Biometrics.kg: when carriage is ahead of donkeys
Collection of biometric data of Kyrgyz citizens - the number one topic. It is discussed everywhere - in breaks at work, in line for a pension, a doctor, shops, markets, in the bus, in social networks, roundtables, as well as at the highest level - in parliament and government... Excitement gripped everyone.
And the first vice-prime minister Taiyrbek Sarpashev added fuel to the flames, expressing the questionable assumption with respect to those who are not very eager to trust the government.
\"If PIN is not provided, then there is something is wrong with receiving benefits and privileges. We will check and anyway it\'s all will be revealed. I don\'t think people refusing only for political principles, maybe there is a personal motives,\" he said.
\"Are you asking for songs? I have no!\"
Motif, you say? Perhaps it is. People have a right to doubt this innovation. Judge for yourself: two and a half weeks officials of the State Registration Service \"kept the defense\" to the last and solemnly assured journalist of 24.kg news agency, that the data on stolen laptops in officers - misinformation.
However, yesterday the first deputy prime minister confirmed the theft, and previously denying it officials of the State Registration Service together with senior government officials began to convince the public that there was no stolen citizens\' personal data in electronic media.
A chief of staff on collection, vice-president of the State Registration Service Eldiyar Ubaliev apparently decided to show off his technical knowledge, and said that even if there is biometric data on laptops, no one can get to them because they are encoded. When asked how we can talk about the security of personal data of citizens, if it is so easy to steal equipment, the official retorted: \"I\'m telling you, but you don\'t believe me.\"
Yes I don\'t believe it! Maybe because I know how much talents our land has, and I believe in the latter-day \"Snowdens\" who periodically break into our official websites of government agencies... If you remember, like recently the same happened to the official website of the Government of the Kyrgyz Republic...
When there is no agreement...
In fact, our officials need to agree in advance how and what to tell lies, because then one said to the media one thing, the second - the other, and the population suffers from confusion. The impression is that each of bureaucrats is acting, according to some his plan.
\"We don\'t force anyone to pass biometric data,\" Eldiyar Ubaliev commented earlier to 24.kg news agency on situation on the fears of citizens not receiving the necessary help in case of failure of biometrics.
And then Taiyrbek Sarpashev says that the government intends \"to impose restrictions on access to public services for people who failed biometrics.\" And it means to be punished...
Yesterday Bishkek school teachers confirmed: yes, teachers are forced to somehow influence the students\' parents, so that they passed biometrics and submit a certificate.
What is that supposed to mean? The government keeps silence.
Slam bang - and it\'s done!
At the round table \"Challenges and Risks: Parliamentary elections 2015\", experts beat all to pieces the campaign held by the government, stating that biometrics - is certainly a step forward, the digital future, but its wrong implementation could undermine the credibility and cast doubt on the results of the upcoming parliamentary elections.
According to Director of \"Civil Initiative on Internet Policy\" PF Tattu Mambetalieva, biometrics shall be administered systemically, elaborately, with normative support, what is absent at the moment, but there is a fair criticism and public outrage. The civil activist studied voter lists, remembering the famous poster - \"Those who drown, will not swim again.\"
\"If we drown in this biometrics today, we can close your eyes for the future. Previously they spoke only about electronic, now paper list... We have a question: which of voter lists is the main one and has the highest legal force? When the Mongols showed us presentation, we have seen that they have a paper version in priority. In our project, this issue isn\'t resolved. What will happen if the two lists become equal, but for technical reasons a citizen suddenly isn\'t included into electronic list? Would then he be admitted to the election? Who will be responsible for completeness and their validity in the court? And how will these moments be regulated? CEC will only be liable for paper version of the list, and State Registration Service - for electronic one? How will the court take decisions if the two lists are different from each other?\" Tattu Mambetalieva asked officials.
According to her, at present there is no any statutory act that defines what \"electronic list\" constitutes, what and how it is regulated. Another important point: how the list of electronic digital signature (EDS) will be verified? By someone one or all CEC members? Or maybe Precinct Election Commission?
The law is harsh, but it\'s the law
By the way, the director of Adilet legal clinic Cholpon Dzhakupova at the roundtable stressed that while the new law has not been adopted, the CEC must be responsible for voter lists, and it isn\'t right to shift responsibility to the state registration service: there is not only administrative, but also criminal liability for it.
\"Preparations for the elections are in full swing, and I stand for everything to be within the law. According to the law, CEC is responsible for the electoral lists,\" she said.
The experts have unanimous opinion: despite claims of the Chairman of SRS Alina Shaikova, who claimed responsibility for formation of electoral lists in the electoral law clearly states that the electoral process doesn\'t admit any interference, and SRS - just subdivision of the government.
\"Please,understand, I do not blame that all is wrong, but it is necessary to solve questions with legal acts. Then change electoral laws and CEC,\" Mambetalieva replied.
\"Unfortunately, time is short, therefore, being ahead of adoption of the law, the government together with the CEC, realizing that it is more appropriate and helpful, transferred this function to the SRS,\" - is justified by the head of presidential administration Daniyar Narymbaev justified.
So, Tayirbek Duishekeevich, sorry that you still do not understand that people are motivated not by personal motive, as you stated, but first and foremost need for the rule of law, which you \"a little\" forget and security of their data, which the state can not guarantee yet.
Important fact: in the process of implementation of this, in general, good idea with biometrics you completely discourage people from going to the upcoming elections for your harsh and unfounded statements and actions. While may be is what you want? There is still plenty of time prior to the election 2015, but the First Vice PM included administrative resource to the full. Do not expect that it is made for our sake, but solely his.
If anyone has forgotten, the President threatened namely Taiyrbek Sarpashev with dismissal in case of failure of the project for collection of biometrics and formation of honest, unvarnished and without \"dead souls\", list of voters. The desire of the first vice prime minister to stay in his chair costs too much for electorate, doesn\'t it?