The best solution for Kyrgyzstan is to negotiate with Stans Energy
The best way to solve the problem with Stans Energy is to negotiate with the company, believes Aktilek Tungatarov, Executive Director of the International Business Council (IBC) based in Bishkek.
On October 14, Canada-based Stans Energy Corp. announced that it has obtained an injunction (the \"Order\") from the Ontario Superior Court of Justice which, among other things, prohibits the Kyrgyz Republic and Kyrgyzaltyn JSC from selling, disposing, exchanging, assigning, transferring, pledging or encumbering 47,000,000 shares in the capital of Centerra Gold Inc. registered in the name of Kyrgyzaltyn JSC.
The order was obtained in a proceeding by Stans Energy for recognition and enforcement of an international arbitration award of the Arbitration Court at the Moscow Chamber of Commerce & Industry against the Kyrgyz Republic for US $118 million. Kyrgyzstan has refused to pay the award.
Stans Energy is a resource development company focused on progressing heavy rare earth properties in areas of the former Soviet Union. In December 2009, Stans acquired a 20-year mining license for the past-producing Kutessay II rare earth mine from Kyrgyzstan. On May 26, 2011 Stans completed the purchase of the Kashka Rare Earth Processing Plant, the plant that previously refined rare earth elements historically from Kutessay II.
Two years ago, the Commission on subsoil use licensing at the Agency for Geology and Mineral Resources of Kyrgyzstan extended the company\'s licensing agreement in Kyrgyzstan, but then the decision was found to be false, and the license was revoked.
As a result, the company cannot operate. It had appealed to the IBC, and directly to the government to decide the problem through direct negotiations, as well as repeatedly made public statements - either independently or through the IBC.
\"We have repeatedly appealed to the leadership of the country that the issue requires urgent attention, and it must be solved immediately,\" said Tungatarov. In December2013, an interagency commission was established to investigate the actual issuance of the license to develop the Kutessay II deposit. \"The Commission, headed by Deputy Economy Minister Adylbek Kasymaliyev, worked classified as \'for official use only\', so we do not know the results - what decisions were made and what suggestions and recommendations were made for the settlement of disputes between the company and Kyrgyzstan,\" IBC Director said.
Time passed, and the company had no choice but to appeal to court, and they have filed a claim to Arbitration at the Moscow Chamber of Commerce and Industry, which satisfied the claim of the company, to which Kyrgyzstan has to pay about $118 million.
\"Unfortunately, in these proceedings, Kyrgyzstan did not even choose arbitrators for itself and did not participate in the proceedings to protect the interests of Kyrgyzstan, while the Government and the Kyrgyz ambassador in Russia were notified of the impending trial in good time,\" Tungatarov commented.
Kyrgyzstan appealed to the CIS Economic Court, which supported Kyrgyzstan. But some lawyers and representatives of Stans Energy argued that this court had no right to address this issue.
On the basis of the Award at the Moscow Chamber of Commerce, the Ontario Supreme Court of Justice (Canada) decided to arrest 60 percent of the shares which Kyrgyzstan has in Centerra Gold. The decision is valid for 10 days from the date of acceptance.
The Kyrgyz Government says the Ontario court decision is unlawful because Kyrgyzaltyn owns these shares, but the claim was filed against the Kyrgyz government.
According to Tungatarov, the Supreme Court of Ontario planned to continue addressing this issue on October 20. \"Currently, the decision is not known, because their courts operate differently than in our country, where decision is announced immediately after a hearing. Hopefully, soon we will learn about the results. I think that the decision will remain in force, they will just extend the period of freezing shares,\" he said.
In the end, what happens? \"Kyrgyzstan is again energetically promoting itself with a bad hand,\" Tungatarov continued. \"The country has a few litigations with investors, but they badly affect its reputation in the international market. As a result, investors are afraid of Kyrgyzstan, and this has a direct impact on the investment climate of the country.\" He supposed that it may also affect the course of negotiations between Kyrgyzstan and Centerra Gold to sign the draft agreement (on the Kumtor gold mine), which was approved by the Kyrgyz Parliament and submitted for consideration to Centerra shareholders.
A big mistake was made when instead of solving this problem immediately, the government has failed to act, said Tungatarov.
At present, a Legal Representation Center under the Government of the Kyrgyz Republic has been created. Tungatarov believes that the Center has to examine the situation and explain to the country\'s leadership the decisions made by the courts - as far as which court had the right to address the case and explain whether the court decisions are legitimate - and give concrete proposals to Kyrgyzstan what to do next, maybe to solve the problem through other international courts.
\"I believe that the best solution for the Kyrgyz Government is to sit down at the negotiating table with the management of Stans Energy. It is not too late, because the company has repeatedly stated that it is ready to solve the issue peacefully. The only thing the company needs is to resume work in the Kutessay II, and nothing more. And then, perhaps, they will withdraw their claims,\" Tungatarov concluded.
http://www.timesca.com/index.php?option=com_content&view=article&id=14434:the-best-solution-for-kyrgyzstan-is-to-negotiate-with-stans-energy&catid=84&Itemid=576