Coal procurement: games about tender
Series of misfortunes pursue Bishkek Heating and Power Plant (HPP). For the third time tender commission was unable to determine supplier of Kazakh coal. Autumn is around the corner, and the capital HPP has only 41,600 tons of fuel in its warehouses. There is a real danger that the HHP will be left without coal, unless, of course, the leadership of \"Electric Stations\" will be able to negotiate with supplier and bring down the price. And that, in turn, will have to ship coal at rapid pace.
Meanwhile requirements originally were limited to single-source procurement. One or the other party, lobbying personal interests, put a spoke in the wheel.
Party of Five
For several years the same companies participate in bids, and LLC \"Progress Company\" wins, which puts a higher price. But due to the fact that the rest of participants either forget to submit documents, or certificates of absence of debt, licenses, LLC \"Progress Company\" is the winner.
The first tender was canceled because of the rejection of applications of participants and an excess amount of purchases. Then the procuring entity has increased the budget from $1 billion 389.15 million soms up to 1 billion 559.25 million.
The second tender involved four companies. The tender commission recommended \"Power Stations\" to conclude a contract with \"Progress Company,\" which reduced the price from $42.79 up to $42 per ton of fuel till Lugovaya station. However, the Ministry of Finance admitted the tender invalid due to cost overruns. Now the amount is increased up to 2 billion 22 million soms.
For the third time the applications for the supply of 630,000 tons of Kazakh coal were filed by five companies. LLP \"Adalin\" estimated supply of fuel at $31.5 million till Lugovaya station, LLC \"Progress Company\" - at $34 million 794,900 till \"Alamedin\" station. LLP \"Zheskazgan Energosbyt\" set a price of $25.83 million till Lugovaya station. In this case, the supplier is willing to provide a discount for supply till \"Alamedin\" station. LLP \"Darsan komir\" is ready to deliver coal for $32.76 million till Lugovaya station. LLP \"Maikuben West\" for fuel set a price of $23.94 million till Lugovaya station.
Emergence of \"Maikuben West\" was a real surprise for contenders. It really made \"Progress Company\" nervous, whose representatives before opening of proposals tried to meet with members of the tender committee and observers. But the law prohibits conducting any negotiations with bidders until all procedures complete.
The excitement of the applicant was justified because \"Maikuben West\" set a price by $3 cheaper than \"Progress Company\". Other companies involved in trading formally.
Crowd scene for competition
\"Zheskazgan Energosbyt\", \"Darsan komir\", \"Adalin\" don\'t change their tender bids, insisting on set price. However, it isn\'t necessary to be a prophet to understand that: for the third time a request is rejected, since it exceeds the approved budget of \"Electric Stations\". If Kazakh companies really wanted to participate in the auction, they would revise the price in accordance with financial capabilities of the procuring entity. Previously this information was only available to members of the commission and served as one of the grounds for recognition of bids invalid. Now the amount allocated for the purchase is published on portal of public procurement, so that bidders do not have doubts.
Despite the fact that \"Zheskazgan Energosbyt\" put the best price for fuel, its application was rejected because of the number of violations. Firstly, the most important deviation from the requirements is that the company has never delivered coal. It is the power supply company, established in 2004. The company now provides electricity to more than 500,000 residents and 6,800 enterprises of Karaganda and East Kazakhstan regions. This information is available on the official website of the LLP. There isn\'t a word about the supply of coal and development of the field. However, the company has a letter of guarantee from the LLP \"Kuznetsky open-pit mine\" on the delivery of 630,000 tons of D. coal.
The Gordian knot
Studying the proposals of suppliers, the tender commission focused on two companies, the most suitable by its price and quality. However, in the process it became clear that \"Maikuben West\" has given a license to mine brown coal. The company\'s website also stated that, in accordance with the supplementary agreement of 2003, it extended a mining claim on mining allotment of brown coal at Shoptykolsky field. The company has the right to extract only the fuel of type B. In 2015-2017 years the minimum coal mining (5.3 million tons per year) is planned for 2015-2017.
The tender commission has requested a license for D-grade coal, but the company sent a contract addendum and protocol. Tempting price has forced members of the commission to make another request asking to send the license without related documents. In addition, the application identified deviations in fuel humidity. \"Electric Stations\" requested coal with humidity of no more than 15 percent, and the company pointed 18 percent.
Experts of Bishkek HPP rendered their opinion, indicating that one of the required qualitative parameters of coal in technical specifications is humidity. The declared by of LLP \"Maikuben West\" humidity of 18 percent is considered a deviation affecting the efficiency of a boiler, fuel consumption and clogging chutes.
The experienced on burning and storage of coal of B-grade of Maikuben deposit was conducted earlier in the HPP. This fuel didn\'t pass pilot testing. Submitted in the application fuel of D-grade of Maikuben deposit is closer to the characteristics of brown coal.
The issue of coal humidity could be solved by taking a trial batch. The difference at $3 per ton of coal and lack of a license, which later outweighed were scaled, as by that time \"Maikuben West\" didn\'t send clarifications and request had to be rejected.
The remaining company - \"Progress Company,\" which has already been awarded victory in the second tender, didn\'t have specific terms of the contract, which must be prescribed by the conditions of supply.
After rejecting the application of potential suppliers, the tender commission examined the proposals of \"Adalin\" and \"Darsan komir\" companies. However, they did not meet the company\'s budget. For supply of coal to Lugovaya station \"Electric Stations\" are willing to pay 1 billion 541.9 million soms and to \"Alamedin\" station - 1 billion 807.4 million soms without VAT. Suppliers also assessed the supply of coal to Lugovaya station for 1 billion 628.8 million and 1 billion 694 million soms respectively.
Deputies\' lobby
It should be noted that the first meeting of the tender commission was attended by representatives of the parliamentary deputy Altynbek Sulaimanov. They told the deputy that one of the providers filed a complaint of violations by commission. Although, before it there was only opening of applications, and there wasn\'t assessment, therefore, any violations were absent as well.
Supporters of the deputy could not coherently explain who invited them and which company complained. They explained only that the reception of the management of JSC \"Electric Stations\" called and invited to the meeting. However, it is not enough solid foundation to allow outsiders to the discussion, especially without written confirmation. People\'s deputy assistants were dissatisfied with this not hearty welcome, but they still had to leave the room.
But if skinhead athletes say that there won\'t be any problems, we will certainly wait for a showdown. And so it happened. Later on \"Electric Stations\" told 24.kg news agency that people of Sulaimanov threaten to check, if, the explicitly lobbied by them, \"Maikuben West\" won\'t win the tender.
Tender continues
The day before the tender commission recognized bids failed. Declaring repeated (fourth) tender is inappropriate. Terms of preparation of fuel are limited, and it is far from certain that a real supplier will appear or existing market participants will no longer play performances.
Obviously, JSC \"Electric Stations\" will negotiate directly with the coal miners. The one, who offers the lowest price, will win. Many companies do not have time for working on correction of mistakes, but will be able to prepare for subsequent purchases. LLP \"Maikuben West\" has a real opportunity to participate in supply not through rough lobbying and compete with LLC \"Progress Company,\" which, will have to reduce the price to deter a potential single buyer.