Kyrgyz state gold company considers Centerra directors ineffective
Kyrgyzstan\'s state gold company Kyrgyzaltyn, which owns 32.73% of the shares of Centerra Gold Inc., withheld its votes from the election of all director nominees other than Orozbayev, Sadyrov and Shakirov nominated by Kyrgyzaltyn. On May 8, Centerra announced that the eleven nominees listed in the management information circular for the 2015 Annual Meeting of Shareholders held earlier that day were elected as directors of Centerra.
Kyrgyzaltyn is wholly owned by the Kyrgyz government and owns 32.73% of the outstanding common shares of Centerra. Canada-based Centerra owns 100% of Kumtor gold mine in Kyrgyzstan.
Kyrgyzaltyn explained its position by the fact that according to the Company\'s financial results for 2014, there was a loss of $44.1 million. This was due to the write-off $111 million goodwill, Kyrgyzaltyn said in its press release. For comparison, in 2013 the company achieved a $157.7 million profit. Moreover, against the falling world prices for gold, Kumtor has increased the production cost per ounce from year to year, and capital costs were also significantly increasing. Kyrgyzaltyn believes this is an alarming signal, which makes one doubt the effectiveness of the company\'s management.
On December 22, 2014 the State Commission for Mineral Reserves of Kyrgyzstan approved the increase in reserves at the Kumtor gold deposit, but on February 10, 2015 Kumtor Gold Company sent a letter on changes in reserves to the Kyrgyz Geology Agency. The new Technical report stated that reserves have been reduced. According to Kyrgyzaltyn, it is the result of non-rational technical solutions and erroneous management of the Kumtor Gold Company and, accordingly, ineffective supervision of the Centerra Board.
For over two years Kyrgyzstan and Centerra have been in talks on a deal to create a 50/50 joint venture that would control the Kumtor gold mine. The Kyrgyz Government decided not to create the joint venture after the publication of Centerra\'s mining plan at the Kumtor deposit, which will significantly reduce Kyrgyzstan\'s benefits of participating in the project.
The 2015 report noted an increase in technical risk in comparison with the 2012 including newly listed risk of traffic dumps, an increase of the flow of water in the pit. Kyrgyzstan conducted its own investigation of the geotechnical and environmental situation at the mine, and it confirmed the risks listed in the technical report.
This clearly points to a gradual deterioration in the production at the mine, for which Kumtor Gold Company management and Centerra Board should be fully responsible, said Kyrgyzaltyn. Besides, Centerra management showed a lack of flexibility and desire to reach a compromise in the negotiations with the Kyrgyz side to establish a joint venture, added Kyrgyzaltyn.
The controversy over Kumtor was the main reason behind Kyrgyz Prime Minister Joomart Otorbayev\'s resignation late in April.
Solving the Kumtor issue is among economic priorities for the country, Kyrgyzstan\'s new Prime Minister Temir Sariyev said. On May 11, he held a working meeting with members of Centerra\'s Board from Kyrgyzstan Kylychbek Shakirov, Kaliynur Sadyrov and Emil Orozbaev on the results of Centerra\'s Shareholders Meeting.
At Centerra meeting, Kyrgyzaltyn, as the main shareholder of the company, officially voiced its position and abstained on the eight nominees (with the exception of those proposed by Kyrgyzaltyn). However, Kyrgyzaltyn acknowledged that most of the other Centerra shareholders took a different position and as a result all the 11 proposed candidates were elected to the Board of Directors.
Earlier this year, Kyrgyz Government proposed to change the leadership of Centerra. On behalf of the Kyrgyz Republic, the State Property Management Fund sent a letter on this issue to Centerra but later the document was withdrawn, and Kyrgyzstan lost the opportunity to change the company\'s management at the annual shareholders\' meeting.
Martin Graham and Lord Clanwilliam, whom the Kyrgyz Government proposes to include in the new Centerra Board, visited Kyrgyzstan late in April and shared their view on how to improve the performance of the Kumtor mine with Kyrgyz MPs.
Kyrgyzstan plans to propose a change of Centerra leadership at an extraordinary shareholders meeting.
http://www.timesca.com/news/15305-kyrgyz-state-gold-company-considers-centerra-directors-ineffective