Kyrgyzstan – country with very high level of internal and external risks for investors
Analysts have identified Kyrgyzstan as a country with a very high level of internal and external risks to investors. This is stated in the report of communications holding Minchenko consulting \"Political risk assessment for foreign investors in Central Asia,\" presented yesterday in Astana (Kazakhstan).++
According to it, in the general ranking of the value of political risk for investors in Central Asia, Kyrgyzstan won the penultimate place with 37 points. Worse is only in Tajikistan - 43 points. The most prosperous in the region, according to analysts, is Kazakhstan (15 points). Turkmenistan and Uzbekistan received 32 and 37 points of risk
Minchenko consulting believes that the most dangerous internal risks for investors among the Central Asian countries are in the Kyrgyz Republic. \"With regard to Kyrgyzstan, as shown by international and Russian ratings, there is a consensus of experts in terms of presenting the obvious - it is on the brink of transfer to the status of \"failed state\" - the weakness of its statehood. The latter is especially slackened as a result of two successive revolutions (2005 and 2010),\" the report says.
In addition, experts point to other risks: \"Break of the country into northern and southern part with the sustainable opposition elites and weak government control over the south (especially Osh city), and ethnic tensions between Kyrgyz and Uzbeks, manifested in the conflict in Osh during the last revolution.\" \"The difficult economic situation (the share of remission from migrant workers in the country\'s GDP - one of the world leaders); the weakness of law enforcement agencies; very strong influence in the field of crime; a serious base for the growth of corruption and organized crime (an important role in the economy played smuggling and re-export of Chinese goods, transit drug trafficking). Internal risks for Kyrgyzstan are seriously enhanced by external one,\" the experts add.
Among them, holding analysts note \"Factor 2014\" (withdrawal of US troops from Afghanistan and, as a consequence, a sharp rise in tensions in the region). \"Instability in Afghanistan associated with terrorist activity and drug-trafficking, that may further strengthen internal instability associated with a weak state. Characteristically, exactly Kyrgyzstan and Tajikistan, according to most expert estimates, are highly dependent on foreign aid and investment, including in countering \"Factor 2014,\" the report says.
In addition, \"among specific external risks of Kyrgyzstan we can mention indirect effect of the conflict in Afghanistan and possibility of recurrence of invasion of extremist groups (modelled after Batken War of 1999); friction with Uzbekistan; geopolitical division of the country into two loosely connected parts; the highest in the region aid dependency competing for influence of the great powers.\"
\"Only mining industry brings not significant export revenues to Kyrgyzstan, there is a lack of export surpluses in energy (here we can add remission of migrant workers and transit trade as the main sources of income). It does not have enough oil products, which are imported from Russia, Kazakhstan and Turkmenistan,\" experts say.
At the same time, the report mentions problems of investors, who work in mining industry of the Kyrgyz Republic. \"In terms of stability of political institutions and the \"rules of the game\" at the moment Kyrgyzstan is especially in a state of crisis. Since 2010 in the Kyrgyz Republic major conflicts have local nature (in contrast to Bakiyev\'s time, whose son Maxim was involved in the process of redistribution of property), that is the conflicts are provoked by local clan groups, and then politicized. Government mainly plays the role of mediator. The most typical example of this type of risk is the problems of Centerra Gold Canadian Company, which invests in Kumtor gold mine,\" the report says.
It is emphasized that \"according to many experts, instability of the institutional environment, which is often deliberately exacerbated by competing political forces, even the biggest obstacle to successful foreign investment than corrupt authoritarian regimes.\" As a result, \"the positive side of the Kyrgyz Republic - relatively high degree of liberal legislation, which is neutralized by instability of \"the rules of the game\". In addition, \"in case of Kyrgyzstan, it is not about confrontation of power and investor, but the confrontation of legislative and executive branches of the government, which takes the foreign investor hostage.\"
\"The situation in Bishkek could be improved by political stabilization and more consistent use of \"the rules of the game\". In particular, resolution of the situation around Kumtor can significantly improve investor sentiment towards the country. External risks can be seriously reduced only in case of solution of the Afghan problem,\" the analysts conclude.