Science.kg. Reforms minus poverty
Since the beginning of September, workers of the National Academy of Sciences of Kyrgyzstan are in some disarray after the proposal of President Almazbek Atambayev to reform science and create the conditions for its revival. Scientists considered this as an attack on the abolition of the Academy: all the reforms simmer down to that the place of elders experienced scientists will come young innovators who understand nothing in the studies.
Renaissance
According to Almazbek Atambayev, the scientific justification should be a vital link in the preparation and public decision-making on major economic, political and social issues. The analysis of the current state of science shows that the core business is not aimed at the implementation of the practical needs of economic sectors and allows us to derive a domestic science at the international level. In this regard, public advisory council made recommendations to reform and revitalize the scientific activities in Kyrgyzstan.
\"The National Academy of Sciences of the Kyrgyz Republic has over 20 institutions, has 115 active members, corresponding members and honorary academicians. However, according to experts, despite such a significant representation, efficiency of scientific institutions remains low, - Almazbek Atambayev said in a letter to Prime Minister Dzhoomart Otorbayev. - Fresh personnel is needed and new approaches to the organization of scientific activity, which should contribute to the effective integration of science and education, the use of scientific advances in the economy and other areas.\"
Experts who suggested the head of the republic to reform the National Academy of Sciences concluded that during 60 years of existence, academics have made great achievements only in Soviet times. Objective and subjective reasons hindered to develop in the years of independence. \"In recent years there have been personnel changes in leadership positions in the National Academy of Sciences. However, even for people with outstanding leadership qualities were difficult to overcome the inertia of the bedrock of \"sockdolager\". The average age of doctors of sciences - 50 years, PhD - 40 years, academics - 73 years, corresponding members - 70 years,\" a letter to the government said.
According to them, Kyrgyzstan ranks 142 in the world in terms of citations and research publications. Overall, the rating includes 236 countries. This index reflects the performance of the scientific community of the country. Russian scientists have made no discoveries, didn\'t win the respect of colleagues from other countries, their work is not recognized on a global level. That what the advisory council under the President thinks.
However, the problem lies on the surface. The state has done nothing in order academics could discover new and unknown.
Work for food
The annual budget of the National Academy of Sciences is 252 million soms, $197 million of which is spent on salaries, and the rest - for utilities, the Social Fund and other expenses. On research and development money is not provided. Naturally, scientists have no incentive to engage in science and research.
Experts insist that science development begins from education. Local universities can\'t boast of any faculty or scientific achievements. \"The largest universities in the world - especially science centers, and then education. Kyrgyz students study for obsolete materials and techniques, being in complete isolation from the scientific and technological achievements. The Ministry of Education actually has withdrawn from the introduction and spread of innovation. The crisis in science has reached a level that it is impossible to leave the organization of science as it is. In fact, it\'s about saving the most valuable: it is necessary to keep the strongest schools, competitive research teams,\" they say.
The aim of reforming the sphere of science is to achieve competitiveness and balance. To do this one needs to create a new system of organization of the scientific sphere, the authorized state body on science, switch to project finance research. The National Academy of Sciences in this scenario will be given the status of non-governmental organization with the functions of a consultative body.
At the same time, the experts don\'t explain how the projects will be funded and on what basis they will be selected. And, most importantly, who will be engaged in researches.
On own resources
The scientific community is divided between those who support the reform, considering that the Academy of Sciences has outlived its usefulness, and those who strongly oppose the reform, calling it another madness of statesmen.
According to the First Vice Chancellor of Kyrgyzstan-Turkey Manas University Asylbek Kulmyrzaev, the country lacks financial resources for scientific development. Reform should be carried out since 1990s. \"Now it is necessary to take severe measures. The current state of science is deplorable. We mustn\'t turn a blind eye. Though late, but reform is required. Expert advice should consist not only of academicians, but also specialists in other fields in order to jointly develop a mechanism of proposals implementation,\" he told 24.kg news agency.
He does not believe that if the Academy of Sciences switches to self-financing, it can be considered as its liquidation. \"Definitely: National Academy of Sciences should be a public organization. This is a worldwide practice that scientific communities are not funded from the state budget. Then it will be motivated to search for new ideas, people, projects, - Asylbek Kulmyrzaev believes. - The academy must exist on contributions of members or international grants.\"
Scientist described his vision of the upcoming reform. The Academy of Sciences will be a platform for discussing problems of the country. Developed on the basis of recommendations the state will implement its policy. There are scanty budgeted finances on science. They will be spent on specific projects. \"It is enough to implement 3-4 big projects per year. The Academy of Sciences has already depleted its resources. I know many members of the National Academy of Sciences, who agree that it can no longer exist in its current form. It turns into a decorative element. It is over, it will be difficult for the first time, but then, with young and progressive people, the situation will change,\" Asylbek Kulmyrzaev noted.
All reforms look cheerfully on paper in the form of proposals. But will the current academics be able to destroy what they have built over the years, and let the younger generation o this system? After all, the problem of science lies in education, which is very poor in the country. And how do we get young scientists, if the education system is outdated, and all the same professors working at the Academy of Sciences teach students?
Never offer to teach fish to swim
The Director of the National Academy of Sciences Abdygany Erkebaev agrees that science as a whole needs reform. But what confuses him is that obscure advisory council, who is only a PhD, makes proposals. Despite the fact that during the years of his presidency, Almazbek Atambayev has never been in the academy, the director objectively took his proposal to reform the structure. \"Science needs development. I myself have repeatedly appealed to the authorities to make reforms. Another thing - recommendations of the Board of Education. The name itself says that it should deal with other issues, not science. It consists of unknown people without academic ranks. Making recommendations requires understanding the science, - Abdygany Erkebaev told 24.kg news agency. - In addition, discussion took place without the scientific community. On the upcoming changes I learned from the media, so this anonymity is surprising.\"
He believes that the experts want to impose a Western model on Kyrgyzstan, where science is developing in the universities. Kyrgyzstan got used to usual model, where the Academy of Sciences is engaged in innovation and research, and universities - learning, teaching and education. Especially there are not examples of successful elimination of the academies. For example, in Turkmenistan it was abolished at first, and then realized the mistake, and for many years restored it. In Kazakhstan since 2003 the Academy of Sciences was given the status of a public organization. However, it still financed by the state. Russia has also failed to make the academy public. The Russian Academy of Sciences, on the contrary, strengthened as a state.
In Kyrgyzstan, it will be difficult for science to develop through private investment. The economy is based mainly on a private business that only cares about itself. Entrepreneurs will not invest money in research. \"Expert council said nothing in their recommendations to amend the legislation, although there is a law of the National Academy of Sciences of the Kyrgyz Republic. I would agree on Western model, if there is sufficient funding,\" said Erkebaev.
Will the officials be able to initiate and complete the next reform? After all, it also requires much money. In addition to changes that the National Academy of Sciences will undergo, it will completely change the attitude to domestic science in order to bring it to the international level.
In the meantime, there is very revealing figure: in Kyrgyzstan there are 18,000 officials and only 3,000 scientists. Just compare: the budget allocates 1.3 billion soms for salaries of deputies, staff of the government and the president...