Corruption.kg: how to wean officials from stealing?
For many years several competent authorities in Kyrgyzstan are fighting against corruption. But can\'t boast the results. Why? Experts claim that the Kyrgyz Republic lacks regulatory framework and suggest adopting another anticorruption law.
Bribe makes official richer
Officials now and then sum up the results of fighting against corruption. Statements that the level of corruption in Kyrgyzstan is steadily declining are regularly voiced. But if you listen to the conversations of ordinary people, it draws completely different picture. Either we live in another country, or \"fighters\" try not to blacken already gray days.
It is meaningless to deny the obvious. From year to year, from day to day the corruption remains the same. Every day the media publish reports about officials, detained for taking bribes. We won\'t go far. Here are messages for the last week.
The representative of Trucking Company in the Batken region was detained red-handed while bribing. He offered 30,000 soms to employee of weight control \"Kok-Talaa\" for fare of 15 freight vehicles that violated the legislation on weight and dimensional standards.
Customs officers and the Department of Vehicle Registration and Drivers under the State Registration Service extorted money from citizens for registration of motor vehicles on the basis of forged documents of title. More than a thousand cars of different models and sizes were imported in the Kyrgyz Republic and passed customs clearance. The damage from a car ranges from $2 to $4,000.
Anti-Corruption Department of GKNB of Talas oblast revealed the facts of abuse of official position in the provision of land in the rural districts Ak-Dobo in Bakay-Ata district.
Misconduct of officials of Panfilov District Office of Agricultural Development in Chui oblast brought damage of 615,000 soms to the state.
The management and staff positions of weight and dimensional control \"Kyzyl-Adyr\" and \"Kemin\" were convicted of bribery. They provided inaccurate information about the weight and dimensions of the cargo vehicles and passed overloaded machine.
All because of conflict of interests?
The list is endless. But there are also so-called high-profile cases. Periodically in corruption scandals are complicit mayors, ministers and MPs. Cases rarely came to court and real sentences. But the fact remains. The level of corruption in Kyrgyzstan is still very high.
What to do? It\'s impossible to put up with what is happening. Otherwise, the result will be sad. Events of the last decade are the best evidence. We need to change the situation. But how? Experts believe - first we must find the cause of corruption. They almost unanimously say that our main problem - the conflict of interests between officials and the state.
\"Conflict of interest - a situation in which the personal interest of man can influence the decision. It may damage the interests of society or a company where an employee works. Conflict of interests - a situation when there is corruption motivation. Simply, the question of the possibility of using official position for benefit. Naturally, when this harms the interests of the organization or the state,\" the expert Bakytbek Satybekov said.
According to the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development, a conflict of interest remains a serious problem in the countries of Central Asia. In particular, at the highest level. One example is a situation where MPs and ministers supervise businesses and simultaneously receive state subsidies, fiscal subsidies and state orders.
\"Regulations for prevention and settlement of conflicts of interests are insufficiently developed across the country. The legislation of most of the regions has no concept of \"conflict of interest\", or it is not sufficiently clear. Existing statutory regulations on conflict of interest are usually contained in the laws on civil service or in special laws regulating the activities of specific departments. They usually define basic constraints on public service: employment of persons with criminal records, work under direct supervision of relatives, commercial activities,\" the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development reports.
What comes to mind? Yes, the same story with Gradient Company, once owned by the First Vice Prime Minister Taiyrbek Sarpashev. And there are names of the former Minister of Energy and concurrently the head of the pharmaceutical company of Osmonbek Artykbaev, the former head of the State Construction Committee and the owner of construction companies Kanybek Narbayev. The government was repeatedly accused that it is almost entirely composed of business, but the situation does not change. And corruption starts exactly from this.
No gifts and donations?
Within the years of independence domestic officials are zealously weaned of stealing from public coffers. Anti-corruption laws are constantly taken for these purposes. One of the last - new edition of the law on public procurement. It clearly says that not only companies of the officials, but also their immediate relatives can not participate in tenders. More than useful and necessary law. After all requirements of the law on civil service, which prohibits officials to do business, our statesmen have learned to easily circumvent, registering the companies to relatives.
But experts believe this innovation is not enough to avoid conflicts of interest. Almost every legal act has corruption loopholes. They pave the way for dishonest officials. That is why the country needs a single law that would become a filter for other enactments for corruption component.
This document was developed by the expert community. The experts decided to base the experience of Georgia. There once adopted a special law on conflict of interest and corruption in public service. It clearly spelled out all the cases where there is a conflict of interest and rules of conduct for officials.
\"The domestic version of the law on conflict of interest in addition to general provisions, which are similar to certain provisions of other laws, there are also innovations. The principal novelty is the presence of norms providing not only the results of fight against arising of social conflicts of interest and corruption, but also provisions aimed at preventing this phenomenon,\" initiators of the bill say.
The document prescribes the range of persons, who the bill is applied to. It also contains restrictions on acceptance of gifts, donations, use of information by public officer. There are obstacles to officials to represent individuals, legal entities and rules relating to termination of work of an official on civil service.
Method for controlling undesirable?
At the moment the bill is passing the stage of public debate. Then proponents are to convince the government and the parliament that the document is actually important and necessary. But even now experts have found mistakes in the bill that could hinder its implementation.
\"In general, promotion of the draft law on conflict of interests is seen as essential and very necessary step in combating corruption in Kyrgyzstan. Unfortunately, the bill does not provide centralization of functions for management of conflict of interest in a public body. Meanwhile, it is advisable to create a department or agency responsible for implementation of the document. Either lay the responsibility for its implementation on anti-corruption agencies,\" Bakytbek Satybekov says.
Skeptics believe that the draft law on conflict of interests, at its best, will be another document that everyone performs in his own interests. In worst - a way of authorities to get rid of unwanted. But initiators of the document still believe in miracles...