April trial. There is no answer to the main question…
Pleadings in the trial on April events finally ended. The last thing is that defendants must come up with the last statement, then the chief judge will retire to the deliberations room for passing a verdict, after which there will be rendered a sentence. Obviously, Damir Onolbekov faces worth daunting task as many issues, including very important and crucial, have remained unresolved.
60 volumes +
The whole country has been waiting for a verdict on this high-profile case for nearly four years. Criminal case on the event of April 7, 2010 was initiated the next day after the tragic date, the investigation on so uneasy case lasted only six months, and already at the first court session, which took place on November 17, 2010, it became clear - the investigation hastened.
The case was accompanied by mass flagrant breaches at the investigation stage, as defense attorneys and lawyers have repeatedly stated about it. Members of the investigative team of the Prosecutor General continued to incriminate unreasonably. When 60 volumes were sent to the court, it failed. Gaps by gaps appeared within the trial at every session. According to lawyers, it was possible to eliminate many of them could only sending the case back for further investigation. But the court was firm and continued the process, facing new facts and new violations committed during the investigation.
Protection of the accused, in its turn, provides more and more evidence of the innocence of their clients. That is why the volume of the criminal case is growing and the public learns more details of the events, and the circumstances of the biographies of some \"heroes of the April revolution\".
A lot of video and photo materials, in particular proving very non-peaceful nature of \"peaceful\" rally of April 7, 2010, were added to the criminal case within the criminal proceedings. Whether it was legal then to prosecute soldiers acting on the law and guarding and object number 1 from an armed assault - this is the first question that the court has not given a clear answer to.
\"Appointed\"
Speaking in the pleadings, the defence reiterated the gaps of the investigation, that, despite attempts of prosecutors and the aggrieved, weren\'t eliminated in the court. Maybe because objectivity of this case wasn\'t a goal of the investigation? Today, many agree that the majority of the defendants are \"appointed\" by members of the caretaker government, accused of all sins.
\"Guilt and innocence of the defendants in case of April events were resolved not by the court, but the interim government,\" the lawyer Lyubov Ivanova, protecting the interests of the former head of the president\'s office Kanybek Zhoroev, stated. She noted that during the investigation her defendant was accused under Article 304 \"Abuse of official position\" of the Criminal Code by three times. And when the case was sent to the court on October 12, 2010, at the direction of the Deputy Prime Minister Azimbek Beknazarov, supervising law enforcement agencies, it was withdrawn and the four defendants Elmurza Satybaldiev, Nurlan Tursunkulov, Oksana Malevanaya and Kanybek Zhoroev were imputed even killing of \"peaceful demonstrators\". The records of the General Prosecutor\'s Office have documents, confirming the words of the lawyer.
The first who declared about this document was the defendant the former State Advisor to President Elmurza Satybaldiev. Later, he presented it to the court. The certificate, signed by the former deputy attorney general Viktor Ivanov and the head of the department Kylychbek Boorsokov, informs about the meeting, held on the eve of the beginning of \"high-profile\" trial on April events.
The curator of security forces of the interim government Azimbek Beknazarov held a meeting with the head of the department of the presidential administration Busurmankul Tabaldiev, the Chief of the State Penitentiary Service Sheishenbek Baizakov, military prosecutor Aibek Turganbaev, the deputy head of the SNB Marat Bekenov, the acting Chief Justice Feruza Dzhamasheva, the Chairman of the Military Court Nurlan Ashymbekov, the Deputy Prosecutor General Viktor Ivanov and the Head of the General Prosecutor\'s Office Kylychbek Boorsokov on October 15, 2010.
The meeting was held in connection with the beginning of the trial of the criminal case on April 7 events scheduled for October 25, 2010.
Beknazarov asked Viktor Ivanov why Oksana Malevanaya, Kanybek Zhoroev, Nurlan Tursunkulov and Elmurza Satybaldiyev aren\'t charged with the aggravating Article 30-97 \"Complicity in murder\" of the Criminal Code of the Kyrgyz Republic. Ivanov explained that the former high-ranking officials charged with abuse of office, and on the results of the investigation they were charged under the Article 304 of the Criminal Code and the case was sent to court. Moreover, Ivanov said that the head of the criminal investigation department of particularly important cases of the General Prosecutor\'s Office Uchkun Karimov is accountable only to the Attorney General by his functional duties,\" stated in the certificate.
\"The military prosecutor Ayibek Turganbaev supported Beknazarov, saying that, if the circumstances aggravating these defendants actually stopped during the investigation, then each of them could be sentenced to five years of imprisonment only. Beknazarov suggested that it can cause resentment on the part of relatives of the killed on April 7 and indignation of the people. This view was supported by the Chairman of the Military Court Ashymbekov,\" as reported in the certificate.
It is noted that after the meeting Azimbek Beknazarov instructed the Deputy Prosecutor General Ivanov \"without noise and flurry\" return the case, which, at that time, had already been sent to the court for consideration on the to the point, and charged the former head of the presidential secretariat Oksana Malevanaya, the chief of the president\'s office Kanybek Zhoroev, the advisor to the president for defense and security Elmurza Satybaldiyev and the attorney general Nurlan Tursunkulov under the Article 30-97. After that, the case was sent to court.
Then Elmurza Satybaldiev explained that this document clearly demonstrates that several of the accused in court are \"appointed\". If there is any sense speaking in your defence after this apparent \"order\" of the authorities? Satybaldiev believes that there isn\'t. And he refused to speak in the debate, calling the arguments \"unfounded\".
Whether it was legal to consider a case in court - is another question left open.
\"Scapegoats\"
Hostages of the political situation became the military of special forces \"Alfa\" GKNB and \"Arstan\" State Security Service. Their lawyers believe that the Prosecutor General\'s Office has exceeded the powers, bringing them to responsibility those, who have acted within the law and statute.
\"Scapegoats\" are sitting on the dock and the real culprits escaped responsibility. As a result there was an irreparable damage to the reputation of both judicial and law enforcement bodies. The demoralization of policemen and soldiers only worsens, as their colleagues are tried for the implementation of laws and regulations,\" their lawyer Ulan Dastan uluu noted.
The defender of employees of \"Arstan\" Special Forces Kubanichbek Kudaibergenov even called the arguments of the investigation absurd. According to him, in some of the arguments of the investigation \"logic is absent, but, despite this, the case was sent to the court and was examined\". \"The investigation wasn\'t carried out at all. Servicemen were accused by acting at that time power, in particular, member of the interim government Azimbek Beknazarov. According to the materials of the criminal case, it turns out that, my client fired 77 and 306 shots and never overshot. While all other defendants made the same. Besides, according to the arguments of the investigation, some bullets after firing by the accused, who were on the roof of the White House, changed the trajectory and got through the wounded horizontally,\" said the lawyer.
The investigation didn\'t specify who killed and whom. There isn\'t answer to the question, who is to blame that some victims received shotgun wounds and died from blunt force trauma. It is still unknown how could the killed in very different places, and even a few tens of kilometers away from the scene be included in a number of victims in the events of April 7 at Ala-Too Square and near the Government House.
\"Accused in absentia\"
Another question left unanswered: whether it is lawful to pass sentence to a person against whom the investigation was conducted in absentia. And if the situation with the former head of the Presidential Secretariat Oksana Malevanaya is more or less clear (immediately after the events of April 2010, she was in the country, didn\'t escape and participated in investigative activities, being on demand), the others - former President Kurmanbek Bakiyev, his brother Zhanysh Bakiyev, his son Marat Bakiyev, as well as ex-prime minister Daniyar Usenov and the commander of \"Arstan\" Esenbai Baiysh uluu, as required by law, weren\'t aware of the decision on criminal charges against them, they were never questioned within the investigation and at the trial... However, these mass violations do not prevent the presiding judge Damir Onolbekov to continue considering the case against them. The lawyers declared more than once about transferring the criminal case into a separate legal procedure. All these petitions were rejected.
As for Oksana Malevanaya, who fled the country, when the crowd of aggressive \"fans\" on the part of the victims at the Sports Palace arranged not just total outrage, shouting threats to burn the houses, dealing with children of the defendants, including the former head of the secretariat of Kurmanbek Bakiyev, her \"escape\" is clear for many inhabitants. When you fly in a bottle when you are, when you shout threats to kill your child , What mother would not be scared when you are thrown bottles, when you are insulted on a national basis, when you are threatened to kill you own child?
Sentence to be passed soon
For making such, without exaggeration, difficult decision the court will need more than one day. It is possible that the judge in chambers will hold more than one week, and maybe, a month. To examine the criminal case, consisting of 88 volumes for today, is not easy. Besides, Damir Onolbekov will review all the collected during the investigation video and photos material as well.
The investigation couldn\'t answer the main question: who shot protesters in the square and at the Government House on April 7, 2010. The court also couldn\'t find the truth. During the interrogation, the victims stated that the protesters at Ala -Too Square people in police and military uniforms shot too. \"But none of them were identified; furthermore, there wasn\'t even an attempt. Investigation of the event of April 7 was extremely poor, the files are full of contradictions and gaps,\" the lawyer Ulan Dastan uluu noted.
The state prosecution recognized it as well. Speaking in the debate, the military prosecutor of Bishkek Azamat Mambetov noted that \"within the trial the actions of military operations of other law enforcement agencies weren\'t assessed\". \"Only sniper groups were brought to responsibility, although, according to the expert, coincidence of bullets, extracted from the bodies of the dead and injured with a weapon of the defendants, wasn\'t identified,\" he said.
Nevertheless, the accused Special Forces officers have to endure humiliation for \"clear\" weapon. And, as stated by the former deputy chief of staff of the State Guard Service Daniyar Dunganov: \"The military are forced to make excuses for a crime that they didn\'t commit, acting on the principle of \"success in never blamed\". \"We can\'t argue with this statement.
The question is open
The aggrieved and witnesses told about some shooters and snipers on the roofs of other buildings - Ilbirs, Historical Museum, the Assembly of People of Kyrgyzstan, the House of Trade Unions and the others. The activist Toktaiym Umetalieva, who was present at Ala-Too that day, also mentioned about them. As a witness in the trial she stated, that a sniper fell down from the roof of Ilbirs building, as he was injured or killed. \"He was shot out of the building, located in the south-eastern direction from the White House. We\'ve all seen his body, which was taken away by ambulance. Since then no one knows who that shooter was,\" the human rights activist said.
The member of the events Emilbolot Kyshtobayev in the court stated that he had found in the an submachine gun in an irrigation ditch near the Government House, a little further a full magazine with live ammunition lied. \"There were snipers on the roof of the White House, so I took the gun and began to shoot at them. I hid behind a column and sometimes come out to fire a shot,\" he explained.
Emilbolot Kyshtobayev noticed that as a result of one of the shots from the roof of the Government House a rifle fell down. \"What happened with a sniper, I do not know, maybe I shot him. I was not drunk, otherwise I would shoot at cadets, I had a full magazine,\" he added.
However, none of \"Alfa\" and \"Arstan\" Special Operations Directorate personnel died and wasn\'t wounded. Consequently, either the witness shot at a sniper from another unit, whose employees aren\'t targeted accused in the investigation, or he\'s lying. And such contradictory testimony in court sounded enough. But there isn\'t clear why the investigation has not paid attention to them. As to the question who killed 77 people and left another 306 injured? And, it seems that the answer to this most important issue in the coming years is not beneficial to anyone in Kyrgyzstan. After all, someone may not like the truth, including the participants of the historical tragic events...