Excise tax on cigarettes: health care or step into abyss?
Almost everyone, who watched yesterday discussion of the bill, which increases the excise tax on cigarettes, asked such question. Initiators of the norm stubbornly insist that they care about the health of the nation. They believe that exactly tax measures can reduce the number of smokers in the country. The deputies refuse listening sound arguments of opponents of the law.
Benevolent intentions
The initiators of the draft law \"On amendments to some legislative acts of the KR (the reduction of tobacco use)\" are deputies Dastan Bekeshev, Shirin Aitmatova, Irina Karamushkina, Daniyar Terbishaliev, Damira Niyazalieva, Mirlan Bakirov, Ulukbek Kochkorov. The Ministry of Health Care also supported new norms.
\"The bill is aimed at preventing the spread of this destructive habit like smoking. These goals are suggested to be reached due to a series of measures, including by means of fiscal instruments. It also will significantly replenish the state budget and simplify tax administration. One of the important mechanisms to reduce tobacco consumption in the world, are tax measures. Therefore, the bill proposes a number of amendments to the Tax Code of the Kyrgyz Republic for a gradual increase in the base rate of excise duty on cigarettes during 2015-2017,\" the initiators of the law say.
In fact, \"gradual\" increase in base rates of excise duty looks rather as an attempt to squeeze cheap cigarettes out of the market. Judge for yourself: the bill requires the transition to a simple flat rate of excise duty in 2015. It is proposed to raise the base rate of excise duty on cigarettes with filter and non-filter cigarettes: from January 1, 2015 - 550 soms (filter cigarettes) and 100 soms (unfiltered cigarettes), from January 1, 2016 - 730 soms (for both types of cigarettes), from January 1, 2017 - 950 soms.
\"In Kyrgyzstan, the minimum tax on cigarettes with the filter will increase the excise tax at 450 soms per 1,000. The most expensive segment - \"Parliament\" cigarettes. They are already taxed at 600-610 soms per 1,000. I spent calculations: 600 KGS - normal price. One thousand cigarettes - it is 50 packs. It turns out that the pack will rise in price at about 3 soms. It\'s a little, but the budget will make a profit. In Kazakhstan, the same tax is 1,900 soms. Here cigarettes are 3 times cheaper than in Kazakhstan, and 5 times cheaper than in Russia. When we enter the Eurasian Economic Union, it would be more profitable to sell cigarettes here,\" the initiator of the bill Dastan Bekeshev said.
Who is it aimed at?
Nothing catches the eye? That\'s right. Rate of excise duty on cigarettes without filter for 3 years increased almost 4 times. The representatives of business community are against such an adjustment. They rightly remarked, such an increase means that unfiltered cigarettes will disappear from store shelves.
\"Do not compare us to Russia and Kazakhstan. We are beginning to raise the excise tax on cigarettes without filter. But such cigarettes are bought by people who have small income. Increase in excise tax won\'t solve the problem. People will buy some cheap analogues from neighboring countries,\" the chairman of the Association of suppliers and distributors Gulnara Uskenbaeva said.
The initiators of the bill have repeatedly said that neighboring Russia and Kazakhstan have already implemented similar rates. But forgot to say that Kazakhstan did this recently when the market trade in cigarettes without filter became almost zero. Is tobacco lobby kings in Kazakhstan are so powerful? Not at all. The state thinks about the future, not only income but also about how to restrict the flow of contraband from neighboring countries.
\"Sharp equalization of excise tax on cigarettes may adversely affect he country\'s security. People will not give up smoking. If they have no money for expensive cigarettes, they will look for cheaper counterparts. Where did they come from? Of course, they will be brought through contraband. In fact, smuggling of cigarettes worldwide is of large scale. But people just don\'t pay attention to it. The bad factor is that terrorist organizations control the industry. It turns out that rash act of parliamentarians can attract into far more dangerous threat to the country,\" experts of the Association of Suppliers and Distributors believe.
Think at leisure
Someone might fair to say that representatives of tobacco companies simply protect business. But it is simple to check veracity of their arguments.
Here are some facts. Organized crime groups in England attract minors to smuggling and distribution of cigarettes. Patronage of tobacco smuggling is a significant part of \"Al-Qaeda in the Islamic Maghreb\" terrorist group financing. \"Hezbollah\" (Lebanon) earns by smuggling of consumer goods, including cigarettes. Income from \"protection racket\" of illegal trade of cigarettes comprises about 20 percent of the total budget of \"Taliban\" movement. There are illegal factories producing counterfeit Marlboro and Camel cigarettes in Pakistan for delivery to Central Asia - Turkmenistan, Uzbekistan, Tajikistan.
The practice of raising excise taxes on cigarettes was applied in Turkey a few years ago. They grew by almost 3 times. The Ministry of Health has reported on reduction of a number of smokers in the country by 20 percent, based on data of official production and importation of cigarettes. And inhabitants of the country, meanwhile, lined up for low-grade tobacco products and smuggling products in bazaars. A similar situation was observed in Romania - after the country\'s accession to the European Union. Now this country has one of the highest level of cigarette smuggling in Europe. According to various estimates, in 2013 it amounted to about 30 percent in 2013.
Alcohol vs Cigarettes
Many countries have a rhetorical question of who exists and for whom - business for state, or vice versa. But not here. Kyrgyz businessmen have to ask it with alarming frequency. The reason is simple: entrepreneurs constantly have to come across examples of the so-called bureaucratic and parliamentary \"care\" about business and citizens of the country. Moreover, it is unclear what logic guides both camps. The current increase in excise tax on cigarettes - good example.
Representatives of tobacco industry themselves don\'t mind raising excise taxes, but always stress that this should be done gradually, avoiding spikes. The government, which should argue for rate hike, this time supported employers and offered more gradual increase in interest rates on non-filter cigarettes. But the parliament stubbornly stands its ground. Why? The question is rhetorical.
Another fact looks strange. Along with increase in excise duties on cigarettes it was planned to raise rates for alcohol industry. But the parliamentarians unexpectedly dropped the idea.
\"After Kyrgyzstan\'s accession to the Eurasian Economic Union, Russia will ask us to increase excise taxes. There will be a single space, customs borders will erase. But Kyrgyzstan has much lower excise tax on alcohol than in Russia. I think we should leave this norm. Then we can get more benefit. Entrepreneurs will come to us, register here and pay taxes,\" Dastan Bekeshev noted.
If the main purpose of the bill is a concern about health of Kyrgyz citizens, then why there is such a strange division? Whether alcohol products are less harmful to health than cigarettes?