Kyrgyz Parliament again talks about the need to toughen the responsibility of parents who don\'t educate and support children properly. Especially financial issue is especially topical - many people are not willing to pay child support, since some negligent moms or dads start a new life after divorce, and they don\'t want extra costs. In addition, a considerable part of these misfortune parents has antisocial lifestyle: booze, don\'t work, utterly neglect their houses or even lose it. Washed-up children end up in orphanages, children\'s homes, get on state support. Therefore, the norm for deprivation of parental rights of those who don\'t want to pay alimony was legally adopted.
About how things are today, and if this radical measure change the situation in a better way, the correspondent of 24.kg news agency spoke with the judge on civil cases of the Lenin district court of the capital Aida Seydakmatova.
- While we can\'t neither use this rule, nor to give any comments about this. Until it will be finally signed, it doesn\'t exist for judges. Generally, if we speak subjectively, I\'d be rather \"for\". The deprivation of parental rights has become more cases, the base - non-payment of alimony by malicious defaulters.
- Who is \"malicious\"?
- The fact of the matter is that there is no specific definition of \"malicious defaulters\". There are a number of actions and attributes, based on which the conclusion is made. For example, when one systematically evades support, goes abroad and is not interested in the child; doesn\'t pay, because is suffering from drug or alcohol addictions, which in itself is an aggravating circumstance. But all these accusations must be proved.
Unfortunately, more often it is impossible to trace how the payment is made, nobody writes receipts, doesn\'t issue checks - gave money into somebody\'s hands, and that\'s all. According to statistics, police almost has no cases on malicious non-payment of alimony. For such cases a criminal liability is provided, but for 2013 there were only two cases: one was sentenced to verdict eight months imprisonment, the other - year. As judicial investigators say, in order to prove that defaulter is \"malicious\", parents should 3-4 times notify the decision to make sure that this person received tendering, and to establish that he doesn\'t want to perform it. But to prove that \"he doesn\'t want\" is extremely difficult and especially my mother, who recovers alimony.
- What is the reason?
- There should be an interaction with the police, but in most cases it refuses to initiate criminal proceedings. The word \"malicious\" in the article - the only motive. Maybe after adoption of new norm something will change: it will be removed or additional explanations will be given. In practice, if alimony payer doesn\'t pay for 3-6 months, it can be regarded as \"malicious\". The most - are unemployed parents. Sum accumulates one, two, three months. Several times they receive notifications and warnings, and if he doesn\'t respond again, the base for applying criminal prosecution appears.
And now prove that he has money, and he doesn\'t want to pay. How to do it? Most of them are private entrepreneurs now, in fact - the unemployed, it is impossible to find out their income. They are offered to repay debts partially. Debtors immediately gets 500 soms, saying that is all he has - will pay when he has money, but refuse. But then again, disappears and everything starts again. As a result, we have a dime a dozen of such cases...
Recently, we don\'t wait till a criminal case will be opened; each judge still has his personal opinion. I was depriving parental rights if the parent doesn\'t show up for several months, and the debts of about 100,000; it is not just evasion but indifferent attitude when nobody needs the child.
- How defaulters can be pressed?
- Of course. The first is restriction on leaving the country. Information is sent to the border and the train service to the airports, in the passport office. But it is possible that a person can simply declare the loss of passport with all other documents and get it to the new name.
- Do you think that deprivation of right has positive aspects? It\'s bad when a children are taken away from their parents?
- Judge for yourself. Here is a recent case, which was considered by me: no father, a woman with five children, and all are on the road. Two youngest were taken away, and those who are older, were left. Termination of parental rights - a complicated process and not always unambiguous. Sometimes children live in social shelters, and neither mother nor their father don\'t support or care about, but in fact there are parents. Is that good? Nothing good. These children have less chance for prosperous future - for adoption in foster family. They are hostages of circumstances. We often consider the situation of children from SOS Children\'s Villages, Hermann Gmeiner School... No mom, brought and lost - what to do? What if the child will be able to get into a foster family? And one can\'t give it away - he has a mother.
- Can you give an example from your practice on deprivation of parental rights?
- There are many. Mothers are depriving mainly because of obscene lifestyle. But, for example, one father was deprived of parental rights not only for failing to parental responsibilities, which, of course, was the main reason, but also partly for selfishness. His children know nothing about him, for many years he showed no involvement in their lives. Suddenly he didn\'t allow her daughter to go to America when she was awarded a grant for free education for three years. It turns out that he had married again and also going to leave for the United States, and for that he needed a pure biography. Not only that he ruined their childhood, but also intended to spoil the future. By the way, soon his second wife also filed for divorce.
- Today, does the court continue to give priority to the mother?
- I can\'t say for sure. Only when the declaration indicates that, one asks to determine the place of residence with his mother, and the other side has no objections, then it quickly allowed. However, we consider each case individually. Today it is common when a child is one year old, and the parents are divorcing and share baby in court. Priority here, of course, has the mother, especially if the baby is breastfed. With older children, up to 10 years, we take into account if it is a girl or a boy, an attachment to the parent, and because of the specific features try to leave the child with her/his mother. We always invite a psychologist, the Department of Family and Child Support. But we can\'t say that mother has more rights than father. \"I am mother!\" indignant mothers say all the time.\" And he is Dad!\" I reply.
Recently I defined the place of residence of the children with the father, because their mother is in Japan for three years. She sends money, helps, but father can\'t take the children anywhere. There is one thing that we are particularly principled. We don\'t share children. Often, the father says: this let him live with me and the other with mom. If the parents mutually decide it outside the walls of the court than okay, but within the same judicial standards all children continue to live with either mom or father.
Earlier there was a tendency to define the child to his mother, now half suits for divorce are filed by fathers. They say: \"A child is with me and mom is disappeared without a trace\". A father officially has a court decision that defines residence of children with him, that he brings them alone, so at least he can get benefits for children, the benefits in school. Now children often remain with fathers. Seemingly, a traditional Kyrgyzstan.
- How alimony is set today?
- There are two procedures. I\'ll tell you in general terms. First - through a court order. In this case, the statement is written, evidence that the child lives with his mother is included, and a birth certificate, which states who his father is presented. If dad works, we give the requirement to provide certificates of employment with the actual income, accrue alimony in the amount of quarter of that sum - no more, no less. We recommend requesting that way.
Another - a flat fee when a parent doesn\'t work. The application is considered in the claim procedure. If actual revenue of alimony payer shows that he can\'t or don\'t want, then the amount is prescribed by the average wage. In Lenin district it is approximately 14,000, a child gets about 3,300 soms. This variant has a disadvantage. Lets suppose that a father is exacted alimony, but he doesn\'t work, he has a second wife and child, and even sick mother. How can I demand from him money? Over 50 percent of the fixed amount (14,000) I can\'t take into consideration. Have to count him, his current wife, for mother, and as a result the amount of alimony is miserable.
In many institutions, the salary is less than 14,000, and if he proves that he gets 6,000, he will pay a quarter of that amount. If he hides - will pay one quarter of the 14,000 soms. When we send entrepreneurs to the tax service, they don\'t go, most of the business isn\'t registered, but earnings are good. It is more profitable for them to be in the status of the unemployed and pay from the average of salary. But their former wives often punish them by stirring up tax service on them.
It is clear that the issue of maintenance of children should be solved honestly. Spouses didn\'t get along together, but for children they forever remain parents, and nobody has relieved of responsibility for offspring.