USD87.45EUR95.90RUB1.07
24.kg

Déjà vu effect: a month without rallies

14:22, 02 April 2014, Bishkek - 24.kg news agency
Eleonora SAGYNDYK kyzy

Bishkek authorities imposed a temporary ban on rallies. Dissatisfied with the decision human rights activists intend to appeal to the prosecuting authorities to conduct an investigation upon the abuse of power by one of the regional administrations of the capital, which took such a decision. The Head of State expressed his controversial decision on this issue through the press service.

 

Rolling sleeves up

In Bishkek, till May 1, forbidden to Organization of rallies on the central square, near the buildings of the parliament and the government of Bishkek is prohibited till May 1.

According to the press service of the Main Department of Internal Affairs of the capital, the decision was taken by Pervomai district administration and was confirmed by the district court. \"The reason for the restrictions are numerous complaints of citizens, preparations for the events dedicated to the 4th anniversary of the events of April 2010 as well as preventing the destabilization of the socio-political situation of the destructive forces to ensure public order, security of citizens and visitors,\" police department explains.

 

Meeting place can\'t be changed?

Now, however, by the decision of Pervomai district court, Gorky Square is defined a venue for rallies, which is located near the Parliament building and the central Ala-Too Square.

The Main Department of Interior noted that \"all protests or other actions, which will be held from March 31 till May 1, 2014 on Ala-Too square and near the parliament and government buildings, would be unlawful, and insubordination to requirement of the law will be punished by an administrative fine.\"

The Head of the Main Department of Interior press service Bakyt Seitov told 24.kg news agency that the amount of fine against participants of an illegal rally will be defined from 200 till 500 soms, the insubordination will entail punishment up to arrest for 15 days. But, as he explains, only the judiciary has the right to define a punitive measure for violators of public order.

 

The same mistake

Note, immediately after the news human rights defenders in Kyrgyzstan condemned the decision. In particular, such a statement was made by Kylym Shany Center for Human Rights, whose Head Aziza Abdirasulova estimated the decision of Pervomai District Administration contrary to the Constitution of the Kyrgyz Republic.

\"Recognition of the decisions of Bishkek District Administration on limitation of organizing peaceful assemblies on Ala-Too Square, near the buildings of the parliament and the government from March 31 to May 1, 2014 by a legitimate court of AidaTilekeeva shows us her incompetence,\" the human rights defender stated to 24.kg news agency. According to her, the officials violated the Articles 14, 15 of the Law \"On peaceful assembly\" of the Criminal Code of the KR. In this regard, Kylym Shamy urges the prosecutor\'s office, the spokesman and the parliamentary committee on human rights, constitutional law and state structure to conduct an investigation upon excess of powers by the regional administrations.

Also, on April 1, 2014 For Democracy and Civil Society Coalition made ​​a demand to recognize the court\'s decision on limitation of peaceful assembly and demonstrations illegal. \"The decision is subject to immediate cancellation because of its apparent contradiction to basic provisions of the Constitution, national legislation and international law. The bitter irony of this judgment, passed, ostensibly, to prepare for the 4th  anniversary of the April Popular Revolution, lies in the fact that mass shooting of peaceful protesters on April 7, 2010 became possible exactly because of the previous government illegally imposed restrictions on freedom of assembly and meetings,\" the statement reports. Human rights activists say exactly \"for prevention of the possibility of re-introducing the \"draconian\" restrictions and prohibitions, there was a long and hard work for discussion and adoption of the new Law \"On peaceful gatherings\", which entered into force on the day of its signing, on May 23, 2012\".

It should be noted that such initiatives on limitation of public rallies have a long history; they have been seen under Akayev and Bakiyev presidency too. In this regard, certain human rights defenders and activists speak about the effect of deja vu.

Thus, in 2007, the then Bishkek Mayor Usenov by his decree forbade any gatherings near the building of the White House. Both former and present-day authorities defined a public garden behind the Sports Palace - near the monument of the real revolutionary writer Maxim Gorky, as a place for rallies. But then the people were allowed to express their demands on the Old Square - in front of the parliament\'s building.

A little later, in 2008, being the parliamentary deputy, Ishak Masaliev, inspired by a decree of the Mayor\'s Office, initiated a bill that allowed holding rallies from 9.00 to 20.00. It was prohibited to install yurts, pitch tent camps on the Ala -Too Square. In the regions of overlap Blocking of major road highways in the regions was prohibited as well. The Law proposed to limit the zone of demonstrations and marches. So, according to the law, one it was forbidden to gather near the Government House, residences of the President and the Prime Minister, as well as near military units and courthouses.

\"Every Kyrgyzstani has the right to express his or her positions and views, nobody forbids holding rallies. However, the Constitution doesn\'t comprise any information when and where one may organize pickets and demonstrations. I consider expedient the introduction of any restrictions. When some want to rally and stand on the square, others dream to walk along this square quietly. So we have to take care of the latter. The project establishes standards for organization and conduct of public events. Events of 2007 showed that within gathering of people a large number of them become unguided even for organizers of a rally,\" Masaliev stated then.

And indeed, after such brief excursions into the past, it becomes clear that there are grounds for déjà vu.

 

Disservice

Meanwhile, the Spokesman for the President Kadir Toktogulov stated to the media that the decision of Pervomai District Court on temporary (for 1 month) restriction of holding rallies on the Ala-Too Square \"Almazbek Atambayev considers clear and reflecting the opinions of the vast majority of Bishkek population.\" At the same time, according to the President, the Mayor of the capital Kubanychbek Kulmatov should search for optimal solution of the problem. \"It is important to consider both the legitimate demands of citizens on early prevention of risks of aggressive behavior of protesters, sanitation and traffic violations in the center of Bishkek as well as the rights of citizens to peaceful assemblies,\" the Spokesman said. So, the President expressed his ambiguous attitude towards the issue.

The political analyst Bakyt Baketayev in conversation with 24.kg news agency noted that after the events in Ukraine, Kyrgyz people wouldn\'t have to go outside to rally. Since all remember sad consequences of such actions. But local authorities, according to the expert, just rendered the supreme authorities disservice in the run-up to the planned buy the opposition kurultays.

\"The Constitution gives me the rights to - rally, speech, and no one can deprive me of them, and if someone is going to do it, s(he) violates the basic law of the country. The latest decision of the local authorities not only violates the constitutional rights, but also nullifies the Kyrgyz trend as well as Kyrgyz paradigm. In the republic people sought the right to hold rallies on Ala-Too square for 20 years. The district judge, who took such decision, overturned achievements of two revolutions in the country. Let this person does not think that with a stroke of the pen he stopped all campaigns. People won\'t go to meetings themselves, because they see what the result of following \"Maidan participants\" is. There was nothing to provide a disservice to the authorities. E should reverse this decision as unconstitutional,\" Bakyt Baketayev says.

The political scientist warns that otherwise people will follow those who call them counter to this decision.

It is no coincidence that the Ombudsman of the KR Bakytbek Amanbayev expressed his concern about the decision of the court on April 1, 2014. \"These steps again brings us back to the recent past when the former regime tried to hide behind such a ban. Once again we remind you that we build a lawful state. This is not a utopian model, it is the real democratic form of society where the law and human rights dominate. Naturally, the realization of this idea - a long-term process, but we have chosen our own path and follow it firmly, and such bans more testify the need to find consensus and greater trust between the government and the people,\" Bakytbek Amanbayev said. According to the chief human rights activist, the decree of the authorities, referring to \"numerous complaints of citizens and the preparations for the events dedicated to the 4th anniversary of the events of April 2010,\" is not tenable.

Note, Bishkek residents waited for 31 March with some anxiety, because the so-called opposition, led by the former deputy Sadyr Zhaparov was going to spend kurultay in Bishkek this day. However, the day before Sadyr Zhaparov on his page on social networks reported that kurultay on the central square of Bishkek was canceled. The reason was a warning from the police of the capital that conduct of kurultay will be considered illegal because of absence of in time application.

\"I\'ll be honest; I did not apply the application for organizing kurultay. Because I referred to the Constitution. Let the government does not respect the laws, but we, as politicians respecting the law, adopted the forced decision to postpone it for an indefinite term,\" he wrote in social network.

The new period of organizing kurultay of opposition will be announced until April 10. It is known that spring in Kyrgyzstan, as usual, is accompanied by protests. Will the current spring become an exception?

 

 


CONTACTS

SOCIAL MEDIA

TelegramYouTubeWhatsAppFacebookInstagram

© News Agency «24.kg» - News of Kyrgyzstan. All rights reserved. All information posted on this website is intended for personal use only and may not be distributed without the written permission of NA «24.kg». The editorial team is not responsible for the content of reprinted materials and statements of individuals. +18