USD87.45EUR95.90RUB1.07
24.kg

Consumer.kg: left alone

13:37, 14 March 2015, Bishkek - 24.kg news agency
Anara MAMYTOVA

More than half a century ago, in the US Congress on March 15, John Kennedy delivered speech in which he first used the term \"consumer\". \"Consumers - all of us,\" he said. It is the largest economic layer, effecting on any public or private economic decision. And there, in Congress, four basic consumer rights were identified: on information, security, choice and the right to be heard. Later, the World Organization of Consumers Unions added another four points: the right to compensation, consumer education, basic needs and healthy environment.

 

24.kg news agency decided to ask the person, for whom defend our interests became a profession, about the fundamental rights of the consumer in Kyrgyzstan. Meet the Director of Public Association \"Kyrgyz Trans Control\" Victor Gorev.

 

- Victor Timofeevich, what is the situation with the right to information in our country?

 

- Complicated question. On paper, it is all nice and good. Like, there is the Law \"On Protection of Consumers\' Rights,\" law \"On the recovery of information\", but we had faced this problem for the first time in 2006, when filed a lawsuit on Kyrgyz Temir Zholu. At that time, the company has installed cash registers at \"Bishkek-2\" station. Of the five cash registers two were left the state, and the three given in private hands. So, the State Treasury said to people that there are no tickets, and then here, behind the glass, in a private box office one could pay 300 soms to get a ticket in any direction. Without providing any additional services, ticket sales were organized just like that. Later, by a joint effort with the antimonopoly agency, it was closed down, but then the trial began, and after five years, we have remained in the judicial field. Last summer, the District Court upheld the case without consideration to the renewal of the trial. After all, we haven\'t been able to get information on tickets, even through the Ministry of Transport.

 

Exactly the same situation is with the Ministry of Energy. Since 2013 we are dealing a case on reclamation of information about technical losses, which at that time reached 40 percent. But for now, neither the State Agency for the fuel and energy complex, nor Severelektro provided data. Soon the trial resumed in Chui oblast court on requisition of information from Severelektro JSC. We asked to indicate where and what measures the agency made, because first one needs to make measurements at sites and find where heavy losses appear, and then make calculations. But these measurements haven\'t been done, so there is simply no information.

 

- Do all government agencies have such a depressing situation?

 

- As for other agencies, such as the current State Agency for Regulation of Energy, there is a solution of the City Court, where the agency is obliged to give information. Since last November, the court decision is attached to the letter, but still blind defense - no information. For the second week we are trying to get an appointment to the Prosecutor General in order to involve them in the process.

 

- What should be done in order agencies provide information?

 

- Levers. That\'s kind of laws provide for administrative responsibility, the imposition of fines for non-enforcement, but what in practice? For example, Alamedin district court imposed a fine of three thousand soms to the management of Severelektro. No money, no information. What is 3,000 soms for the director, if the value of the case - about 100 million soms?

 

- Maybe changes at the legislative level are necessary?

 

- Penalties should be severe, and in addition to the administrative sanctions, there should be active levers in case the guidance doesn\'t execute the court decision and the laws.

 

- Did you try to appeal to the government on negligent senior officials?

 

- No, we went for the legal way - through the court. Moreover, we achieved positive results. Our trial should open the violations in the payment system and the establishment of standards of technical losses. The loss shouldn\'t be more than 5 percent, but today they comprise 12, and previously was 30 percent. That is, each month of Severelektro writes off about ten million soms for technical losses. If the manager doesn\'t give the information, it might be worth to consider it as complicity in a crime or concealment of the crime? That is why we intend to appeal to the Prosecutor General\'s Office. Let\'s see what they say.

 

- Do I understand right that when the court\'s decision is not executed, the company\'s accounts can be arrested?

 

- In Procedure Code there is the concept of \"maintenance of the claim,\" and it can be in different forms. This can be arrest, and the prohibition of some actions. Here is a definition in which the company is prohibited writing off more than 5 percent of the electricity in the technical losses before independent examination, but the department continues to write it off.

 

- You are defending not isolated cases, but the rights of consumers all over the republic?

 

- Today, trials on low-quality goods have begun at the request of a dozen people. This includes cell phones and home appliances. But starting legal proceedings, we saw a violation of the system. That time in a lawsuit was written \"protection of indefinite number of consumers.\" For instance, the case of a mobile phone, when even in the presence of the warranty card a company refuses to repair it. We have detected a problem that affects all consumers. And move on, without solving it, is useless. What is the point to solve a special case, if the problem still remains?

 

- How many people did you help and how many actions win?

 

- Few. We have cases that are lasting one and a half year, three years. The system in the KR is built so that you can sue for years. Lawyers know how to use all kinds of schemes that can delay the process, and the courts swallow it, although they have the right to make a decision. But the law is quite good, no worse than in Russia or Kazakhstan, but in the countries I listed there is a bunch of laws that have launched mechanisms for their implementation. For example, it is impossible to assign examination, quite simply impossible to continue lawsuits if they are long.

 

- By the way, at whose account the examination should be carried out?

 

- The Law \"On Protection of Consumer Rights\" says that at the seller\'s account and in Article 176 of the Civil Procedure Code - at the expense of the person who filed the petition. An old lady came to me saying that the coat she bought at her small pension, has torn apart, and where can she take money to take the examination?

 

- And what about the judicial reform, about which one writes?

 

- There is no reform, and we see and feel it on the processes. The judges have no responsibility for making unjust decisions which are taken out \"out of the blue.\" Do not like it - appeal it! Judge throws off his responsibility. And to appeal takes time - people simply give up. To be honest, I find it hard to call our activities as consumer rights protection. In fact, we have been probing the judicial system, in which there are no reforms. And in order the system start working, one needs to change the law.

 

If in Kazakhstan, Belarus and Russia the mechanisms for implementing the law are put into operation by by-laws, government regulations, we have no government regulations on this issue. A lot needs to be changed in the Code of Civil Procedure, the mechanisms should be launched. See, the government provides many services - education, health, transportation, security, energy services and so on. If the mechanism of protection of consumers\' rights has worked, as in Kazakhstan or Russia, there would be no need to hold rallies: recorded facts and restore justice in the field through judicial processes. Last year the Department of Consumer Protection was formed in Kazakhstan, not to mention Russia...

 

The State Agency for Antitrust Regulation has function to protect the rights of consumers, but the actual work is to write \"notes\", and credibility of the public agency is zero. According to our letters the competition authority officially went to check private entrepreneur, took a prescription, all as expected, but businessman just didn\'t let inspectors in. Can you imagine - not letting in the representatives of the state! There is no mechanism, and authorities can\'t do anything, and if can - don\'t want itself.

 

- Listening to you, everything seems to be sad...

 

- I declare formally that there is no mechanism to protect the rights of consumers in Kyrgyzstan. What we do, I don\'t want to hurt myself, even can\'t be called a rat race. We are trying to do something, but in order to protect consumers, the state agency must participate, but there is no such agency. Can you imagine that the mayor\'s office was deprived of everything? It has only the name. Well, a representative of the municipality goes with us on the courts, acts of signs, but now doesn\'t do even this. Office, for example, has no right even to impose the fine, it can only invite the entrepreneur, and the latter may or may not come. Moreover, our legislation is too softish, and inaction of public authorities - antitrust, customs, certification bodies...

 

In 2005 the law on technical regulation came out, in 2006 government decree approved the list of authorized bodies of state supervision over the implementation of technical regulations, but then it all died out. These regulations have already appeared, but not the body. For example, we found a non-certified product, raised the issue and sent claim letters to 16 stores, opened lawsuits but the state agencies checked only two stores for the whole year.

 

- Well, on the other hand, if they start checking - there will be rising tide of discontent, saying, business is oppressed, strangled...

 

- Stop! Let\'s be honest. Many people are speculating on the subject of business. And why should it develop at the expense of the rights of the consumer, by providing poor service or the sale of defective goods? By what right they develop the business to the detriment of the health of consumer? This is element of speculation, but there should be the golden mean. Business must be responsible, but, unfortunately, is not. And we are left to the mercy of traders. And why? Because businessmen sit in all ministries, as well as in our parliament, so who will harm himself?

CONTACTS

SOCIAL MEDIA

TelegramYouTubeWhatsAppFacebookInstagram

© News Agency «24.kg» - News of Kyrgyzstan. All rights reserved. All information posted on this website is intended for personal use only and may not be distributed without the written permission of NA «24.kg». The editorial team is not responsible for the content of reprinted materials and statements of individuals. +18