Central Asia: bleak prospects
Withdrawal of NATO troops from Afghanistan is expected by the end of 2014. Experts are sure: Central Asia will face deep shocks and enormous threats to security and stability. The prospects of the region are estimated, at best, as indefinite, and at worst - as very bleak. At the same time economic threats become real among the risks of political instability.
Afghan syndrome
\"Afghanistan - is a long-playing threat to Central Asian countries. We are familiar with it, got used to it,\" the Head of the World of Eurasia Public Fund (Kazakhstan) Eduard Poletaev is sure.
According to him, the Afghan problem faces the Central Asian countries for more than 20 years. Now people started speaking about it again only in connection with the upcoming withdrawal of peacekeeping forces. \"Creation of efficient Afghan army remains the main task of NATO forces for today. Within the formation of an independent security Afghanistan has a lot of vulnerabilities and real terms for withdrawal are unknown,\" Edward Poletaev noted.
The near future of Afghanistan, in principle, is obvious. The current Afghan authorities are unlikely to be able to keep the situation in their own hands. Interest of Americans and Europeans in the region weakens. Against this background, predictions concerning returning of Taliban movement to power seem quite real. In such conditions there can appear new border conflicts and flow of illegal drugs from Afghanistan can increase. Currently, hundreds of citizens of Central Asia, including Kyrgyzstan, are fighting in Syria. Analysts believe that sooner or later they will come back home and try to create an Islamic state in the region. Radical religious movements represent no less danger.
\"Regarding the withdrawal of troops, I think, it will give impetus to aggravation of the situation in the region. Most likely the Taliban will come to power in Afghanistan, now it is becoming increasingly clear. Hardly the Taliban themselves will claim any territorial, geographical claims, but opposition movements, such as the Islamic Movement of Uzbekistan, the Islamic Movement of Turkestan and many others can do it,\" the expert Alexander Zelichenko said.
Echo of Ukrainian Maidan
At the same time, regional experts agree that the probability of threats from Afghanistan stands for Central Asia, but not primarily. Eduard Poletaev is sure that, besides the Afghan problem, Central Asia has also new risks. Example - the recent events in Ukraine. \"In connection with the situation in Ukraine there was a need to assess the level of security in our countries. There is no need to turn into an instrument of geopolitical game. We must be cautious in estimates of various non-healing wounds that exist in each country,\" Edward Poletaev believes.
Predictions for 2014 tell that the events in Ukraine will have an impact not only on the political stability in the countries of Central Asia, but also the economic one. Introduction of economic sanctions against Russia deflects impact on the region. The director of the Center for Public Policy Research (Kazakhstan) Meruert Makhmutova informed at \"Central Asia: Challenges and Risks in 2014\" round table discussion.
According to her, it was \"clear before the escalation of the conflict in Ukraine, when in 2013 the Russian economy showed a decline.\" \"Devaluation of rouble caused subsequent devaluation of tenge. The international community is quite skeptical about the imposed sanctions against Russia. But they might not be so dangerous, but the uncertainty that exists at the moment. The signal that Russia has showed to international community in connection with the events in Ukraine, was clearly appreciated by investors. They slowed to enter the markets of developing countries, including Central Asia,\" Meruert Makhmutova noted.
She noted that the Russian economy together with the economy of Kazakhstan - the most integrated with RF - can live in conditions of blockade for 1.5-2 years by infusion of stabilization funds. \"On the other hand, impact of the past years has led to the fact that our economy is actually insensitive to such measures. Economic recession occurs owing to isolation. Uzbekistan, Tajikistan and Kyrgyzstan are of great importance from migrants\' remittance. In case of deterioration of the economic situation in Russia and Kazakhstan, migrants will be forced out of these countries,\" Meruert Makhmutova noted.
Alternatively, the expert suggested \"not to live in illusions that someone will help, and take a reality check of the situation and solve their problems in order to survive.\" The expert\'s advice is topical for Kyrgyzstan more than ever. The country depends on external inflows, including significant revenues from Russia. But the coming year won\'t give generous \"gifts\".
\"Soon there will be talks about the fact that the country\'s budget loses a substantial amount after the withdrawal of Manas Transit Center. While Russia is engaged in the Crimea, it will not pay attention to requests of the Kyrgyz authorities and force Kyrgyzstan\'s entry to the Customs Union. It will just observe the events in the political arena. In this situation the Kyrgyz authorities have to rely only on themselves,\" the economic expert Akilbek Apaitov said.
New challenges - new economy
Another \"enemy\" of the countries of Central Asia can be considered raw materials orientation of the states. Extraction of mineral resources comprises lion\'s share of industry in almost all countries in the region. The risk of future problems is related to the fact that primary production develops without processing. The mining industry occupies 56 percent of Kazakh industry, 70 percent - in Kyrgyzstan and Turkmenistan, 60 percent - in Uzbekistan.
\"Usually economists say that the main challenge of Central Asia - political instability. But, unfortunately, it is not so. Stability directly depends on the integration of their economies. The main problem in Central Asia - broken system of economic relations,\" the professor of Kyrgyz-Turkish Manas University Zhusup Pirimbayev.
The professor emphasizes that there is population growth in Central Asia. In fact, the growth is close to 30 percent. This suggests that labor market annually increases in Central Asia. Employment problem will become more relevant in terms of development of resources in a manner that does not require substantial employment of workers.
\"Only integrated economy can become the alterative. We need to interact with each other. But today, the trade turnover between the countries of Central Asia comprises just 15-16 percent. The water question is still open. Sooner or later we will come to the fact that some countries, including Kyrgyzstan, will store water for their own needs. It will unlikely please the neighbors,\" Zhusup Pirimbaev note.
Exactly the integration will provide the basis for the economy of cooperation in strategic issues and division of labor. It will also allow settling the problem of free labour resources more effectively. The easiest solution to the problem of employment of citizens is independent processing of minerals produced in the country. \"If the processing of natural resources in Kyrgyzstan reaches 25 percent, the employment will be about 30,000 working places,\" Zhusup Pirimbaev notes.
Not together, but apart
But what exactly can\'t do the countries of Central Asia - to combine the use of collaborative efforts profitably for each other. All attempts to organize anything like real cooperation don\'t bring results. Part one of the reason for this is the frantic desire of states to defend the independence, which was relatively recently found.
\"Until now, the countries of Central Asia, unfortunately, couldn\'t create an international structure, even if remotely, resembling the European Union or ASEAN. Why the Central Asian countries can\'t create a regional international organization? I am convinced that no one successful international structure wasn\'t created and can\'t be created without the formation of common for participants values,\" the Director of the Institute for Public Policy Muratbek Imanaliev believes.
Partly the development of such course of events was contributed by the fact that after becoming independent the Central Asian countries try to form their internal and external political courses without assistance and keep distance from the Soviet past in every possible way.
There is tension between them. Clashes on the borders occur regularly and adds oil to the flame of difficult relationships. The countries of Central Asia are characterized by political instability and volatility of political governance as well as different economic potential. As a result we struggle for supremacy between the countries and even personal dislike of individual leaders. But Central Asian countries are not ready to unite even facing the threat of impending danger.