USD87.45EUR95.90RUB1.07
24.kg

Kubatbek Baibolov: Malpractice is still stronger than law in Kyrgyzstan

18:40, 26 May 2014, Bishkek - 24.kg news agency
Makhinur NIYAZOVA

The President of the country Almazbek Atambayev signed the amendments to the Criminal Code, involving punishment for \"misleading information on crime\". Most of the journalists and representatives of civil society, who appealed to the head of the state, seeking to form democracy, were left unheeded.

Even after the adoption of the law some officials said that the media should not sound the alarm, saying that they will not touch them. However, lawyers hold exact the opposite opinion. Is this true? 24.kg news agency asked the former Prosecutor General Kubatbek Baibolov about this.

 

- Kubatbek Kalbekovich, let\'s start with history. Whom, when and why started to be brought to responsibility for false information?

- The criminal law has all the time the Article 127 \"Slander\" and the Article 128 \"Insulting the honor and dignity\". The same article is in the criminal legislation of almost all countries of the world. But at all times journalists, at the instigation, the society had a negative attitude to this norm. Media representatives believed that this article is formed against them only because there was always confusion between libel per se and the practice of law enforcement. Slander by itself - a disgusting thing. The state, thus, takes on the responsibility to protect its citizens from this evil. But in practice, our law enforcement and judicial systems used this article to persecute truth-seekers - and not only journalists, but also politicians. And that was the reason for such a negative attitude.

At the dawn of independence and in the romantic period of our democracy, when we see it permissiveness, in my memory there was triple attack on this article, including from the part of journalists. And I will not hide, I was always against its abolition, because I clearly understood what it might end with. Now for many it is obvious: this article was sobering and restraining factor. We should clean up the practice of libel persecution of dissidents in order the state to punish for libel and slander, not for freedom of speech, and all would stand in its place. We have long worked to ensure that the state does not interfere with political persecution of slander. They are completely different things.

 

- It is obvious that this article was initiated by politicians to settle accounts with each other. But journalists suffer as a result. Do not you think so?

-Journalists have always believed that this article is directed against them. After all, people in everyday life, it happens, insult each other, but they don\'t settle the problem through the court. And when the media write about it, the reaction is different. The law will really affect the writing and shoot brethren, as well as politicians and statesmen, who have at all times dealt with opponents through the use of legal documents. This abhorrent practice spawned a negative attitude to this article.

Politicians at all times dealt with each other. And it wasn\'t necessary to model and expect that after abolition of this article we will be swamped with mud and slander. Initially, all avidly read publications, where someone is insulted, while experiencing voluptuous feelings... Now there was a period of sobriety. Today there is no politician who \"would not poured with slop\".

 

- The Civil Code contains an article on the protection of honor and dignity. What prevents to apply it?

That\'s right of moneybags - denigrate vulnerable groups, including journalists. Stipulated penalties in civil procedure does not stop people to slander, especially in the political struggle.

 

Especially grisly stories are perceived. And all media practice in its filing, and citizens will gladly read it. Nobody reads about anything positive, and does not perceive as a journalist. They must constantly give fresh and interesting news. And if you write about the creative - is anyone interested?

Now, distinguishing truth from falsehood is practically impossible, and people do not care too much about it. They do not care how much people will be offended. The word on the lips of a journalist - the same incisive weapon, like a knife. It hurts even harder. Why for carrying bladed weapons we deprive a person of liberty, and for a word, which is the same weapon, do not prosecute? But the new government, following the lead of society and because of negative attitude to this article, as well as for their own PR, abandoned state responsibility to protect and defend the honor of citizens, abolishing this article. The state should take responsibility.

 

- Returning to the same, what the former \"family-clan regimes\" were criticized for?

- It\'s hard to understand why the authorities needed this article. If we assume that they are very concerned about the state of crime in the sphere of ​​justice, and the article about false information, remember, in the section \"Crimes against justice\" and then there are other rules.

Those, who canceled the article \"Slander\", were criticized themselves. But they can\'t return the previous article in the Criminal Code, as laid down in the Constitution, as there isn\'t a legal prosecution for insulting the honor and dignity. Therefore they decided to stop on the other side - through the Article 329 \"False denunciation\" by changing the last word on the \"information\". But they did not consider that libel in criminal law refers to \"individual freedom\" section and \"false information\" - to \"crime against justice\". They have different generic objects.

 

-Taken into account current realities and imperfection of the judicial system in the Kyrgyz Republic, will this law be used as intended? May it become a tool of dealing with undesirable?

- The law itself is correct, but we are talking about our vicious practices. To institute criminal proceedings and take somebody into custody there must be a motive. Given our vicious practice, the adopted article is a much more dangerous and \"hard\" compared to slander. Because any message about crime falls under the signs of this article. Today, law enforcement and judicial authorities do not bother on proving of actual knowledge of the committed act. If you need to put a man in prison, no one will intervene. And they won\'t prove much.

Statement of a victim to law enforcement agencies, in general, also falls under the signs of this article. If guilt isn\'t proven and a person is acquitted, even being involved in a crime, who wrote a statement falls under the same article. Journalist, who wrote in the media about a crime, also falls under the signs of this article.

 

-Whom will these amendments affect at first?

- Freedom of speech. This is a serious blow to it. And this media tools - reporters. I think that journalists will be the first victims, and it will happen very soon. These processes will be illustrative.

 

-In their excuse, shall we say, proponents of the law cite the example that many countries of the world have such an article, and it supposedly does not affect freedom of speech in those states. Is that so?

- Countries that are listed in the certificate - the U.S., Germany, Belgium, Austria, Britain, Denmark, Spain, Lithuania, Latvia, Norway, Poland, Sweden and the others, democratically advanced states with quite different control mechanisms and modalities of laws, rather than with us. There are other law enforcement agencies, judges and citizens. Different mentality. They do not deal with each other, using subtleties of the legislation. Any law must be built according to local conditions, and it is the most important thing.

 

- Do developers of bills - MPs - did not have to consider these factors?

- I am confused why this block in the Parliament is supervised by legally illiterate people, who have never worked in this direction. The initiator of the bill Eristina Kochkarova hasn\'t worked a single day as a judge, prosecutor or lawyer. Our criminal law is very schematically and institutionally formed. And they break it.

 

- Today, a large part of the population abuses \"yellow press\" in a blatant lie. Will this law help to avoid \"ushaki\" (rumors)?

- This amendment takes only one segment - report on a crime. In general, the state of freedom of expression and journalists of this article will not change. But there will be localized impact. Norm will appled the first time selectively. After it, it will be safely forgotten, as many others. We have a lot of good articles in the Criminal Code, but they do not work.

This article distract us from big things. If we lived in more mature society, we would think about correction of the state elite formation rules, from which everything would change, including journalists. Instead of it we amuse ourselves with fragments.

We have to decide what state we are forming. If totalitarian and dictatorial one, these measures are justified, because they do not fit into the framework of a democratic society with market economy. We have a perfect alogism: we declare values, but in practice we take steps in the other direction.

 

 


CONTACTS

SOCIAL MEDIA

TelegramYouTubeWhatsAppFacebookInstagram

© News Agency «24.kg» - News of Kyrgyzstan. All rights reserved. All information posted on this website is intended for personal use only and may not be distributed without the written permission of NA «24.kg». The editorial team is not responsible for the content of reprinted materials and statements of individuals. +18