USD87.45EUR95.90RUB1.07
24.kg

Budget.kg: beware of builders

13:57, 29 January 2015, Bishkek - 24.kg news agency
Tatyana KUDRYAVTSEVA

Scanty state treasury doesn\'t allow the authorities to carry out all its obligations. Situations, when dishonest officials are trying to \"earn\" on meager finances, become even more complex.

 

Fish rots from its head 

 

A recent audit of the use of budget funds in the State agency of architecture, construction and housing and communal services for 2012 and the Department of Housing and civil construction for 2012-2013 - additional confirmation of how Kyrgyz officials care about their own pockets at the expense of the state.

 

About 19 million 19.3 thousand soms should have been allocated for the maintenance of the central office of the agency in 2012, but the actual expenditure amounted to 17 million 523.2 thousand. It seems we can talk about reduction of expenditure, but the audit showed that in fact the costs could be even less. In 2012, all departments had vacant posts. Rather than hire people, the director of the state agency concluded employment contracts with people without the appropriate seniority and experience. They were paid wages at 837.3 thousand soms.

 

In August 2012 the president ordered to allocate 500,000 soms from the reserve fund for the manufacture and installation of the flagpole in Tash-Dobon rural district of Alamudun district, in Chui province. The State Committee for Construction transferred the money for this work to LLC \"SMU-3\" without bidding and providing invoices. Grand opening of flagstaff was timed to the Independence Day of the Kyrgyz Republic, but the materials for its construction were registered only after 4 months.

 

The budget of the State Committee for Construction has such an article as special means. The main sources of income come from the quarterly payments to the 10 percent of the profits of subordinate institutions and voluntary contributions. In practice, the subordinate units of the State Committee for Construction transferred money even being at a loss, and the central office spent the money (406.8 thousand soms) for the payment of premiums for the holidays and special occasions. Although special means can be used exclusively for research, experimental design, urban planning and design work, purchase of equipment.

 

Department of omnipotence

 

Even greater violations were revealed in the Department of Housing and civil construction. Almost all the money allocated from the state budget for capital construction pass through it. Let\'s start with the fact that the maintenance of the department takes 2.9 percent of the funds under the article \"Capital investments\". However, neither Ministry of Finance nor the Ministry of Construction had received the report on the use of the money.

 

Instead, the annual budget funds used by the Department were recorded as capital expenditures. In 2012 they amounted to 46 million 530.8 thousand soms, in 2013 - 44 million 764.3 thousand soms. Because of this, all reporting on the performance of the cabinet of the republican budget in financing capital investments distorted. The same rules applied for sponsorship. The result in 201246 million 530.8 thousand soms were used out of the system of the Treasury, in 2013 - 44 million 764.3 thousand soms.

 

Department illegally disposed of the money that was allocated for the repair and construction of social facilities. In the 2012 budget allocated the money to finance 200 projects. Work on 181 of them passed through the Department of Housing and civil construction. During the execution of the budget money was redistributed, and as a result the Department has funded the work on 156 sites at 957,592 million soms.

 

In this case, a significant number of objects were funded under \"Capital investments\", they were in the southern regions - Osh (60), Jalal-Abad (27) and Batken (20) regions. However, there was no effect of the redistribution of money. In 2012, only 6 objects were with balance value of 198 million 360.2 thousand soms.

The audit revealed serious gaps in administration of financing of capital construction objects. In fact, the list of funded facilities includes proposals that have no economic justification and project documentation. This leads to inefficient use of public funds, long-term construction and investment in unfinished objects. The volume of unfinished construction of public facilities at the end of 2012 amounted to 3 billion 53.7 million soms, in 2013 - 5 billion 658 million soms.

In addition, the State Construction Committee has not yet developed projects of type schools, kindergartens, sports halls, standard cost of design works, responsibility of designers, who allowed poor quality and incomplete design.

 

Charity begins at home

 

The Department of Residential Construction and Civil Engineering (DRCCE) isn\'t accustomed to take care of treasury. Apparently, they follow the example of the authorities in the person of the State Construction Committee. For example, in 2012 staffing schedule of the department was approved by the Director of the State Construction Committee in the amount of 120 units with a monthly payroll of 973.5 thousand soms. In 2013, the staffing schedule was changed twice. At first, they provided for 60 employees with payroll of 521.7 thousand soms. That\'s where the savings! But nothing of the kind. A month later, the DRCCE decided that it cut too many working places and increased the staff up to 76 units. Respectively, labor costs increased as well - up to 638.1 thousand soms. Another 48 employees are accepted to the territorial department of capital construction with a total salary of 412.2 thousand soms.

By November, staffing schedule was changed again. The Director of the Department ordered to reduce a number of employees up to 14 people, but labor costs raised up to 754.2 thousand soms, as well as spending on maintenance of territorial subdivisions - up to 472.2 thousand soms.

According to the law, salaries of employees of the department shall be the same as in the central office of the State Construction Committee. But in fact, DRCCE salaries are established without any regulatory confirmation. For example, the director of the office receives the same salary as the State Construction Committee Secretary of State. Salaries of the department heads averaged 10.5-11.5 thousand soms. The same specialists in the central department receive only 8.8 thousand soms. The situation is similar for other staff members.

The audit found out that DRCCE accountants don\'t achieve any progress. They run payroll calculation by outdated computer program. They couldn\'t update the software in department - absence of technical experts. But then, they awarded financial assistance in the form of bonuses quarterly and without any orders. By law, contract employees should only receive a fixed salary without bonuses and allowances. But in fact, economists of the department did not stint on additional financial incentives of people out of the staff.

For example, in July 2012, D.I. Borbodoeva by contract with a salary of 10 thousand soms was taken as the leading specialist of the accounting and finance department. For six months she received 154 thousand soms instead of 60 thousand. Representative on issuing and collecting loans under Nooken district and Mailuu-Suu town, also working by contract, received material assistance of 16 thousand soms due to illness. However, they even didn\'t require a medical certificate.

In 2013, according to payroll records provided by the department, 33 million 329.6 thousand soms of wages were charged. The analysis showed that the wage fund increased by 13 million 937.7 thousand soms for the year. Including increasing the size of salaries by 2 million 724.1 thousand soms and payment for years of service - 2 million 99.6 thousand soms, bonuses - 7 million 660.8 thousand soms, vacation - 1 million 540.8 thousand soms.

Half of structure of the fund consists of premiums for almost half of gross salary. Without orders in 2013, quarterly bonuses were charged at 2 million 780.9 thousand soms.

 

And this is an incomplete list of violations for which the State Construction Committee leadership turns a blind eye. A criminal case is initiated against the former director Kanybek Narbaev. It is filed under the Article \"Abuse of Power\" upon illegal application of calculations and cost estimates in preparation of Bishkek construction projects budgeting. Most likely, in the near future new episodes will be added to the case. But whether it will stop fans to profit at the expense of state?


CONTACTS

SOCIAL MEDIA

TelegramYouTubeWhatsAppFacebookInstagram

© News Agency «24.kg» - News of Kyrgyzstan. All rights reserved. All information posted on this website is intended for personal use only and may not be distributed without the written permission of NA «24.kg». The editorial team is not responsible for the content of reprinted materials and statements of individuals. +18