It is a well- known fact that the offender should be imprisoned. Only the law is the criterion of legitimacy of one\'s actions. And if the law is violated in respect of the offender, it should serve as an alarming signal: every crime has the guilty.
For the second week in a row the whole country is discussing the escape of prisoners from the prison No 50.
At least four officers of the State Penitentiary Service were killed in attempt to detain prisoners, escaped from the prison in Nizhniy Nooruz village, Chui region.
Heart failed
As of today, only four out of nine escapees survived.
On the day of escape on October 12 the officers without delay have detained five of them (one was injured), four others have managed to disappear.
The five have been returned to prison. But in less than ten days, one of them - Taalaibek Zhumanov- died. According to official information, the death of a prisoner was the result of an acute heart failure. The death has caused many doubts and mixed reactions. Someone thought that the fugitive was battered to death to \"pull out\" information about the escape. And there were those who supported such an attitude. \"They are the criminals, many of them were sentenced to life. Why do they have to serve and idle their time in a jail? We should ignore them, we have to return the death penalty,\" the citizens wrote in social networks.
But one more inmate- Bakyt Kenzhegulov- died the next day. \"It happened in an isolated area for sick convicts at penal colony No 47. The death was caused by cardiovascular and respiratory failure,\" the State Penitentiary Service said.
No sooner had the people recovered and thought about two questionable deaths, that other sad news came: one more prisoner, who escaped from prison No 50, Muratbek Zhumaliev, passed away. Cause of his death also raised a lot of questions. \"You don\'t say that it is a hear failure again?\"- people thought. Their guesses were correct. According to official data, the death of the offender was also caused by a cardiovascular disease, however, the report also specified, that he had a cerebral contusion and brain swelling. The question is how did he get brain injury? Was he beaten up or just accidentally hit his head so hard?
It turned out that three of the prisoners (wow, what a coincidence!) had a weak heart. Although the State Penitentiary Service has assured that the condition of all the inmates, who committed the escape, was stable.
Chill out
After three deaths in two days everybody has began to doubt the veracity of the conclusions of SPS medical unit.
Human rights activists also expressed their concerns. They took care of the rights of prisoners. \"At the moment the officers of SPS beat up all the prisoners, even those who did not commit the escape. This was reported by the prisoners and their relatives. There is a chaos and riots in the correctional institution, which is organized by the investigators and employees of the service,\" Toktaiym Umetalieva said.
Human rights activists pointed out that even if a person was in prison, no one had the right to take his or her life.
SPS is the body that executes the punishment determined by the court, but not imposes it. The service staff must act strictly according to instructions and in accordance with the law.
SPS press service reported that Zhumaliev, Kenzhegulov, Zhumanov were dangerous special offenders sentenced to life imprisonment for murder. \"During the arrest and imprisonment, they behaved themselves very aggressively and defiantly threatened to kill staff and investigators, their families. During the investigation, they attempted to attack the investigators, all the legal means of containment and restraint of the detainees have been used,\" statement says.
And what, I wonder, are the methods of restraint? Beat up to death and say that the prisoner had a heart failure?
Of course, no one says that prisoners should be cared for, nursed and patted on the head. They have committed a crime, the court found them guilty, and they should bear responsibility. The question is whether the punishment corresponds with act that they have committed?
Punitive measure
Such incidents as the escape of prisoners from jail, murder of guards and other law enforcement officials, generate a public debates on the very thorny questions: should we spend so much effort and money on the maintenance of dangerous criminals in prison or the death penalty must be returned?
- In Kyrgyzstan, if a person has committed an extremely serious crime: abused child, intentionally killed someone or committed terrorist act, he or she is simply put in prison. Then the offender is released and, as practice shows, often breaks the law again. Such people should be punished to the fullest extent of the law, and if it is not strict, it is necessary to toughen it, - citizens offer.
So far the life imprisonment is the highest penalty in our country. Humanely. So the delegated to the parliament deputies have decided.
And if we want to live in a legal state, than all, without exception, must obey the law and comply with it in respect of all citizens. If it does not suit us, then we need to amend all the documents starting from the fundamental one and ending with the interdepartmental regulations. The law enforcement officials themselves, including SPS, do not have the right to decide on the punishment.
Human rights activists, in particular, Gulshaiyr Abdirasulova noted the necessity of investigation on the death of the captured fugitives.
According to her, \"in lawful states the authorities always apprise the happened, even if it is a fugitive, even if he has violated the procedure of legislation, or, as in our situation, the guards of the prison were killed.\" \"Everything should be within the law. The law clearly regulates when to use physical force and firearms,\" Gulshaiyr Abdirasulova said.
\"And in the closed institutions the role and responsibility of the state increases significantly. Firstly because it is a closed institution, which is subordinated to the state authorities. No one can enter or exit it. The state takes responsibility for the health of the detainees. As for the death of the three escapees, the investigation should be carried out. Was it is a revenge? I do not rule that out. And such revenge is illegal. I really feel sorry for the relatives of killed SPS employees. There must be an investigation of all the facts. There should be statements about complaints during medical examination. For example, whether excessive force has been applied that could cause death,\" she stressed.
Wait for an answer
\"There are a lot of questions about the happened. How did the prisoners manage to get out? Who opened the door? I would not be surprised that all the witnesses possess any information that they can give, to say who is behind all this. I expected that the five captured escapees to tell how they were released,\" the human rights activist said.
Meanwhile, the prosecutor\'s office for supervision of legality in penal institutions together with the State Penitentiary Service will check the facts of death of three criminals who were arrested on the day of their escape from prison No 50, the press service of the main oversight body informed.
It is noted that an appropriate legal appraisal will be given to the facts following the check.
Everybody is in anticipation of what the prosecutors have to say.