Elena Kuzmina: Not boundaries but internal problems of Kyrgyzstan to hinder investments from Customs Union
Less time left before the entry of Kyrgyzstan into the Customs Union, but the debates about the correctness of this step are continuing. At the same time, almost no one says that joining the CU - not a panacea, and this step won\'t solve many problems of the country. Exactly about it, as well as about resource nationalism, the prospects of investing in the development of Kyrgyzstan and its branches within the Union, the head of the sector of economic development of post-Soviet countries in the Centre Post-Soviet Studies, Institute of Economics of the Russian Academy of Sciences Elena Kuzmina told in an interview.
- Will Kyrgyzstan\'s joining the Customs Union attract new investors from Russia, Belarus and Kazakhstan?
- Of course, it will. But we shouldn\'t assume that the entry into the Customs Union automatically implies the solution of all trade and economic problems of Kyrgyzstan by neighboring, more powerful economies. Any business is investing, not because the government wants it, but because it has to be good for business. The state can only insure some of the risks of national business in the most important countries for it.
General rules of the trade and economic union remove most of the barriers to effective collaboration. But Kyrgyzstan should have not only objects for investment, but also a stable internal situation that will give investors confidence in return on investment. Low level of infrastructure of Kyrgyzstan, the instability of the tax laws and investment, inflexible credit laws could scare off investors.
- Will the investment policy of the CU countries undergo any changes, and will sanctions against Russia affect their investment climate?
- Sanctions against Russia may reduce the investment opportunities of the country at some point, while there is a reorientation to other markets. But it should be noted that Russian investments in Kyrgyzstan today is not very significant, so maybe they will increase even with sanctions.
Major problem for the investment of both Russian and Kazakh companies in the Kyrgyz economy are not Western sanctions, but internal political and economic problems of the country. Moreover, the imposition of sanctions hasn\'t abolished the Russian economic aid to Kyrgyzstan, as well as duty-free sales of Russian fuel, $1.2 billion for the setting up joining the CU customs and phytosanitary infrastructure were allocated.
- Which sectors will be the most attractive to investors from the CU countries? Will projects of other foreign companies be taken into account?
- Agro-industrial complex, the textile industry, hydropower, mining (non-ferrous and rare earth metals) - on the initial stage. Later we can talk about industrial cooperation, transport and other infrastructure projects.
Most likely, Russia and Kazakhstan will take into account the risks, particularly of a political plan that arose in their previous work with Kyrgyz companies and try to minimize them to the stage of signing contracts.
This is not about Kyrgyzstan\'s nationalization of foreign companies on its territory when entering the union. Change of ownership can be based only on the legislation of the Kyrgyz Republic and at more favorable terms of the contract after the end of the previous agreements. Existing documents of the Eurasian Economic Commission, which regulates the activities of the Customs Union and the Common Economic Space, don\'t involve the redistribution of property (CU - sales, production and not the union), but strengthen markets for their goods within their borders.
- Will the competition increase, in particular for deposits of rare and precious metals that are put up for sale, and revenues to the budget of the republic?
- Competition will increase because Kazakh companies, such as \"Kazakhmys\", and Russian may be interested in these deposits. But there are some pitfalls. Firstly, according to the forecast, the main development of gold will end after 2026, and Kyrgyzstan will have to think about what to replace this loss of substantial budget losses. Here can help the existing large pool of small developments. In other countries, they give 15 to 30 percent of the country\'s mineral resources. In the field of development of small lots of positive: significant mineral resources, a large number of jobs, reducing internal migration. However, this is high cost, which can be held only by serious national companies.
The second problem - is the so-called resource nationalism, which is characterized by threat of expropriation, cancellation of previous contracts and licenses, extortion at the local level under threat of blocking works. It leads to rise in cost of investment, high investment risk assessment for all other sectors of the economy, reduction of mines expiration date by developing the richest areas on the principle of \"take and leave.\" Kyrgyz authorities have to deal with these problems.
According to experts, it is necessary to exclude political interference in the work of regulatory bodies; implementation of the Roadmap on short-term development strategy; increase in investment rating up to an average among mining countries; balancing the interests of the state, companies and local population; achieving a positive public perception of development of the mining sector.
-Now, mainly, Kumtor project provides with industrial growth of the republic. In the long term, we can expect diversification of sources of production growth in the Kyrgyz Republic, including companies of CU countries?
- Judging by the words of Kyrgyz officials, they are counting on mining development, metal processing and metallurgy, machine building, light and food industry, production of building materials and power industry. Exactly these branches represent the interest for the state, as well as for foreign investors. Their development will contribute to diversification of the Kyrgyz industry.
And, of course, the Russian side will retain interest in objects of military-industrial complex of the republic, for which it is the main investor.
- Can the Russian, Belarusian and Kazakh companies provide independent development of Kumtor?
- If you talk about financial and technical capabilities of these companies, then yes, they are quite able to engage in independent development of any field in any country, what happens now. If we talk about replacement of investors by others, the following should be noted here. The Eurasian Economic Union does not imply creating closed economic system and autonomous development of the global economy. All the same laws of economics will work here. And directive substitution of companies of one states for the companies of others is impossible.
Yes, it can be assumed that the whole situation around Kumtor is played in someone\'s interests. Not the fact that only in the interests of the state. I would say, based on the dynamics of outbreaks demanding nationalization or revision of contracts in the field, likely, such sentiments are used to strengthen influence of some political forces of the republic and weakening of others.
- The main question that concerns society - benefits of simple Kyrgyz citizen from entering the Customs Union. Do they exist in the short term?
- Here is an example. Upon entering the CU, the government will have to take measures for bringing the economy out of the shadow. In this case, the state budget will receive additional funds that can be spent for increasing any programs and public investments in development of formal sector of the economy and, consequently, increase the number of work places. Experts estimated that after legalization of only 10 percent of business, gross domestic product will grow by 1.5-3 percent, budget revenues - by 3-5 percent, investment and lending activity in the financial market - by 5 percent. Will this affect an ordinary citizen? In my opinion, it is a rhetorical question.
Another example. Closed customs border with Kazakhstan has already led to reduction in supply of goods from China to major markets of Kyrgyzstan: Dordoi and Kara-Suu. In 2012, they amounted to 401.9 thousand tons, in 2013 - 329.9 thousand tons, which is 22 percent less than previous year. During the first 9 months of 2014 volume of trade in Dordoi market fell by 3-4 times. Reduction of foreign trade with China, owing to impossibility of further re-export, leads to loss of product market in Kazakhstan and Russia, growth of unemployment in major wholesale markets and sector of small businesses, involved in shuttle trade, deterioration of financial condition of small and medium-sized businesses. These are ordinary citizens.
Then we can talk in details about two sectors of the Kyrgyz economy - agriculture and textile industry, where the majority of the population engaged in. Lack of common customs laws and phytosanitary standards seriously reduces access of Kyrgyz exporters to the markets of the CU. By the way, they are the main trading partners of the Kyrgyz Republic. According to Economy Minister of the KR Temir Sariev, share of CU countries in total foreign trade turnover of the Republic in 2013 amounted to 40.7 percent, exports - 27.8 percent, imports - 44.9 percent. It is loss of jobs and wages of ordinary Kyrgyz people.