The Russian rouble and monetary trends in Central Asia and the world
ALMATY (TCA) - Are commodities too cheap or is money, in particular the American greenback, too expensive? That is the basic question behind what is currently dubbed a \"rouble crisis\" and misleadingly connected with \"sanctions\" veiling the face of what is a profound global market deadlock which touches Central Asian, Caucasian, other former Soviet economies and indeed most of those in the rest of the world.
Seeing from the outside it looks like there is a need of a \"demonetisation\" of tangible goods markets - or to put it quaintly: let not cash value determine commodity value but the other way round. Interestingly, Central Asia with its rich variety in natural resources finds itself right in the middle of what could become the biggest economic and industrial revolution since the 18th century: a shift from a world economy based on greed to one based on need. The question is profound and of global impact - and so is any possible answer to it.
Each episode in the continuing cycle of economic and financial shakeups can be seen as \"an artificial blow up of financial bubbles and craving for easy money, absence of proper responsibility of national financial institutions and the weakness of the global financial management\" - at least in the words of Kazakhstan\'s President Nursultan Nazarbayev as he spoke at the opening of the 6th Astana Economic Forum back in late spring 2013. His opinion was later accompanied by that of Nobel laureate John Nash who simply observed on one of the panels he took part in that \"money is a tool but has wrongly turned into a means in itself, an obsession\".
\"In fact, these and other fundamental causes of the global downturn have not been eliminated yet,\" the Kazakh head of state thundered in his address. \"The deficiency of the global currency system is the main reason for the current global economic storm. Let me remind that I persistently urged to change the ways of global currency emission and circulation that do not meet the criteria of legitimacy, democracy, efficient controllability and responsibility. Yet to this day, there have been neither efficient global anti-crisis mechanisms nor reliable global reserve currency or a group of regional currencies. No sufficient will and responsibility has been present to make radical decisions.\"
If asked today, Nazarbayev would indeed be most unlikely to have changed his opinion which is quite understandable since the country he is responsible for finds itself right in the middle of a crisis which is dominated by false images. Thus, commodity prices over the last couple of years and through last year in particular have \"lost\" substantial \"value\", with oil close to 60, metals in the order of 30 and cereals around 20 per cent on average. But have they really? In terms of US dollars, quite so. But in Russian roubles, a barrel of oil cost about as much as it cost a year-and-a-half ago while other commodities have even become more expensive. It should therefore be considered quite natural if one thinks objectively for a moment using pure mathematics that a commodity producing and exporting country adapts its domestic currency\'s exchange value to sales prices against foreign currency with little other aim than to preserve as much of its domestic purchasing power and profits on domestic sales as possible.
The policy pursued by the Russian government roughly consists of the following pattern: swallow losses in cash, compensate them by taking money from state reserves and use the opportunity to \"de-dollarise\" the national economy. \"With the fall of the average price for oil from $100 to $50 per barrel in 2015, the budget revenues just from oil taxes could decrease by 2.1 trillion rouble [$31 billion] while a more serious fall in price, to an average of $40 [per barrel] for the year, could lead to a budget revenue decline of 3.1 trillion rouble [$46 billion],\" Ilya Trunin, head of the tax, customs and tariff department at the Russian Finance Ministry, wrote in an article posted by SputnikNews on February 4.
But he added that Russia has more than enough reserves to take care of the \"losses\" and can use the opportunity to make the state household book less dependent on a currency from the other side of the globe over which the local government has no control. Other former Soviet states are less consistent in their currency policies and at least in part cling to the dollar benchmark. In the end, they could lose a lot more in terms of national purchasing power than Russia does unless their governments grasp the overall idea.
Irrespective of European and American sanctions toward Russia, and the ongoing war on terrorism and the use of oil money by ISIL, it all leads to two basic monetary scenarios for years to come. The first one consists of persistent, though fluctuating market situation that determines undervaluation of commodities and overvaluation of cash, resulting in blowing bubbles on a regular basis which are bound to burst subsequently.
The second scenario consists of a trend already visible and led by Russia and China in particular, with most of southern Asia and Latin America following the pace and even the European Union getting to its senses. The first step was the creation of currency baskets for national reserves, mainly consisting of US dollars, euros, yens, Swiss francs, and Sterling, but increasingly also of yuans.
Which scenario is going to prevail remains to be seen in the actions of several world players.
http://www.timesca.com/news/26-opinion-head/14965-the-russian-rouble-and-monetary-trends-in-central-asia-and-the-world