Procurement of coal: the same are bargaining…
Bishkek Heating and Power Plant (HPP) was designed under Kazakh fuel. Basically, it is delivered from Shabyrkul deposit. From year to year Electric Stations OJSC announces tender for the supply of coal, and the same companies with the same violations have established tradition to participate in it in order a procuring entity to start negotiating directly and bargain with suppliers once again.
Earlier you start...
Preparations for new heating season at Bishkek HPP started before the current season completed. The Procurement Department of Electric Stations OJSC announced a tender to supply 630,000 tons of Kazakh coal, in advance, on March 24, knowing that they unlikely the first time to determine the supplier from the first time.
The auction was attended by the three companies. Progress Company LLC is ready to deliver fuel at $35,884,800 ($56.95 per ton), Darsan Coal LLP - for $ 32.76 million ($52), Adalin - for $31.5 million ($50). However, the last two Kazakh organizations have not provided certificates of the bid security, which is the reason to deprive them of the status of applicants. According to the law on public procurements, the tender shall be considered valid when it is attended by two or more suppliers.
It should be noted that the application of Progress Company LLC, offered $35,884,800 for 630,000 tons of coal, can\'t be considered, as exposed amount exceeds the fixed budget. Electric Stations provided 1.389.15 billion soms for purchase of Kazakh coal.
Note also, the long-flame coal and gas belongs to the category of high-energy fuel, produced at the coal fields of Kazakhstan. In the experience of many years Shabyrkul fuel is supplied to Bishkek HPP. In general, 900,000 tons of fuel required for the heating season. Electric Stations will buy missing volume from local suppliers, as the government pledged to support domestic producers. In future, Bishkek HPP will have to refuse from imported coal at all. After upgrading of equipment boilers will be adapted to Kara- Keche coal. Therefore, all industrialists have less time and opportunity to put over their schemes.
The first tender failed miserably. Participants did not seem to know what documents need to be prepared and what information to be gathered. Kazakh companies participate at auction without collateral for the second consecutive year, hoping that the committee members will make allowance for them, and local distributors set fabulous prices for the goods. Although the portal of public procurements published budget of the procuring entity, and participants of the tenders know about this, because there they will learn about upcoming purchases and receive information of interest.
later you purchase...
The tender was declared invalid owing to violations of the law on public procurement. Thus, it will be reappointed, until the suppliers and industrialists will not get tired and do not dare to buy fuel from the same source by direct negotiations. But such a scenario we had in the past year.
After a series of unsuccessful tenders in June 2013, Electric Stations rejected bids for the supply of 450,000 tonnes of Kazakh coal of D, DR ranks due to budget surcharge.
All the same companies fought for the right to supply fuel to Bishkek HPP. Progress Company LLC offered $43.5 for a ton of coal, Adalin LLP - $52, Best - $50. However, the procuring entity has pledged a smaller amount of money and decided to buy coal without tender.
One should say that Adalin LLP then also didn\'t submit the tender collaterals for guarantees.
After that, it was reported that at Bishkek TPP delivers Kyrgyz Kazakh coal Progress Company Kyrgyz brokerage firm, which participated in the tender, delivers Kazakh coal to Bishkek HPP.
According to an independent expert of the fuel and energy complex Rasul Umbetaliev, a ton of coal from Shabyrkul open pit costs $21-22, railway costs - $8-10, and at Lugovoe station the cost of a ton of coal is already $31-32. Electric Stations OJSC buys a ton of coal at $42.5 from Progress Company LLC and has a profit of $ 8-10 per ton. \"If Electric Stations purchases coal directly from Shabyrkul open pit, it would save $4-4.5 million. Progress Company LLC, which did not win the auction, and but gained the supply, is suggestive of the existence of corruption schemes in purchasing of coal for HPP,\" he considers.
The Chamber of Accounts found out that brokerage companies deliver coal to Bishkek HPP and inflate prices. Analysis of fuel purchases showed that in recent years Electric Stations buys coal from intermediary firms from Kazakhstan. Since June 2012 and in the first quarter of 2013 Kazakh brokerage firm, not being coal producer, and, not owning coal open mines in Kazakhstan, in the person of Best LLP, TNK- Komur, Shakhta Zapadnaya (Western Mine) supplied 514,090 tons of fuel to Bishkek HPP. At least 83 percent of it comprised Shabyrkul coal, which was supplied by the intermediary Best Company.
Furthermore, from the Shabyrkul coal manufacturer sent letters that Shubarkulkomur JSC can not conclude a direct contract with the Electric Stations in connection with what it has already made contracts with Best, Progress Company on coal supply to Kyrgyzstan.
Irrespective of violations
The member of the Supervisory Board at the initiative of transparency of fuel and energy complex under the Ministry of Energy and Industry Nikolai Kravtsov also said that Electric Stations OJSC violates the law and lobby the interests of private companies to the detriment of the public ones.
According to him, the procuring entity has sent invitations to potential suppliers of coal, resulting only three companies were involved in bids, whereas in 2010 29 companies acquired tender documents. \"The tender committee had no data on the cost of coal of mentioned brands in the wholesale market, so there was no possibility of evaluation and comparison of bids by the Law \"On Public Procurement\". Wholesale price is $22.3-24.1 per tonne excluding VAT and transport costs. Progress Company proposed $43.5 per ton of coal, which is as close to the cost budgeted in the energy company. This suggests the leak of information regarding the price and volume of coal by the procuring entity in favor of the supplier. The trip of Salaydin Avazov and Rayimbek Mamyrov to Kazakhstan to Shubarkulkomir JSC coal mining company may serve as confirmation of this assumption. Acquisition of D rank of coal by Progress Company without careful examination of the proposals of other potential suppliers is hasty and economically unfeasible action,\" Nikolai Kravtsov wrote to the Minister of Energy and Industry.
Electric Stations OJSC tried to explain that his statement was unfounded. Invitations to tender were sent to Shubarkulkomir JSC, Best LLP and NorthPowerTrade, since Shubarkulkomir JSC is a direct manufacturer and the companies - the largest suppliers of coal from this open mine.
Taking into account the structural and technological features of Bishkek HPP equipment functioning while using Shabyrkul coal with low cost and high efficiency, since 1997 Electric Stations OJSC acquires D and DR rank fuel annually. In addition, there is a government decree number 316 requiring the company to acquire coal from Shabyrkul open pit.
Shubarkulkomir JSC supplies fuel at $27-29 without transportation at 100 percent prepayment. Taking into account the railway costs till Lugovoe Station the price will be $41.51-42.51 per tonne. The Kyrgyz side was able to negotiate for the supply at the same price without tendering.
Been there, done that
Once it became clear that this year the last year\'s scheme can repeat, at the opening of tenders Rasul Umbetaliev hit spewed charges the Head of the Department of Fuel Supply Taldybek Azhiev. He said that Electric Stations OJCS is let by nose by the private companies engaged in the resale of coal.
However, the procuring entity hasn\'t yet paid to the suppliers of Kara- Keche fuel. \"We recognize that we didn\'t fulfill the obligations to domestic coal producers. This year we plan to buy another 400 million tons of coal from them. They haven\'t yet fulfilled the contractual supply oblugations, so the first thing we buy Shabyrkul fuel that delivered in full. I will not deny that we don\'t pay to local coal miners, so they don\'t hurry to deliver at term. The company does not have enough money,\" Taldybek Azhiev explained.
Of course, Electric Stations OJSC hasn\'t enough means due to lower exports of electricity to Kazakhstan. However, they buy Shabyrkul coal 100 percent prepaid.