Payment system, as it turned out on the background of the Ukrainian events, is one of the components of economic security of any country. And almost all countries of the world provided such systems long ago. However, the Russian experience should serve as example - the imposition of sanctions by the international operators, registered in the United States, immediately hit the economy. It seems that Kyrgyzstan has its own payment system, but how it will ensure the security of payments is a higher questionable matter. The bill roams about the offices of the Parliament for already a year and the presidential administration, while lobbyists from foreign \"payments\" are trying to delete a point, where processing of information should take place on the territory of Kyrgyzstan.
How to pique ... not our story
Visa and MasterCard international payment systems from March 21, 2014 without warning ceased to serve customer cards of four Russian banks, \"Russia\" Joint-Stock Bank, Sobinbank JSC, SMP Bank and InvestCapitalBank JSC. According to the Central Bank of the Russian Federation, these actions have touched seven banks in Russia, suffered owners of several hundreds of thousands of cards.
In 2010 a project on creation of a national payment system in Russia was discussed at the meeting with the Russian President, but according to media reports, two payment systems are actively used services in the country, lobbying for their interests. If, initially, the development of a special section of the law provided for the establishment of processing within the country, then further advancement of this section of the bill was withdrawn. International systems undertook similar actions in Kyrgyzstan.
\"In due time Russian banks were rich, it was prestigious to have own system. The issue of creating a national system of payment was not so relevant as in our country. Each bank has spent huge amounts of money to create own ones. It would be very inconvenient to abandon them and invest in something else. Therefore Russia had active development of international systems,\" the Head of the Payment Systems Department of the National Bank Evelina Lelevkina, says.
\"Many countries have their own payment systems, using local maps. And there are countries that initially limited the development of international card systems to allow its own internal system of cashless payments to develop. This is not quite correct, as people travel outside of their country, and they need a tool to pay there. But people with low incomes who practically do not leave the country for social projects - pensions, benefits and salaries - need to have own national system,\" the NB KR experts add.
Currently, within imposing sanctions, the Russian State Duma introduced a bill banning the placement of operating centers and payment clearing centers of these systems outside the country.
Russian economist Mikhail Khazin writes that the liberal lobby in the government and the Central Bank of Russia impedes it in order to prevent creation of a full ruble financial system.
\"This is well illustrated by the way the Central Bank and Sberbank agreed regarding promotion deliberately failed project to create a national payment system based on \"universal card\" of SberBank, though there is Global Payment System infrastructure that allows to create such a payment system just for a month. However, almost all the Central Bank\'s actions today are aimed to maintain or increase the dependence of our economy on dollar,\" he writes.
How to pique ... our story
We don\'t have so much at stake. However, the need to protect our citizens - a fundamental matter, especially when the world practice has developed a precedent of open financial pressure.
The draft Law \"On payment system of the Kyrgyz Republic\" still not signed, although it was adopted by the Parliament. The parliament also accepted it with moans and groans and payer tried to cross out a fundamental point about finding a processing center in the country to the bitter end.
But the document was adopted in the first edition, and the processing of payment cards and the final settlement of accounts must still be carried out in Kyrgyzstan. However, after the document was submitted to the Office of the President of the Kyrgyz Republic, the document was sent back for revision. Members of the conciliation group are suggested to change the wording 4 of the Article 20 and 6 part of the Article 15 in order to allow carrying out processing of payments in national currency outside Kyrgyzstan!
\"Draft law on payment system was developed in 2009, where for the financial security of the country it was immediately provided a point, stating that all domestic payments in national currency must be handled in the territory of Kyrgyzstan. The Parliament approved the law in three readings, but then was returned with objections, as certain contradictions concerning Visa International System arose on these points. Their representatives began to openly obstruct our law. For economic and financial security of the country it is necessary to eliminate the risks of sanctions and international systems should not affect our decisions, processing payments in national currency should be implemented here,\" the NB KR experts say.
Elimination of such formulations in law carries significant risks for the financial security of the country. Implementation of processing outside the country makes Kyrgyzstan dependent on the international payment systems and allows providing both political and economic pressure on decisions, taken in the country.
The adopted by the Parliament draft law does not provide for a ban on the use of cards of international payment systems on the territory of the Kyrgyz Republic, but only requirement for commercial banks on implementation of the processing and mutual settlement of accounts in the national currency on the territory of our country, what is feasible for all systems.
Otherwise, information about payments in KGS, including budgetary payments, may be sent outside the country and used to intervene in the internal affairs of Kyrgyzstan similar to the situation with Russia (not to mention the risk of introduction of various kinds of sanctions). Especially, that tariff on taking such payments through the international system is much higher than domestic payments in the same systems.
\"Budgetary payments in national currency shall be treated outside the country and depend on the decisions of foreign payment systems. Such payments are domestic, and the order of their processing and settlement of accounts must be implemented in accordance with the legislation of the Kyrgyz Republic at affordable rates in order to protect consumers and competition in the market for bank credit cards,\" the experts say.
What do we have?
Processing - a center for processing of card payments for calculation of net positions, what bank owes another bank and how much. A single interbank processing in Kyrgyzstan was created under the state program, for what we attracted a loan of the World Bank. It was counted for needs of the whole republic that allowed entering more than one million cards.
Creating a single interbank processing payment processing for all types of cards supposed creation of a single system. These works were carried out since 2002, and the system was implemented in December 2006. At least 18 banks took part in Kyrgyzstan, the card is accepted in almost by all terminals and ATMs. Shareholders of the system are 14 banks and 2 nonbank organizations.
\"Elcart\" card is designed not only for domestic market, but in the near future, one can make international payments through it. Processing center also accepts Visa and Union Pay. In the short term MasterCard will also be able to enter this system.
Outside the country it is still impossible to use \"Elcart\" cards. \"But now we are working with Union Pay to produce co-branded cards, it will combine the logos of the two systems. \"Elcart\" will operate in Kyrgyzstan by our rules, after leaving the country- by the rules of Union Pay,\" Evelina Lelevkina informed.
Real risks
\"The situation that is observed now in Russia on Visa cards, don\'t touch us directly,\" the expert of the National Bank says. But if any sanctions are imposed in terms of international money transfer systems, Kyrgyzstan will have significant risks. \"If there are sanctions from these systems, they may affect the banks of Kyrgyzstan, as we have quite a lot of cross-border transfers on different systems,\" Evelina Lelevkina said.
Cards in figures
The amount of bank payment cards demonstrates dynamics: national system cards are used 4 times less than the cards of international systems.
Over half a million (551,939) cards belong to two foreign operators. Visa has 263,532 cards, Master Card - 1,129, Golden Crown (Russia) - 287, 278 cards.
\"Elcart\" National System released up to 156,998 units.
Total number of active terminals and ATMs by systems amounted to: by international systems Visa & MasterCard - 206 ATMs and 1,714 terminals; by national system \"Elcart\" - 344 ATMs and 1,313 terminals; by international system \"Golden Crown\" (Russia) - ATM 281 and 565 terminals.
Services for production and maintenance of international Visa cards provide 9 commercial banks. MasterCard - only one bank. \"Golden Crown\" - 4 commercial banks. \"Elcart\" services virtually all our banks.
At least 2.8 million payments totaling 839.5 billion soms were made through the interbank payment system in 2013. The total volume of card transactions amounted to 51.9 billion soms and increased by 47 percent compared with 2012.