Kyrgyz Parliament Debates Controversial Electoral Law Changes
For any country that has undergone two revolutions within the past ten years, a parliamentary election is an important event - and Kyrgyzstan is no exception.
As the election process is looming for the next Kyrgyz Zhogorku Kenesh (Parliament), the legislative body is debating new amendments to electoral law which will seek to weed out the serious candidates and parties from the fringe elements.
Leader of the Ar-Namys faction Felix Julov is proposing to raise the electoral threshold from 7% of total voters number to 10%. Another initiative often suggested to raise the election pledge up to KGS 5 million.
Those in opposition argue that this ambitious proposal to raise the fees will make it impossible for those without money to enter parliament.
Dastan Bekeshev, a deputy in the Ar-Namys faction, says that raising the election pledge \"will lead to property discrimination and would cause the parliament to be flooded with oligarchs.\"
Other parliamentarians are saying that the amendment will help prevent the parliament from being divided and rendered ineffectual by an unsustainably high number of coalitions and parties, which often fight and disagree as well as lead to frequent changes of government, a looser control over national economic issues, as well as exposing vulnerabilities.
Political analyst Denis Berdakov says all these new proposed amendments will make the upcoming elections a difficult process.
\"These difficulties could produce instances of violence during the upcoming elections. The intention to raise an electoral threshold is driven by a desire to block parties without significant financial resources. This shouldn\'t be allowed. Elections in our country are often turned into a fight between clans and tribes instead of a fight for democratic values and development of human rights,\" he says.
Berdakov says that there are also reports that high-level officials are selling parliamentary seats in advance before the election takes place. Kyrgyz newspaper www.vzgyad.kg published an interview with MP Shirin Aitmatova who suggested that parliamentary seats should be sold for USD $500,000.
Political analyst Mars Sariyev says that while there might be such cases, unless there is evidence there\'s no need in such discussions, as they take the focus away from more important things.
Head of Kyrgyz Policy-Asia Analysis Center Elmira Nogoybaeva says that the upcoming elections will likely be followed by protest actions. She says that in the regions, where economic situation is more difficult than in the capitals, protest actions have started already.
\"We are observing a \'Leadership crisis,\' low trust in all institutions, including the parties. Both opposition and pro-government parties don\'t have much support from Kyrgyz citizens, as they have never fulfilled their promises to the people. The parties are using elections to gain resources for themselves, and they don\'t do much to improve citizens\' conditions, therefore the protests and lack of trust,\" she says.
\"The most powerful party, financially and administratively, is the presidential party SDPK. Another party, Ata -Meken, follows next with long history and a thorough party structure. However, in 2009 we saw that it\'s not necessarily about long history, and if parties don\'t offer substantial platform, they will lose,\" says Berdakov.
Naryn resident Askar Kasbaiev says he doubts things will change much in Kyrgyzstan with the new election.
\"Our deputies promise things and bash others for being corrupt and not caring for people. But once they are in power they forget their promises. Once they are in power they become corrupt themselves,\" he adds.
Changes to electoral laws may succeed in limiting new players from entering the parliament - but this lack of competition is unlikely to improve governance, let alone democratic representation.
http://www.silkroadreporters.com/2015/03/23/kyrgyz-parliament-debates-controversial-electoral-law-changes/