Customs Union: month for thinking
A month has passed since the Head of Kyrgyzstan announced the date of joining the Customs Union and the Common Free Market Zone. During this time, virtually nothing has done for implementation of the Roadmap items. Government officials and ministers visited the regions, once again on cloying roundtables talked about the pros and cons of approaching integration at roundtables and for the umpteenth time agreed on the fact that there is no alternative, but to comply with an unwritten order of President.
Meanwhile, it is not clear what the Ministry of Economy will start from and whether it will be able to implement the plans by its own. Or we have to ask for help from the neighbors again, but now the intellectual one?
Manage for 5 months
Roadmap for accession of the Kyrgyz Republic to the Customs Union was approved by the decision of the Supreme Eurasian Economic Council on May 29 in Astana. That moment marked the beginning of approximating the republic to the long-awaited, but unknown. Some fear the apocalypse in 2015, confident that the already impoverished country will become even poorer. Others, however, are optimistic and wait for miracles. Alas, in both cases there is only an illusion. In order to avoid the deplorable consequences it is necessary to work, rolling up the sleeves. And in order to achieve prosperity, it is necessary to work even more.
As a preliminary, Kyrgyzstan is to deal with the Roadmap and start implementing it. It consists of 10 sections, such as customs administration, technical, customs and tariff and non-tariff regulation, sanitary, veterinary, phytosanitary security, transport and infrastructure, countervailing measures, trade policy, statistics and other measures on development the infrastructure. Besides, it is necessary to bring the legislation into conformity with the agreements of the Customs Union, to develop mechanisms of distribution of sums of customs duties between CU states, to cancel control on the Kyrgyz-Kazakh border, to determine the timing of the transition period prior to enactment of technical regulations.
Kyrgyzstan hopes on certain preferences, but asking a lot is fraught with consequences. \"If Kyrgyzstan will include too many goods into the list of exemptions, the market into Kazakhstan will not open,\" the Deputy Economy Minister Daniel Ibraev believes. - When Kazakhstan entered into the union, it had about 400 exemptions. Now its number has declined. We understand that if we have more exemptions, the border with Kazakhstan will not open. Three countries are concerned that the goods will re-export. For the country it is important that the product will easily pass the border to the CU countries. Preliminary, there are 2,000 positions in our list - required for Kyrgyzstan goods. We divided them on the groups: particularly necessary goods and those that are subject to re-export. We will defend our positions.\"
Kyrgyzstan has many ambitions, but making a dead set and doing nothing is also disadvantageous. After all the money for implementation of the Roadmap and creation of the Development Fund has already been allocated, and hence the KR has no right to oppose. Work has already begun on the construction of logistics centers, inventory of laboratories is conducted. However, the timing of their entry has not yet been determined. Officials only decide on the basis of which laboratories the accreditation centers will be established. The Ministry of Industry and the Ministry of Agriculture as well - are the main departments, which will have to decide how to spend $1 billion, develop the primary projects. It is not an easy task, but there is no way back. And no matter what difficulties arise, Kyrgyzstan made a promise to join the union in January 2015.
Stubborn statistics
Nevertheless, members of the Eurasian Economic Commission confirmed that unrealistic points in the Roadmap on accession of the Kyrgyz Republic to the CU are absent. According to the Deputy Director of the Department of Integration of the Eurasian Economic Commission Sergey Shukhno, all that is written in the document have been approved. \"Kyrgyzstan is able to implement the Roadmap within the established deadlines. This will open a multi-million dollar market, where the country can export the produced goods,\" he noted.
In fact, the creation of favorable conditions for trade without customs barriers is one of the advantages of the association, which will apply uniform requirements and documents, confirming safety of the products for increase of exports. But if we can produce high-quality product? One thing - to build logistics centers, the other - to release products, which could have a certificate of quality.
While exports to the CU countries reduces and only becomes expensive due to the adoption of new rules and agreements. According to the Ministry of Economy, in 2013 compared to 2010, it decreased by 21.5 percent. Re-export volumes also reduced. According to customs statistics, imports of Dordoi and Kara-Suu markets decreases. From December to April 2014 the volume of trade in Dordoi market sharply reduced. Currently daily no more than 50 trucks with goods come, while in the previous years the market of machines received 150-200 cars. Imports from China in 2012 amounted to 401,900 tons and in 2013 - 329,900. However, when joining the CU, foreign trade with China will further reduce because of the inability of the re-export, although it is now 80 percent of imports from China in Kyrgyzstan, goes to the CU countries. As a result, entrepreneurs lose market and acquired trade relations, unemployment among those, who work in large wholesale markets and small business sector, will increase. At the same time the budget deficit will increase due to lower tax payments.
About \"juniors\" and \"seniors\"
At one of the roundtables Kazakh expert Rasul Zhumaly tried to open all secrets of the \"evil plan\" of Russia to deprive CIS countries of sovereignty. \"For Belarus integration - is an economic project, it wins and Kazakhstan lost some independence. After joining the CU trade balance in Kazakhstan was zero, i.e., how many products were bought, the same number was sold. Previously, we could purchase some of the goods in China and equalize prices. Now we can not do that. All we need to coordinate with the supernational body, headed by Russia - said the expert. - Also stringent sanitary standards are introduced. If in one meat product there are revealed bacteria, Russia fully bans the import of meat from Kazakhstan. For 4 years in Kazakhstan twice the national currency devalued twice. Russia is not ready for equal dialogue and integration. It has the role of \"elder brother\", the other states were given the role of juniors.\"
In a rather harsh speech Rasul Zhumaly continued: \"The Customs Union - a political order, but social and economic priorities must maintain it. In 2009 people and experts underestimated the risks that carried the integration; many took the Customs Union as a union of customs officers. But after the establishment of the CU they felt its shortcomings on their wallets. There were promises to build big enterprises, but in reality nothing happened. They said that competition of the three countries will intensify, the prices will drop. But in Kazakhstan prices have risen by 50 percent. Small and medium-sized businesses found themselves in a complex situation. They went bankrupt and closed.\"
According to him, there were moments when Kazakhstan intended to go out of the union at all. Therefore, from the Treaty on the Eurasian Economic Union the political aspects were removed.
However, do not forget that exactly Nursultan Nazarbayev is the initiator of the Customs Union.
How to make pluses from minuses?
There is an alternative view, supported by figures, that the Eurasian integration wasn\'t created for enrichment of a single country. According to the Eurasian Economic Commission, in May 2014, compared to last year prices for goods and services in the whole CU and Common Free Market Zone grew by 8.1 percent. Per month price increase was 0.9 percent.
The largest price increase was recorded in Belarus, especially for food products and paid services - 19.1 percent and 39 percent respectively. In Kazakhstan, compared with other countries - members of the association, recorded the smallest increase in prices - 6,8 - 7 percent. In Russia food prices grew by 9.5 percent, nonfood prices - by 5.1, paid services - by 8.4 percent.
Analysts of the Academy of Management under the President of the KR determined that Kyrgyzstan has much more tariff lines that give an advantage in trade with Kazakhstan and Russia, than with China. We have the greatest advantage of the KR in agriculture and textile industry. In the future they may be the key aspects. Changing trade, the growth of production in the country, according to forecast, could reach 8.8 percent.
Russia, Kazakhstan, Belarus moved to the next stage of integration - the creation of the Eurasian Economic Union. Currently the legal base of the Customs Union and the Common Free Market Zone amounts to more than 100 international treaties. Evolution of the Customs Union and the Common Free Market Zone in the Eurasian Economic Union, as well as the desire to unite Kyrgyzstan and Armenia, reflects the dynamic development of integration processes in Eurasia. Unlike the KR, Armenia has completed the implementation of the Roadmap and preparing to join the Eurasian Economic Union. At the last meeting of the Eurasian commission in Sochi much attention was paid to Armenia. Some consultations were held with Kyrgyzstan, because there are absent certain developments. Following the Armenian example, the republic has a chance to be on time. The main thing - do not get lost in the pros and cons of the integration.