Should Kyrgyzstan wait for threats and from whom?
Riots in Tajik Khorugh and terrorist attack in Urumqi (XUAR) forced the expert community to digress from the crisis in Ukraine and pay attention to the Central Asian region. Moreover, according to many Kyrgyzstanis, with the withdrawal of coalition forces from Afghanistan in July 2014 the threat of worsening socio-political situation in the border countries will increase.
The version that the last event occurred is the links of one chain is being considered. The final tragic act will be in the south of Kyrgyzstan, where the pain of the June tragedy of 2010 is still felt. On the threshold of the fourth anniversary of Osh events the power, of course, is afraid of possible recurrence. Besides the constant conflicts in the border areas don\'t contribute to stability.
Equally disturbing is the fact that young Kyrgyzstanis, who received \"baptism of fire\" in Syria, are returning home. And how do they intend to apply their \"knowledge\" is unknown. \"We have information on Syria: how many of our citizens are there, how many people died. Intelligence agencies are working in this direction,\" the Vice Prime Minister Abdyrakhman Mamataliyev said recently at the session of Ar-Namys faction. But this answer raises even more questions, including the main one: are the security forces able to ensure the safety of the Kyrgyz Republic citizens in case of any emergency?
Who is next?
Some analysts, however, don\'t see any threat yet and don\'t believe that the effects of incidents in XUAR and Tajikistan will somehow affect the KR.
The Expert of the Russian Institute for Strategic Studies Azhdar Kurtov in his interview to 24.kg news agency noted that he is far from forming-up panic hypotheses. \"The riots in Tajik Khorugh are not related to China, he said. - Rather, they may be involved in drug trafficking from Afghanistan. But even if to assume some connection between the worsening situations in the region, it may lie in a different plane. Recently concluded agreements between the leaders of Russia and China in Shanghai, of course, deal a serious strike to the position of Western countries and the United States. Some experts and politicians in Washington, for several months, constantly criticize the administration of the President Obama that he made a strategic mistake in the conflict situation in Ukraine. Namely had conflicts with both, Russia and China, that contributed to the rapprochement of these two states. From the experts\' point of view, Obama had first \"succeed in his pressure\" on Moscow, involving China to this course,\" he says.
Azhdar Kurtov is not sure that gloomy forecast of recurrence of the events in southern Kyrgyzstan in 2010 will come true. \"Of course, such a scenario is not excluded - at least for the reason that the overall economic, social and ethno-confessional and political instability in Kyrgyzstan hasn\'t disappeared. But for the explosion in a particular place at a particular time the proper conditions should be provided. In the coming months, I don\'t see such conditions. In order they can develop, serious destabilization of the situation in the republic, or in the surrounding areas of neighboring countries is needed. Riots in Khorugh could become that way only theoretically. But in practice, I think the authorities of Dushanbe will take control of the situation, and therefore the spread of conflict in the region won\'t happen,\" the expert concluded.
The head of the Central Asia department of the CIS Institute and the member of the Russian Academy of Sciences Andrey Grozin supports him. According to him, neither Moscow nor Beijing, neither Brussels nor Washington has long-term strategy of building relations with Bishkek. The \"great uncles\" of international politics look at Kyrgyzstan as Somalia. \"Kyrgyzstan is used as a bargaining chip in the game with more powerful and influential states - such as Kazakhstan with its oil and Uzbekistan with its policies. Kyrgyzstan has no interest for them. And because of irresponsible statements and actions of some of our politicians,\" Andrey Grozin said.
He added that the genesis of acts of terrorism or disturbances lies in the carelessness of officials responsible for security. \"If we talk about the events in Urumqi or Khorugh, in the first case, the Chinese intelligence services don\'t exclude external factor. But there is no plan for the destruction of Central Asia. There is a reflex reaction to external stimuli from the U.S., which irritates the Russian policy in the region. But foreign policy priorities of the Kyrgyz Republic have already been identified. For example - approval of the Roadmap for joining the Customs Union of the KR,\" Andrey Grozin said.
Don\'t kick a sleeping dog
Another expert, Alexander Knyazev, is not so optimistic. In his opinion, it is obvious that a potential accumulated in the north- eastern Afghanistan and in several provinces of Pakistan plays and will play an important role. Since the autumn of 2010 there was military buildup. Along with this, militant groups mobilized as well, most of which consist of immigrants from the former Soviet Union, particularly from Central Asia. \"It was a noticeable influx of Uigurs from Xinjiang, the residents of the Kyrgyz south. In the context of these groups people often speak of the Islamic Movement of Uzbekistan (IMU), but it is not entirely accurate. IMU in its classical form was completed in 2002, when, after displacement from Afghanistan in Pakistan\'s Waziristan, \"Mukhalifat\" has appeared the IMU - internal opposition that led to a split in the organization then leaders and sponsors had changed. Now these groups that are changing names, organizational configuration, there are two major external patrons - security services in Turkey and Saudi Arabia. Urumqi attacks have rather \"Turkish trail,\" political scientist Alexander Knyazev expressed his opinion.
He also believes that the events in Khorugh have completely different motives. And one of the main reasons is that the Gorno-Badakhshan Autonomous Province - the poorest of Tajikistan\'s regions - deprived of the attention of the official authorities. \"Therefore, the basis for determining the natural social protest has been there for a long time, and they are only amplified by inadequate actions of Dushanbe, which made a bet solely on force control over this difficult region. Such situation consistently is used from outside, but known Sunni radicalism is not involved in the protest,\" Alexander Knyazev said.
Another root of evil the analyst sees in the Aga Khan Foundation, under the auspices of which a serious network of non-governmental organizations was formed. \"As expected, all of them aren\'t politicized at this stage; they are busy by anything - from education to dealing with everyday social problems. But the essence of network activity consists in the fact of consolidation of this mesh network under new slogans at the right time. So it was in Serbia, in Georgia, in Libya, Ukraine and Kyrgyzstan in 2005. In this sense, the structure of the Aga Khan is the same as that was created by USAID or the Soros Fund,\" Alexander Knyazev said.
He says that in the case of expansion zones of instability territory of south of the Kyrgyz Republic - and the whole country (in addition to the direct neighborhood) - transit, uniting two conflict zones can be used. This is taking into account that for the \"island of democracy\" - and it is noted by all analysts - typical low level of stability, catastrophic weakness of law enforcement agencies, as well as the possibility of adding to the potential for conflict with domestic resources are typical. Then the extension of the conflict zone on the territory of Kyrgyzstan is more likely. And if you consider Afghan territory as the main base of terrorist groups, at least two corridors pass through the KR: Khorugh -Osh and Afghan Darwaz-Karategin zone of Tajikistan-Batken region.
We are few but roses
The Gorno-Badakhshan Autonomous Province of Tajikistan is a major transit corridor through which the lots of drugs in Afghanistan pass. \"The Tajik authorities had eventually applied adequate measures. If they can bring the situation under control, some extent and the flow of drugs through Kyrgyzstan will be reduced. As for Afghanistan, there military-political situation is ambiguous. Big concern causes the members of illegal armed groups and terrorist organizations who participated in Egypt and Syria. Part of them are located in the province of Wazirista, where, according to the latest information, serves a considerable number of our compatriots, but there is no accurate data. According to various estimates, there are between 60 and 400 citizens of the Kyrgyz Republic. The problem is that we don\'t have accurate data so far, and it is not only the lack of Kyrgyz security forces, but also of neighboring countries. The terrorist international is formed there,\" the former Vice Prime Minister of the Kyrgyz Republic on the power block Tokon Mamytov says.
He adds that, in its turn, adopted measures by Afghan authorities lead to the fact that some militants retreats, troops are defeated and captured. This influenced on the fact that many people escape from there and return to the native land.
\"And it will be used by certain forces to destabilize the situation and rocking in the Fergana Valley. The second round of elections in Afghanistan will be held one of these days, and, again, this question arises. Results will affect, and it depend on them, weather the situation in the Central Asian region, in particular here, will begin to worsen,\" Tokon Mamytov said.
At the same time, he believes that there won\'t be direct effect of the terrorist attacks in China on Kyrgyzstan. But advised not to discount the fact that it is an activity of the Islamic Party of Eastern Turkestan, and its adherents can use our territory as a transit zone for subversion. \"Militants can go through Kyrgyzstan, as it was in February, when the border area of the Issyk-Kul province the citizens of the neighboring country were killed,\" Tokon Mamytov reminded.
He stressed that it is early to sound the alarm. According to him, when he was vice prime minister, law enforcement agencies have developed a plan on warning attacks of terrorists and extremists. And in this work, as the former official assured, GKNB, the Ministry of Internal Affairs, the Border Guard Service and the Ministry of Defense were involved. \"I can\'t say in what direction they act, but it is conducted. Law enforcement forces of the KR are able to repel and prevent the escalation of the situation and keep everything under control,\" Tokon Mamytov optimistically concluded.
Hopefully, the analytical things of experts and general statements are correct, and soon the fragile peace in the Central Asia Region won\'t be disturbed. And coming parliamentary elections in Kyrgyzstan in 2015 won\'t become a detonator.