USD87.45EUR96.10RUB1.06
24.kg

Deal to create Kumtor joint venture in Kyrgyzstan has failed

11:46, 10 April 2015, Bishkek - 24.kg news agency
news agency

The Kyrgyz Government and Centerra Gold Inc have not agreed on the future of the Kumtor gold project. On April 7, the Committee on Fuel and Energy Complex and Subsoil Use of the Kyrgyz Parliament found the Government\'s work on the Kumtor gold project unsatisfactory.

Kumtor, the largest gold mine in Central Asia, is located in Kyrgyzstan\'s Tien Shan mountains. Centerra owns 100% of the Kumtor gold mine through its wholly owned subsidiary Kumtor Gold Company. The Kyrgyz Republic holds 33% shares in Centerra through the state gold company KyrgyzAltyn. 

Kyrgyz Prime Minister Joomart Otorbayev said that negotiations on Kumtor with Centerra will continue, but the parties have not come to an agreement. A 50/50 joint venture is disadvantageous for the Kyrgyz side, said the Prime Minister. He is against the creation of a joint venture under the terms offered by the Canadian side.

\"It is good that a joint venture has not been created, because the recent studies have shown that the JV would be uneconomical for Kyrgyzstan,\" he said. 

The Government has decided not to create the joint venture after the publication of Centerra\'s mining plan at the Kumtor deposit, which significantly reduced its probable gold reserves.

Terms changed

On February 9, Centerra announced a decrease in Kumtor gold reserves and a new development plan for 2015-2016. On March 26, the company released a new mining plan with a decrease of 21% which will significantly reduce Kyrgyzstan\'s benefits of participating in the project. 

In turn, Kyrgyzstan demanded to change the terms of the agreement and provide payment in advance. Centerra has not accepted the offer. 

The Kyrgyz Government said that it is impossible now to sign the agreement with equal shares, as the current conditions contradict to Kyrgyzstan\'s interests.

There is also new information on the state of the mine, about significant risks that led to the revision of the work plans until 2020 including pit wall instability, the movement of the glacier, waste of rock dumps, tailings content, and drainage from the pit. This could lead to increased costs.

Unacceptable proposals 

According to Otorbayev, Centerra makes the Government unacceptable proposals on the JV creation, offering small funds for land reclamation and working through offshore companies. 

The Kyrgyz Government proposed Centerra to pay $3 million for environmental pollution but the Canadian side is ready to pay $1 million. 

Kyrgyzstan wants to increase the trust fund to $69 million while Centerra suggest $40 million. The Kyrgyz Government proposed to abolish the lease of equipment, but the Canadian side insists on payment of the lease. 

JV or nationalization?

Otorbayev also expressed a negative opinion about the nationalization of Kumtor. The gold mine cannot be nationalized because there are big risks of payment of huge money to Centerra for damages. As a result, the mine\'s importance will be diminished and foreign investment will not come. 

Earlier this year, the Ata Meken parliamentary faction initiated a bill on Kumtor\'s nationalization.

Otorbayev said he would resign if the MPs will insist on Kumtor\'s nationalization or the joint venture\'s creation. 

MPs questioned the outcome of the Government\'s negotiations with Centerra. \"We did not get a definite answer about the future of the Kumtor project, as the Government has no specific arguments against its nationalization,\" MP Ryspayev said.

As a result, the Prime Minister suggested initiating, under the Canadian law, changes to Centerra\'s Board of Directors and management. 

Background

In February 2014, the Kyrgyz Government was tasked to create a 50/50 joint venture, and it predicted large gains in 2014. The Kyrgyz parliament supported the memorandum under which Kyrgyzstan and Centerra would create a joint venture with equal stakes.

On April 1, 2015, the Advisory Council on the negotiations with Centerra to restructure the Kumtor project discussed the outcome of the Government\'s negotiations with Centerra which took place from 23 to 30 March in Bishkek, as well as the content of Kumtor\'s revised mining plan, published on March 20, 2015 on the Centerra website.

As a result, in case of creation of a 50-50 joint venture, the previously projected dividends will be reduced significantly for the Kyrgyz side. There has been an adverse change in the input data and the conditions under which the Kyrgyz Government began negotiations with Centerra in 2013, and on the basis of which the Agreement was concluded in January 18, 2014.

According to the Advisory Board, the adoption and publication of a revised plan of the Kumtor mine was \"an unpleasant surprise\", because this issue has never been discussed.

The State Agency for Geology and Mineral Resources was instructed to carry out a detailed analysis of calculations on Kumtor.

Conclusion

Centerra has not yet accepted the proposal of the Kyrgyz side to adjust the agreement to establish a joint venture and will answer not earlier than in July of this year, the Geology Agency Chairman Duishenbek Zilaliyev said. The Kyrgyz Government also needs time to check the reasons and circumstances to reduce gold reserves, he added.

What Kumtor\'s future could be? The Government opposes nationalization but the parliament supports it. Experts say that in case of Kumtor\'s nationalization Kyrgyzstan\'s shares in Centerra, arrested by the Canadian court as a result of a lost arbitration case, can be confiscated and Kyrgyzstan would lose up to 75% stake in Centerra. 

It is clear that the Government is trying to avoid taking the responsibility, while delaying the negotiations, which have lasted for three years, badly affects Kyrgyzstan\'s investment image and the country can be regarded an unreliable partner in the international market.

 

http://www.timesca.com/news/15181-deal-to-create-kumtor-joint-venture-in-kyrgyzstan-has-failed

CONTACTS

SOCIAL MEDIA

TelegramYouTubeWhatsAppFacebookInstagram

© News Agency «24.kg» - News of Kyrgyzstan. All rights reserved. All information posted on this website is intended for personal use only and may not be distributed without the written permission of NA «24.kg». The editorial team is not responsible for the content of reprinted materials and statements of individuals. +18