakhimov in an interview to 24.kg news agency offered to envy silently and refine ourselves.
-Xi Jinping, Narendra Modi, Shinzo Abe and John Kerry have visited Kyrgyzstan. What has caused such an interest in the country? Or are these the attempts to weaken Russia\'s influence?
-Central Asia again fell into the scope of basic geopolitical players. But I would not bind the visits of Shinzo Abe and John Kerry with the previous two - the President Xi Jinping and the Prime Minister of India Narendra Modi. Generally speaking, we see four tours, which took place for a short by historical standards period. Moscow does not make a tour through the region. Kremlin builds relations on the principle of direct \"chordate\" links and \"the rings\" exist on a permanent basis - these are integration associations. Within this system, there were held several events - summits of the CIS, the CSTO and the accession of Kyrgyzstan to the EEU. Thus, if we take into consideration all these factors and look at the future, we will see that just for the last year the number of contacts at the highest level has doubled or even tripled.
- It means that in terms of recent political events and the global crisis, Central Asia has even scored gains?
-Yes, we can say so. On the one hand, this attention flatters vanity of the heads of Central Asian countries, on the other - it indicates that the region is not lost. At the same time there is a serious reboot. Activity of Beijing and Moscow is increasing. Projects of China, namely the Silk Road Economic Belt, which is in fact an asymmetric response to the two previously proposed. The first one is rather amorphous but has a good starting position - the New Silk Road project, outlined by Mrs. Clinton. The second one is EEU that formed on January 1, 2015 with the foregoer in the form of the Customs Union, existing from 2010.
The Chinese presented their economic belt as a non-confrontational, and called for integration with existing projects in this area. The Silk Road fund is filled with money, which deeply impress the leaders of Central Asia. It\'s about $ 40 billion, as well as large-scale investments through new tools: Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank with a capital of $ 100 billion and two financial institutions, the contours of which are not fully defined - the bank of the SCO and BRICS bank.
- But it is unlikely that geopolitical rivals of China will cede Central Asia so simple and easy ...
- Of course, not. Though, everyone understands that China with its almost four trillion of foreign exchange reserves available is a serious and welcomed investor. At the same time, Japan and India are closer to the course taken by Washington. In this context and taking into account the factor of pressure on Russia - \"sanctions-anti-sanctions,\" Moscow has to cling close to Beijing. But this does not mean that the rivalry between them will end. That is why the visits of the Indian and Japanese Prime Ministers are not autonomous, they are the elements of a general policy stacked against Beijing and partly- Moscow. This is normal. Any \"anti\" term does not mean a great global war. In trade and economic terms, this can be regarded as effective competition and rivalry. For example: under the \"sanction-anti-sanction\" regime, the exports to Russia ... from the U.S. have increased!
Another point is the Trans-Pacific Partnership agreement. China did not get in; the key players there are the U.S. and Japan, which gives the international trade and economic organization a powerful effect. China is not there, but there\'s Vietnam. Why do I focus attention on this country? Vietnam has a powerful, dynamically developing economy and almost 90 million people. In May 2016, the country has to sign an agreement on free trade zone with the EEU. That is to say, Vietnam is here and there. It is very pragmatic.
But back to our region. Thus, if we take all aspects on Central Asia and Kyrgyzstan in particular, into consideration, we see: it is propitious moment to restart relations with all the geopolitical players.
-But we have nothing to reboot with Russia, haven\'t we? We are the members of one union...
- For the time being there is adaptation amid decreasing trade and investments. We buy in EEU goods at $ 6 billion, and sell - at $ 2 billion. And if you look at the statistics with other countries, you will see - we buy a lot, but sell almost nothing. Here we should adhere to a simple economic rule - to be friends with those who buy anything.
-How much the big economy and politics aces are interested in Kyrgyzstan?
-Not to be unfounded, let\'s look at the figures that loom on the results of the visit of Mr. Abe. That is $ 120 million to Kyrgyzstan against $ 18 billion to Turkmenistan and $ 16 billion to Uzbekistan. Why they are so interested in Ashgabat? This is, above all, about participation of Japanese companies in the grand TAPI (Turkmenistan - Afghanistan - Pakistan-India gas pipeline) project. Note, the Indian Prime Minister also mentioned it during his tour. And all this is done to neutralize China, which would successfully intercept the project separately establishing relations with Pakistan, India and Afghanistan.
But TAPI was born by the United States, and the Americans do not allow the Chinese to prioritize their own interests. The proof is Japanese investments in Turkmenistan\'s gas reserves and the future pipeline. And there is another important point- the Asian Development Bank (ADB). The United States and Japan hold its controlling interest. The bank did not let the Chinese in equal partnership and took non-constructive stance towards Russia.
If we were in 1984 and talked on this subject, I would say bluntly: ADB is a tool of imperialism. But even now I can say the same thing! So, ADB largely prepared the basis for the visits, which we are talking about, in economic terms.
- Whether Kyrgyzstan can await any preferences after all these visits?
-In the next few years Kyrgyzstan will clearly follow the footsteps of Moscow. Within the geopolitical revenge, one had to slap the West with \"wet dirty wiper\" (in the words of a Moscow political analyst) for geopolitical damage in the Ukraine, which Russia has suffered, and our country has played a role of an equalizer. The first was denunciation of the agreement with the United States dated 1993. If we look at the history of USAID relations with the third countries, we can see that few dictators in Africa and Asia, who declared themselves socialist-oriented, could afford that. Termination of the agreement is the work of external forces, an attempt to break away from the presence of a comprehensive personnel, trained by the U.S. at all levels of the government in Kyrgyzstan, and the so-called \"external control\" of international financial institutions.
-But this is the most difficult question, because everyone knows who these people trained in the United States are ...
- This is another thing. The Americans have achieved huge success because they always had stated that spent the money not on infrastructure, but \"brain and outlook reversal.\" And $ 2 billion which they have invested in our country were spent on that. Construction of the new campus of AUCA, which cost tens of millions of dollars to American taxpayers, confirms the fact. If we calculate the cost of education in Kyrgyzstan, beginning with pre-school training, we\'ll see - it is several-fold lower. That is, the struggle for the minds is of crucial importance. I think it will be followed by an asymmetrical response from China (through the Confucius Institute, and special training programs in China). The flow of students from Kyrgyzstan to Russian universities will grow. Another thing is effectiveness of this response.
-At the beginning of the conversation you mentioned that Kyrgyzstan was trapped ...
- The projects that we could offer to international investors are characterized by limited or long- term payback. Projects that are of interest to certain players are already funded by ADB or the Export-Import Bank of China. The Chinese are building roads, they have launched two refineries in a test mode. We are classical object of geopolitics, that is, we are governed. The issue of art of our foreign policy is that we have to learn generating projects that would fall into the pole of attention and would be implemented. We are purely regional economy. It is necessary to concentrate on priority top 20 projects which are really profitable and effective. But we have troubles doing it, so it is difficult to negotiate with some major players.
- What about our gold?
-Gold mining itself does not create a large numbers of jobs. Its export does not require a complex logistical scheme. If we had an industry that could produce the equipment for extraction of gold or chemicals, there would be a multiplier effect. Now there are our resources and imported equipment, machinery, chemicals, professionals. That is, the gold comes and goes. It is clear that the role of gold in the revenue part of the budget of Kyrgyzstan is high, it is akin to the oil and gas dependency. In fact we had to create an analogue of the National Welfare Fund, which would accumulate windfalls from gold. This would be a source of savings for future generations and financing of infrastructure projects.
-Good. And what about the water?
- Consequently, this sphere also requires a serious reboot. Our neighbors should pay for water. There are no other options. Of course, you can recall about Kambarata HPP-1. But it is just a gorgeous media product with the cost (virtual) of $ 3 billion! Look, now the people are throwing up their hands and saying that we can not but consider the interests of our neighbors, so the Kambarata project is not implemented. At proper time, it has been worked out to consolidate the image of Russia as an ally and \"savior\" of Kyrgyzstan. I do not mind, the role is played by 200 percent, but I would like to see a material object. But most likely, it will not be completed at all.
Now Russia is much more interested in Uzbekistan in terms of human resources and economic power. Kyrgyzstan\'s interests in water and energy balance can easily be sacrificed. We can not make ourselves known on the world market, as we have no money. The country is petty-bourgeois and it can not generate projects and has noting to offer to big investors. It is necessary to cultivate the big bourgeoisie outlook, approach the country from the perspective of a major player and transnational capitalism. We have Kisa Vorobyaninov syndrome (\"give something to the former deputy of the State Duma\"). If nobody of the strongest has helped us, we would have survived and learned earning money.
-It turns out that the loans seduce and hinder development?
-Partly. Basically, the grants and loans are local. What is the destructive role of grants? They seduce or oblige. Either you start dancing after somebody\'s pipe, or lose muscle skills, become impotent, I am sorry. One has to work to repay the loans. A banking system of a country, living at the expense of grants, is deliberately loosing. Local manufacturers also loose. Grants are linked to someone. Look at our roads. They are built by the Chinese. It would seem that everything is fine, but they use their equipment and workers and do not pay taxes. That is their money - their contractors, their money - their equipment and people. Look through the political economy of grants and you will understand how much one grant dollar destroys within the national economy! No wonder that Alexander Lukashenko got rid of all the Western grant handouts.
At this time, our neighbors work out normal, human projects - working and promising. Kazakhstan\'s nuclear industry, for example, has prospects in relations with Japan. There are already joint ventures. But we are still standing with an outstretched hand and look at Russia with a hope. Yes, due to the accession of Kyrgyzstan to the EEU, Russia took revenge for geopolitical knockout in Ukraine, and until we are pampered and fed. But this time will pass quickly. Russia also does nothing to harm itself. Russia\'s export has grown in our direction. But our exports to Russia almost did not increase! This means that they take the invested in our development money, and we need a long-term investments but not media products like Kambarata-1. This refers to investments from other sources also - it should not be grants or aid, they should not be politically motivated. Otherwise, the country will be a permanent recipient that will exacerbate the structural problems in the economy. And so it will continue till Kyrgyzstan not to rebuilt outlook at the state level, and we do not come out of the role of mental petty-bourgeois country with a high corruption and excessive ambitions.