Parliament and the government are killing the economy of Kyrgyzstan.
Once considered country\'s \"gold\" asset of 33 percent stake in the Canadian company Centerra Gold through the efforts of officials and deputies gradually turned into \"so-so\" asset. But Kyrgyzstan can fool it away - there are many people wishing to arrest these shares on claims of international arbitration courts in which the republic stuck for a long time.
What were you waiting for?
Another news on the arrest of 6.5 million shares of Kyrgyzstan in Centerra Gold Inc by the court came from the Canadian province of Ontario on March 3. According to the head of Kyrgyzaltyn Tokon Mamytov, securities are frozen at the suit of the Latvian businessman Valery Belokon. He appealed to the Court of Canada after the Kyrgyz government hasn\'t complied with the deadline obligations under the verdict of the International Court of Arbitration in Paris (France). The KR has to pay $16.5 million.
Valery Belokon submitted to arbitration claim against the government of Kyrgyzstan \"in connection with the expropriation of a credit institution Manas Bank, belonging to him. After the change of power in Kyrgyzstan on April 8, 2010, the government introduced there a temporary external control. Bank suspected of having links with the family of former President Kurmanbek Bakiyev. Conservation regime is still continuing.
For several years, representatives of Valery Belokon negotiated the termination of Kyrgyzstan criminal case against Latvian businessman and management of Manas Bank. In exchange, offered to withdraw the case. But there were no intelligible suggestions.
So was with the reaction of the Kyrgyz government after the defeat in court on October 24, 2014. For the execution of the judgment the State was given two months.
There was a response though. In 2014 the government issued a statement and was pleased that
\"the tribunal claims of Belokon upheld in part, and in financial - less than 1/5 of the claims filed against it.\" This is understandable: the initial claims comprised $100 million. Apparently, the officials didn\'t worry about the need to pay $16.5 million, because after the announcement on this matter they just lost cause.
Game on someone else\'s script
Much more serious is the situation with Stans Energy. On its lawsuit the same court in Ontario arrested 47 million shares (60 percent) of Kyrgyzstan in Centerra Gold in 2014. Amount of the claim to the country - $118.2 million.
Initially, two licenses for the right to develop mineral deposits Kutessai II (rare earth metals, bismuth, molybdenum and silver) and Kalesai (beryllium, lead) till 2029 were issued to Kutisai Mining. In 2009, Stans Energy bought the company together with the licenses.
Official exile of investor started with criminal investigation of the General Prosecutor\'s Office, in January 2013 on the extension of the agreement with the Kutisai Mining. Bishkek Inter-District Court upheld the claims of the Prosecutor General\'s Office, and the company lost its license.
The company was charged with violation of license agreements. According to representatives of Stans Energy, force majeure - the events of April 2010 - prevented fulfill the conditions. That time the overthrow of President paralyzed government agencies, and mining companies couldn\'t coordinate a work plan and deliver reports.
But, apparently, the battle against Stans Energy began long before the opening of criminal proceedings. In an interview with a reputable online portal ProEdge Wire the Canadian expert in the field of rare earth metals Alastair Neil spoke about piquant conversation with the head of China\'s rare earth company. The Chinese, according to Alastair Neil, confidently stated that by the middle (at the latest - by the third quarter) of 2013 the deposit will be taken away from Canadian investors. Chinese, according to the expert, boasted ties to the Kyrgyz government and named the sum, which will cost him takeover of deposit: $1.5 million.
Local media wrote that the main participants in \"torpedoing\" of Stans Energy were members of Ar-Namys parliamentary faction, headed by Felix Kulov. They managed to push the decisions, recommending the State Geology Agency to revoke the license of Canadians. Judging by the date specified in China, everything was according to the script. Well, except for the fact that the new investors of the field haven\'t appeared. Although we can\'t exclude that no one was going to develop it. Apparently, the elimination of competitors was quite enough.
Finish off the last
Arrests of Kyrgyzstan\'s shares in Centerra make position of the government, which is struggling with the establishment of a joint venture with the Canadians on the further development of the Kumtor gold deposit, more vulnerable. Parliament gave the Cabinet one month to complete the negotiations, otherwise threatened nationalization of the company, which is the flagship of the economy.
The same ill-fated stock of shares should become contribute of Kyrgyzstan to the joint venture, in order to ensure 50/50 shares. It is unclear to create it now, considering the arrest of securities.
The initiator of the parliamentary motion against the Canadians is the leader of Ata Meken Omurbek Tekebayev. Now Felix Kulov joined him. Yesterday, he said once again: he wants to believe that the government will cope with its task and a month later will fulfill the order of the parliament. \"Otherwise, the question on nationalization of mines will rise again. I am against such a measure. On the other hand, in the world there is no such case that any court abolishes a law on nationalization. It is the sovereign right of the state, and issues of reparation of damages should be considered in our courts,\" he added.
Such optimism of deputies is striking. The truth is about how they are going to ensure work on the mine, deputies keep quiet. According to analysts, the daily cost of running of the enterprise is over $1.4 million.
The proposed by the deputies variant \"to produce ourselves, sell gold and invest in production\" doesn\'t stand up to scrutiny. In the case of nationalization of enterprises all financial flows on the operating costs of Centerra mine will be frozen. If Canadian investors sue in international arbitration, in no doubt, the sale of gold, produced at Kumtor, on international markets will be very, very problematic, because, the precious metal will be immediately arrested after leaving the territory of Kyrgyzstan.
And it is doubtful that anyone would agree to invest in a controversial company. Same with lending production with dim prospects. How long will the resources of Kyrgyzstan for support of the work of the mine last, even at the maximum reduction of all costs?
Smother by own hands
By the way, the situation with Kumtor the government rocked itself, when in the autumn of 2013 established a commission with the intention to change the terms of the enterprise. In other words, to squeeze money from investors to the maximum.
Long negotiations accompanied by deputy and folk performances on nationalization, the opening of the General Prosecutor\'s Office criminal cases against former officials upon the conclusion of agreements with Centerra bear its fruits. At the time of formation of the commission Kyrgyzstan\'s blocks of shares in the Canadian company was worth $1.5 billion, now - just $370 million.
Hardly anyone will take responsibility for such actually sabotage against the state. In this case, the actual loss of the country is much more. After all, there were sensible proposals - to sell part of the shares and create a development fund. How many profitable projects could run for this money! But no, we decided to go by own way. As a result, still begging, asking money from Russia, Turkey, Kazakhstan.
Kyrgyz authorities are not going to learn from mistakes. Games, which can put an end to the economy, are continuing in the parliament. Government demonstrates gallows optimism, and now the country is not thinking about the investment climate and image of the country - it is more important to survive and to pay for international claims. They are unlikely to be written off to Kyrgyzstan. Debts won\'t disappear, even if not pay attention to them.