Deputy privileges: look before you leap
No sooner had the members of Parliament of the new convocation received the cherished deputy certificates than they rushed to fulfill election campaign promises. Another Speaker is not elected, the structure of the legislature is not discussed, but they already abandon their privileges - immunity, cars and other things. But is this all so rosy in practice?
Without protection
The Social Democratic Party was the first who spoke about reduction of expenditures. The Social Democrats proposed each deputy to have one assistant (now they have two - note of 24.kg news agency), to allocate an official car to the secretariats of the factions and abandon the parliamentary immunity (proposal was voiced by ex-speaker of the 5th convocation Asylbek Zheenbekov and Isa Omurkulov - note of 24.kg news agency). Later on, some representatives of the Social Democratic Party posted in social networks, that the faction has taken a resolute decision and it abandoned the parliamentary immunity and official cars.
But some MPs expressed concern that the lack of parliamentary immunity might negatively affect the lawmakers. \"Whether the authorities will not use it to crack down the opposition?\" deputy chairperson of Bir Bol faction Cholpon Dzhakupova asked.
Ironically, individual members of the Social Democratic Party also adhere to this position. In particular, in an interview with 24.kg news agency the former head of the Committee on Ethics and Regulations of the Parliament of the 5th convocation Aynuru Altybaeva stated that \"if a deputy has no immunity, then ... roughly speaking, there can be buck-passing\". But it seems that her voice has not been heard.
Hidden hazards
Someone will object to it, saying, \"isn\'t it the people asked the deputies for, and why we are indignant again?\" But there must be a clear distinction between separate moments.
As the Public Movement for the Abolition of the Benefits and Privileges of Parliament Deputies stressed, the deputy immunity - is the norm, \"stipulated by the Constitution, which can not be changed even under the plausible pretext.\" \"We demanded that, on the one hand, it served as protection from possible political pressure on the deputies, but, on the other hand, it would not play a role of mechanism of withdrawal of unscrupulous deputies from liability for criminal offenses, including the past ones which are not covered by the statute of limitations,\" the activists stressed in a statement.
Generally, co-chairman of the movement Azamat Tynaev sees \"another possible hidden subtext\" under the attempted abolition of parliamentary immunity. \"The resolution on immunity is a constitutional norm, and its change can become, except for the total pressure on opposition MPs, a cover for passing other amendments to the Constitutional law,\" he warned.
The head of Coalition for Democracy and Civil Society Public Association Dinara Oshurakhunova at all called the initiative an attempt to \"catch parliamentary opposition on the populist bait\" by posting a statement on Facebook. \"Abandon cars and apartments if you want to look good in the eyes of the voters, but you need the immunity, while the money and power are leverage on the courts, prosecutor\'s office and the National Security Committee. If you remove the immunity, the silence would be usual for this Parliament,\" she said to MPs.
Bargain one trouble for another
Activists of for the Abolition of Benefits and Privileges of Deputies of the Parliament stress that the declaration proposed by them and signed by most parties that entered the current Parliament (all, except Onuguu Progress and the Social Democrats, which has agreed verbally- note of 24.kg news agency) includes wider range of parliamentary privileges. In particular, in addition to personal transport, the MPs have been also offered to abandon service apartments (retaining only the payment of rented housing to the deputies who do not have housing in Bishkek) and to stop using special medical treatment, health resort treatment and free public transport traveling. The last point is puzzling at all: have you ever seen a deputy, using a bus or trolleybus? But the norm is still included in the law.
But even if one of the factions is ready to give up apartments and summer holiday at the expense of the state budget, any of the newly-born members of Parliament did not even mention the main point, about which the public association says. It is about \"linking of salaries of MPs to the tenfold minimum subsistence level for Bishkek\", which civil society offers to replace by \"the officially adopted in the Kyrgyz Republic minimum wage or living wage.\" This is understandable, because, according to official figures, the largest spendings in the Parliament are exactly the on salaries of deputies, which vary from 25,000 to 80,000 soms per month.
But the MPs distract voters\' attention by the fact that they dismiss 120 drivers and the same number of assistants, retaining a consultant instead of two. Now imagine a consultant who alone is preparing for a people\'s Deputy decisions and conclusions on the draft laws, the complaints of citizens, regulates the reception of voters, sends requests to the ministries and agencies ... But if several committees are holding meetings simultaneously on different floors of the \"White House\"? In general, those who have to take on all of this, already now roll their eyes in despair ...
Although, as it became known to 24.kg news agency, along with reduction of number of assistants, there will be, possibly, increased the number of employees in the secretariats of the factions. It is planned to introduce from 5 to 15 extra posts. But what for is this fuss, if the work is more effective when a deputy may give an order to a personal consultant and not to fight for him or her with his colleagues in the faction?
Attempt №2
That is why the ex-deputy of the Parliament Omurbek Abdrakhmanov in his time promoted the bill on the optimization of financial and economic activity of the Parliament, where he offered not only to eliminate the parliamentary garage but the Administrative Department of the Parliament. This organization, according to reports, \"consumes\" almost as much as auto enterprise of the Parliament - about 90 million soms per year, although it is just a maintenance bloc, serving the Parliament.
According to Omurbek Abdrakhmanov, having reduced the Administration Department and retaining only technical positions (cleaners, repairmen), it would be possible to include them in the Parliament office. Although it is incredibly boosted - about half a billion soms are spent annually, which is only 200 million less than on the deputies themselves.
\"By the way, Chynybay Tursunbekov supported the proposal then, surprising me. However, he did not abandon Cadillac,\" Omurbek Abdrakhmanov remembered, complaining that the Chamber did not follow the example of the leader of SDPK faction - the bill was rejected.
We tried our best, you know the rest ...
Given the fact that not all the factions spoke out about the parliamentary privileges, and the structure of Parliament will be discussed, there is a hope that in discussion of the issue the people\'s deputies will be guided by common sense, pragmatism and impartiality. As the MP Zhoomart Saparbayev from Ata Meken told to 24.kg news agency, he supports the idea \"to reduce the budget for the maintenance of the Parliament, but the main thing is that it would not affect the efficiency of work.\" \"It is not a secret that the government bodies have many redundant agencies, departments, so the analysis is required to reduce them not for cuts, not for the sake of public relations, but for the sake of efficiency, mobility and budget savings,\" MP said.
The deputy from SDPK Elvira Surabaldiyeva also agrees with him. \"Of course, as an entrepreneur in the past, I am for optimization of costs, especially that many of the things that we are supposed to, I can afford myself. But here - you have to be honest and forthright to the end - there is another side of the coin. Our party, like the others, has members who came from the regions or have no car,\" explained the MP, citing the example of her colleague - a widow, the mother of five children, who lives outside the capital. Elvira Surabaldiyeva stressed that these issues require a differentiated and balanced approach.
As they say, it\'s easier to break than to make. We can only hope that the deputies will carefully examine the structure and costs of the Parliament before making a decision. The budget of the Parliament, indeed, has articles elimination of which will reduce the burden on the state budget and will not stall the work of the legislative body.