Elections. Program maximum (Part 1)
Less than two weeks left before the parliamentary elections. Candidates are intensively giving promises. Will the statesmen remember their own words after October 4?
It turned out in practice that not all parties have finished their election programs. Some organizations posted their abridged versions or talking points on their websites. So, official website of Ar-Namys party has no election program at all. The relevant section of the site includes message to the electorate dated 2010. As the party leader Felix Kulov explained, \"they failed to update it due to difficulties with translation.\" Ata Meken website is also not updated. But the \"newcomers\" posted their programs on the most visible places. 24.kg news agency carefully studied them.
Not to mix apples and oranges
Most of the parties offer the same. There are many common phrases and the lack of specificity, particularly in the sections, dealing with \"social sphere.\"
The program of the ruling party has a section about competitive education. Social Democratic Party of Kyrgyzstan proposes to change the standards of education with emphasis on training in natural sciences and highly skilled workers. Also, emphasis should be placed, according to SDPK, on language training. It means that every school graduate should speak at least three languages: the state language, the official one and one of the world languages. If memory serves, the President Almazbek Atambayev said that he was ashamed - the senior students do not speak Kyrgyz. The Social Democrats have heard it and included \"language\" item into the program. In their speeches to the voters, candidates swear to build schools and kindergartens up to 2020 but they are erecting mosques and prayer rooms so far.
Onuguu-Progress also takes care of teachers. In its program the party, in general, offers to make education a priority of the state policy. Views of Bir Bol and Onuguu parties on a part of investing money in its development coincide: both political organizations call expenditures on education investments in the future of the state. One more similarity: Onuguu party show care for the increase of salaries to teachers, but it does not specify the reserves for this increase. The leaders of Progress party plan to reduce the number of universities and unload kindergartens, again through the construction of new ones.
In addition, Bir Bol party promises to build 10 kindergartens of a new type and 9 educational regional centers. It notes that teachers have a low salary and it is impossible to qualitatively teach the younger generation for such money. The program, however, does not mention the sources from which it is proposed to increase the salary of teachers.
Kyrgyzstan party also advocates for a decent education for the countrymen. \"Our country is in need of opening new kindergartens and other pre-school educational institutions. We will work towards finding investments for the construction and opening of new kindergartens throughout the territory of Kyrgyzstan,\" the party program states. And it is noted that \"quality textbooks, quality teaching and innovative teaching methods are the basis of quality secondary education.\"
How long has the party changed its attitude to textbooks and books? A few years ago its leaders did not consider it shameful to auction a social and culture object. Being a head of Tokmak town in March 2010, the leader of Kyrgyzstan party Kanat Isayev auctioned and sold a library on the balance of the Mayor\'s Office. There was a serious scandal. According to the head of the culture department of the town council Sabira Turusbekova, Kanatbek Isaev had no right to put up the library for auction. Now the building houses an amusement facility.
Who gives more?
Ata Meken party went even further. In the election program the party promises to \"promptly introduce electronic textbooks and teaching guides in schools to ensure Internet connection.\" There is an important point: to start introduction with schools in remote areas. The country can not provide schools even with ordinary paper textbooks. Today the schools and preschool institutions have only the Russian books.
Ar-Namys party promises teachers \"the minimum salary, amounting to 20,000 soms\" and \"to create conditions for the development of private secondary schools.\" A few days ago Deputy Prime Minister of Kyrgyzstan Valery Dil, a protege of the party, also voiced the idea on removal of article, which guarantees free education, from the Constitution. \"The state is not able to provide free education so some services were made paid. Thus, we are violating the Constitution and ask ourselves the question: \"What should we do?\" I do not see the other option except change of the article of the Constitution. About 52 percent of the budget of our country is spent on maintenance of social standards of the population. And the services, rendered in the field of health and education, do not satisfy not only our society, but also us, the government,\" the Deputy Prime Minister said. Does it mean that after the elections the Kyrgyzstanis to be completely deprived of free school education, which can hardly be called free now?! Even today, each school takes charges for a particular service, calling it \"voluntary contributions of parents.\"
Ata Zhurt Republic dedicated the whole block to education. There is inordinate concern for teachers again. Ata Zhurt Republic decided to make a trick move. The slogan about housing to all teachers through a mortgage concessional lending sounds like the yell of Lenin: \"Earth - to the peasants, factories - to the workers.\" And Ata Zhurt Republic promises free compulsory vocational education to all teachers.
How do you like our mountains?
Almost all the parties included in their programs the measures on tourism development. A lot of them speak about necessity to attract visitors not only in summer but in winter buy they do not offer any specific measures.
For example, Kyrgyzstan party states: \"Our nature is amazingly beautiful, with bright sun, deep and unique gorges, fabulous, beautiful sandy beaches, clean mountain air and mild climate.\" But it does not mention any way to attract tourists.
Onuguu Progress party did not particularly excel painting innovative methods of development of the tourism industry, and just said that \"Kyrgyzstan is the country of tourism.\" For its successful development, according to party members, we need to create a legal and institutional framework (this paragraph is repeated in tourism block twice), to protect nature and to create favorable conditions for attraction of investors, both domestic and foreign. That\'s all.
How do you do!
All the parties offer almost identical ways of reforming the health care system. For example, Bir Bol party is not satisfied with the Medical Care Insurance Fund, and it wants to reform it, retaining the principle of per capita funding.
Ata Meken party also offers to change the system of state and private health insurance, in particular, to introduce new standards for insurance on the principle of solidarity - \"the rich for the poor\", \"healthy for the sick\", \"young - for the old.\" In addition, the Socialists are for introduction of remote medical consultations and services. That is, doctors will diagnose remotely without examining the patient. How will it work - guess by yourselves.
And Republic Ata Zhurt party focuses on targeted medicine. As its program says - 12 billion soms for personal and concrete assistance to the population in health care sphere. Next is the dream of turning Kyrgyzstan into a medical center for the whole region.
Ar-Namys party also hits where it hurts- salary of medical workers, promising to raise it. The minimum salary of physicians will be at least 20,000 soms. The party promises favorable conditions for the development of private medical institutions.
Onuguu-Progress party also took care of health of the nation. The party proposes to create a \"Deposit of a young doctor.\" And the rest are common phrases, such as the development of clear rules for health care rendering, a system of television and online consultations with specialists working in any medical institution of the country. Among the other things, of course, is promotion of healthy lifestyle.
Program of SDPK has no separate section devoted to health care. The Social Democrats pay much more attention to the economy, administration, foreign policy and agriculture.
You reap what you sow
Not all parties have paid attention to agriculture as a strategic sector of the economy, despite the fact that Kyrgyzstan is considered to be an agricultural country.
SDPK devoted the entire block to this issue. The party reminded that 65 percent of \"island of democracy\" residents live in rural areas and the agricultural sector gives 30 percent of GDP. The Social Democrats call for import substitution. That is, farmers have to provide country with the key food products. They have high hopes for EEU and the removal of customs barriers. However, being the members of the Union for more than a month, the Kyrgyz people have not yet felt the delights promised by the association.
Onuguu Progress party proposes to create a center of agricultural mechanization, which will provide villagers tillage and harvesting services under a piece-rate payment. The party intends to revive the agricultural cooperatives. The idea is not new, it is discussed for years, but the farmers, who run away from the collective farms, are not much in a hurry to merge into joint households.
Republic Ata Zhurt again promises loans to farmers at 7 per cent per annum. Therewith, the state program of preferential crediting of farmers is operating in the country for years. The party seems to have decided not to bother with preparing new dishes, thinking that the voter will \"eat\" everything like it is.
But Bir Bol party, for example, believes that we need to reform the relevant agency, supervising agriculture, and offers to consider development of the agricultural sector in conjunction with the regional one. The program of the party said that the development of agriculture should be a strategic priority enshrined in the law. It is proposed to create complex of storages for fruits and vegetables in Batken, Jalal-Abad, Osh and Issyk-Kul regions - the most favorable areas and also to establish commodity exchanges. In short, it was discussed more than once at all levels. But the matter did not move further than proposals and programs, saturated with abstruse words.
(To be continued)