“Cooperation” operation or running in place?
After collapse of the Union the leadership of independent Kyrgyzstan resolutely started on the development of democracy. No less emphatically than the Bolsheviks, who organized collective farms by withdrawing peasants\' lands and forced unification, Kyrgyz authorities went back. They distributed land, cattle and properties of collective and state farms to peasants and discovered them the way to unknown future of the market economy.
Results of reforms
Villagers used the received \"good\" as they could. Some managed to organize farm households and bear a heavy burden of a farmer. Those who could not, allotments sold or rented land allotments. In short, they survived as best they could. The land and agrarian reform resulted in creation of more than 350,000 farms throughout the republic. The average size of arable land of peasants - 2.7 hectares. This is throughout the republic. And if we consider provinces, the least are registered in Jalal- Abad province - by 1.2 hectares. In such a situation it is not surprising that the provision of internal market with its own products is far from desirable. So, it is 62.5 percent by bread products, meat - 57.8 percent, vegetable oil - 34.2, sugar - 12.2, fruits and berries - 23.1 percent.
According to the academician Zhamin Akimaliev, in comparison with 1990, the fertility of arable lands decreased by 50 percent. This confirms the fact that for the last few years, wheat yield amounts to on average 25 tons per hectare, while in times of the Union it reached 35 quintals on the average.
There is safety in numbers
It became clear early in the agrarian reform that small farms can not be highly effective, as households became naturalized gradually. The law on cooperation was adopted in 1991 as an alternative way of development. Henceforth there were made changes and other regulations relating to organization and development of cooperatives were adopted as well. But serious development of the co-operative movement failed. The experience of foreign countries with developed agriculture shows that the sate itself plays a significant role in the formation of cooperatives. The U.S. agricultural sector, which occupies a leading position in the global market, receives great financing from the government. Including soft loans, leasing of agricultural machinery and assistance in fertilizers\' supply.
Due to the fact that in the first years of independence the government was limited to publication of legal acts for development of co-operation, but did not provide substantial financial assistance and other measures to encourage villagers, the country had just over 100 cooperatives in 1990s.
Having come to power, Kurmanbek Bakiyev outlined cooperation as one of the priorities of the country\'s economy development and urged farmers to unite in cooperatives, promising state support. As a result, there were already 1,240 cooperatives in 2006. However, due to lack of funds they did not receive adequate support. As a result, in 2012 a number of cooperatives decreased up to 426 - almost three times!
Co-op? Not afraid
According to Head of the Department of Development of Cooperation and Science of the Kyrgyz Ministry of Agriculture and Land Reclamation Sharshenbek Ismailov, one of the major stumbling blocks in the development of cooperation in agriculture - along with a lack of funding - misunderstanding of values of cooperation and lack of awareness of the Western type of cooperation by local villagers. Now the country has only a few cooperatives working according to western type - from sowing till crop sale. They are created with the help of international projects.
\"Most of villagers perceive cooperatives as collective farms: they give their lands, cattle and will be as employees,\" Sharshenbek Ismailov explains. He believes that the country is necessary to conduct a large-scale work on explanation of values, benefits and prospects of the consolidation for development of cooperative movement. In this regard, it is necessary to \"break another, no less important barrier of the unification - a sense of possessiveness of some villagers and mistrust to each other.\"
Co-op is not a heal-all
Currently, the Ministry of Agriculture has developed a program for the development of agricultural co-operative movement in Kyrgyzstan for 2015-2019 years. Its priorities are defined by such measures as creation of legal, economic and organizational conditions, improvement of the mechanism of financial and credit support of cooperatives and infrastructure cooperation, the introduction of elements of cooperative governance, the development of scientific, information and consultation as well as agricultural cooperatives staffing support.
According to Sharshenbek Ismailov, the program is currently under consideration of the government. \"At the first stage the Ministry of Agriculture is going to conduct extensive outreach activities on promotion of cooperation,\" the expert added.
Unfortunately, the cooperative movement doesn\'t imply guaranteed development of agriculture, improvement of crop capacity and ecology. Cooperation is seen as forced form of agricultural production for agricultural development and food security of the country.
The British politician Sir Winston Churchill, democracy is not the best form of government, just mankind hasn\'t invented better than democracy form.
The same is the cooperation in agriculture. Perhaps it is not ideal for development of agricultural sector, but there is no alternative.