USD87.45EUR95.90RUB1.07
24.kg

US government faces increasing resistance to engagement in Kyrgyzstan

20:04, 19 October 2015, Bishkek - 24.kg news agency
Anastasia BENGARD

The US government is facing increasing resistance to engagement in Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan even at the level of development programs. This is stated in the report prepared for the US Agency for International Development (USAID) by Noah Tucker, Management Systems International, published by the regional analytical network in Central Asia.

 

\"Current estimates indicate that as of January 2015 the total number of foreign fighters in the Syria/Iraq conflict exceeded 20,700 - a figure that now surpasses the Afghan-Soviet war of the 1980s and makes it the largest mobilization of foreign fighters to a Muslim-majority conflict zone since World War II. Like the Afghan conflict before it, the war in Syria and Iraq appears likely to drag on for years, and has become one of the defining issues of a generation of young Muslims in Europe, the Middle East, and the former USSR,\" the report  \"Central Asian Involvement in the Conflict in Syria and Iraq: Drivers and Responses\" says.

 

 \"For Central Asians watching the war from afar, the details of the conflict and the frequently warring factions that fight it are obscure. But for those interested in joining, it is a conflict about grand narratives that offer meaning to the lives of marginalized migrant workers in particular, who are the core target audience for recruiters. An increasing number of Central Asians are being drawn to both of these factions and their and to their goals. The states of the former USSR provide the third largest proportion of foreign fighter recruits behind Western Europe and the Middle East. Exact estimates for the number of Central Asians mobilized into the conflict very widely, and there are many incentives on the part of regional security services and their favored commentators to exaggerate the level of threat to the region.

 

Migration - primarily economic migration - may be the single most important factor for Central Asian recruiting to the Syrian conflict. All sources of available information show recruits come almost exclusively from outside the borders of the Central Asian states and that an important part of messaging and recruitment happens online. Migration and subsequent marginalization or ghettoization breaks important community bonds for the migrants and removes them from positive mitigating factors - family, community, religious leaders - that all work to prevent militant mobilization at home,\" author of the report says.

 

\"Much of the Central Asian public reaction to the rise of ISIS has been spurred by conspiracies alleged in the press and by Central Asian politicians that promote the belief that ISIS is an American \"puppet\" created to hinder the development of Muslim-majority countries. Central Asian governments frequently choose to fuel, rather than correct, these conspiracies,\" the report stresses.

 

The report mentions possible program responses of the US government and USAID: economic development and job creation efforts, training and retraining of the unemployed and returning migrants, community-building for migrants, living abroad and counter-messaging programs.

 

\"But implementing these or other programs in Central Asia and especially in Russia is a far more complex and difficult undertaking. Any USG countering violent extremism (CVE) efforts intended to address these issues would face at least three serious challenges. First, remittance-dependent governments are unlikely to adopt any measures that would have the effect of reducing out-migration. Second, even if political will exists, addressing migrant radicalization by trying to change the dynamics of labor migration would require both significant scale and fine-grained targeting. To design and implement successful programs would require a major investment of USG and other donor resources. Third, there is the challenge of a lack of Central Asian government receptivity to USG interventions. The USG faces increasing resistance to engagement in Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan, even at the development level,\" the report says.

 

\"These caveats need to inform consideration of potential USG responses, but they are not intended to support the conclusion that nothing can or should be done. In the event that USG resources (human as well as financial) are made available to address the problem of VE among Central Asian migrants, USAID and the USG more broadly should explore programming in the following four areas: economic development and improving standards of living, helping migrants build community support structures, capacity building for religious counter-messaging to VEO recruiting and community support, broadening US engagement.

 

While suspicious of civil society building, Central Asians (and their governments) remain open to programs that help with economic development, assist them in improving their public services and offer education opportunities.

 

In areas where it has become more difficult for USAID and USG to work directly, programs may encounter less political resistance when they can be publicly led by the World Bank, OSCE, the Asian Development Bank or local organization partners. While any new development programs are unlikely to be welcomed in Russia, one can find job opportunities in Turkey, which is the central conduit for recruits from Russia and has its own large population of economically marginalized ethnic Uzbek immigrants vulnerable to recruiting. It could be a good site for pilot programs of this nature that could work in partnership with pre-existing organizations.

 

 Each government should be encouraged to pursue policies that help returning fighters who want to lay down arms to re-integrate into civilian society and see them as potential allies rather than criminals to be imprisoned.\"

 

The full version of the report can be found here.

CONTACTS

SOCIAL MEDIA

TelegramYouTubeWhatsAppFacebookInstagram

© News Agency «24.kg» - News of Kyrgyzstan. All rights reserved. All information posted on this website is intended for personal use only and may not be distributed without the written permission of NA «24.kg». The editorial team is not responsible for the content of reprinted materials and statements of individuals. +18