USD87.45EUR95.90RUB1.07
24.kg

Ishtamberdy Mine Highlights Kyrgyzstan’s Gold Dependency

14:16, 11 September 2015, Bishkek - 24.kg news agency
news agency

The Ishtamberdy gold mine operated by Chinese Full Gold Mining Joint Stock Company (JSC) will operate beginning 20 Septembe­­­r, 2015. The exploration project will serve as an export and revenue alternative to the controversial Kumtor Gold Mine operated by Canadian company Centerra Gold. While Ishtamberdy indicates stronger Kyrgyz-Chinese relations, the opening of the mine fails to diversify Kyrgyzstan\'s economy and will be impacted by protests influenced by Kyrgyz nationalism that drives decisions about Kyrgyzstan\'s mineral resources.

 

Kyrgyzstan relies on foreign investment of gold mining and exports, remittances from its migrant workers in Russia, and foreign aid from countries and institutions to keep its economy stable and to develop its institutions­­­. Mining Ishtamberdy will not solve Kyrgyzstan\'s economic problems as sporadic protests and political unrest and instability deter foreign investors and threaten existing and future operations.

 

Protests against gold mining contributes to the perception of a poor investment policy and poor governance. Kyrgyzstan is already ranked 120 according to the 2014 IMF ease of business index. Kyrgyzstan\'s investment laws are inconsistent.

 

Full Gold Mining\'s obstacles with Ishtamberdy emphasizes the Kyrgyzstan\'s history of applying extra pressure to foreign mining companies.

 

Ishtamberdy, situated in Chatkal Jalal-Abad Oblast, was scheduled for operation in the second quarter of 2013. The Kyrgyz government suspended the operating license of Full Gold Mining JSC in early February 2013 over licensing issues. Operation was to resume in early October 2013 and if operations remained suspended past 10 October 2013, Full Gold Mining would quit the project. Ishtamberdy first \"opened\" in 2011 after Full Gold Mining settled a dispute with local residents from Terek-Sak village after protests from 17-18 August, 2011.

 

The 2011 protests opposing Ishtamberdy followed Kyrgyz protest methods: blocked roads, suspended operations, followed by an inquiry into business practices. Protests are stoked by nationalism that grew in response to Centerra Gold-related incidents. Desire for Kyrgyzstan to reap the benefits of its natural resources and political dynamics in the region motivated protesters.

 

The Ishtamberdy project will ostensibly face protests as situations involving the Kyrgyz government, a foreign company, and gold will be a source of tension and mistrust. Protesters (and sometimes the government) feel that any gold mining agreement that does not include a fair cut of revenue for the Kyrgyz people is exploitative and should be challenged. Despite Centerra Gold\'s Issyk-Kul Development Fund and community projects, protesters felt Centerra Gold\'s contribution to Kyrgyzstan\'s social and economic development was inadequate.

 

Ishtamberdy will provide additional infrastructure and only increase access to Chinese markets, not developing Kyrgyzstan\'s overall markets or Kyrgyzstan\'s investment climate. According to the May 2015 U.S. Department of State report citing Kyrgyz statistics, Russian and Chinese infrastructure (not necessarily mining-related) creates little employment. Gold mining ventures hire local workers to develop the local community. Ishtamberdy was originally supposed to create 600 jobs. According to a 2012 IMF report, four national gold exploration projects were to create 3,100 jobs over a three-year period.

 

Kyrgyzstan is a severely indebted country that relies on gold, primarily from Kumtor Gold Mine, as a main form of revenue. Moreover, Kumtor contributes 7-10% of Kyrgyzstan\'s annual GDP. Kyrgyz officials wish to nationalize Kumtor mine or obtain 50 percent or more of the revenue. The Kyrgyz Government routinely changes terms of mining operations such as environmental standards and licensing to pressure companies to comply.

 

Another example of protests impacts would be the Chaarat project operated by Chaarat Gold Holdings Limited. Multiple foreign stakeholders such as Mironovskoye and Kyzil Ompul exploration assets are interested in the mining project. Targeted production of Chaarat was to begin in 2013 with the aim of being a low-cost producer. Kyrgyz K-News reported conflict at Chaarat between workers and management over disproportional representation of Kyrgyz people in the operation and employees. Protesters at Chaarat field ­­engaged in \"blocking of roads, capture techniques, beating employees of companies involved in exploration and development of mineral resources.\"

 

Declines in gold manufacturing can undercut Kyrgyzstan\'s growth dramatically. The Asian Development Bank stated that a \"16% decline in gold production at [Kumtor] cut [GDP] growth in [Kyrgyzstan] by two-thirds to 3.6% in 2014 from 10.9% in 2013.\" The volatility of gold markets is also a concern even as gold prices remain stable. Other sectors have expanded: manufacturing in Kyrgyzstan contributed 42.6% to the overall GDP of 7.1%­ and construction contributed to 8.9% of the GDP increase.

 

As Chinese stocks tumble and fluctuate and Kazakhstan\'s currency devaluation and oil woes impact the region, Kyrgyzstan faces more difficulties and benefits from the Eurasian Economic Union will remain unknown. Kyrgyzstan\'s economy requires an expansion of its service sector, debt restructuring and debt pay-offs, and increased trade. Kyrgyzstan would benefit from increased regulation because of loopholes and probable government and corporate corruption.

 

Seemingly, China is at an advantage as the two countries have stable diplomatic and economic relationships which may mitigate some protests and ongoing negotiations over gold mining contracts. Mineral rights are viewed as securing sovereignty and asserting Kyrgyz independence. Populism, which spiked after the 2005 Tulip Revolution, also influences anti-foreign business attitudes.

 

http://www.silkroadreporters.com/2015/09/10/ishtamberdy-mine-highlights-kyrgyzstans-gold-dependency/

CONTACTS

SOCIAL MEDIA

TelegramYouTubeWhatsAppFacebookInstagram

© News Agency «24.kg» - News of Kyrgyzstan. All rights reserved. All information posted on this website is intended for personal use only and may not be distributed without the written permission of NA «24.kg». The editorial team is not responsible for the content of reprinted materials and statements of individuals. +18