Kadyr Malikov: Policy of double standards inevitably leads to protest actions
Kadyr Malikov - well-known expert theologian, who is actively engaged in discussion in order to give explanation, for example, in such a delicate sphere as religious one. Once when the Defense Council discussed the issue of religious situation in Kyrgyzstan, the society started active polemics. The main dispute arose around the question whether the government should intervene in the affairs of believers. Kadyr Malikov believes that heated discussions may arise a little bit later and on another issue. Today he answered questions of 24.kg news agency.
-In your opinion, what risks and challenges face Kyrgyzstan at present?
- Global economic crisis is hidden not only in unjust distribution of resources, but also in the present system of political world order, which leads to social, economic, political, and value changes in all countries of the world. Attitude towards the notion of power, democracy, freedom and rights changes. Somewhere it leads to protest actions, and somewhere - to coups, revolutions, interethnic strives and conflicts. Of course, all this does not happen without the participation of external geopolitical players. All this we have previously observed in Kyrgyzstan and Georgia, for example. Now we can see it in Ukraine.
And every time the true essence of foreign policy of Western double standards, corruptness of family and clan ruling, merging of crime and power are revealed...In fact, quiet often the same persons come to power on the rebound of revolutions.
Such processes inevitably lead people to protest moods and awakening. Time will show whether it will be \"Central Asia Spring\" or something else. But there are risks of destabilization, as in Ukraine, in any country of our region. There is increased risk for Kyrgyzstan, especially on the verge of joining the Customs Union and closure of Manas base military component. The processes in the Middle East, particularly the participation of our citizens in the conflict in Syria, or activation of radical groups in Afghanistan, focused on Central Asia should be taken into consideration.
In addition to the national or regional factors have and there is a risk of destabilization of religious component. Here it is important to anticipate and reduce conflict points, one of which - the definition of the boundaries of secularity and religiousness. Fining a balance between religious and secular values in one state are the general rules of the \"game\".
- On the basis of what you have said, what processes are underway in the spiritual sphere of Kyrgyzstan?
- From year to year religious values start playing great role in the society of Kyrgyzstan. They as regulator of citizens\' behavior, somewhere even act as an ideological system. On the other side, we observe rapid decline in the authority of secular laws among the population, since the laws are perceived by ordinary people as a mere tool in the struggle for power or its retention.
In general there is a tendency of degradation of political systems and models of secularity across the regions not because of the influence of religion, but because of the internal contradictions of the system and corruption.
And if we talk about the basic mechanisms of the political system, the crisis of secular power system is also associated primarily with the human factor. Spiritual and moral crisis of present oligarchic groups in power in combination with the corrupt system has led to a vicious circle.
The way out is possible only by changing the political elite and the establishment of new mechanisms and models of statehood on the basis of national, historical and cultural peculiarities of the country.
-Do you have own advice of how to resolve this problem with minimum losses?
-In fact, now we can see some attempts of believers-intellectuals in Central Asia and Russia searching for ideological, social and even political answers in Islam as a kind of alternative to illiberal values. Due to it, I consider that discussions about the place and the role of Islam in Central Asia mutual comparison of Islam and Democracy, searching for ways of harmonious coexistence of religious values and secular are very important nowadays.
-Do you cast doubt on secular model of our country\'s development?
-No, I don\'t. The main issue is in the interpretation of the notion \"secular state\" itself and originating from it perception of the term \"democracy\" and \"human rights\". In the sense that for a large part of the population, democracy and secularity are not perceived as a form of political system and tool of state-confessional regulation, but as a kind of ideology that is often contrasted to, primarily, religion.
Let us recognize that the countries of Central Asia in the minds of the officials still retained as the Soviet system, which implies opposition of secular system to religious values, which gradually leads to the inevitable ideological conflict. Especially between Islam and the secular system represented by the ruling political groups that use all branches of government (legislative, executive) in resistance to the growth of Islam.
And as a result there is formed an artificial situation where the state itself opposes the revival of Islam thus seeing it as a threat. And, in fact, the ruling political secular elite are fighting against Islamic revival by hands of the state and on the behalf of it. So, heated discussions about the model of secularity will be in future. The most important thing is that we must avoid extremes and try to find acceptable common points.
-Do you think the state should not regulate the religious sphere?
-The state should act as a neutral arbiter between religious organizations, while, on the basis of national interests, cultural and religious backgrounds, to orient their policies in line with non-contradiction to traditional religious values of the population of Kyrgyzstan. That is, acting as an arbiter, the state has a policy of continuous dialogue, developing and improving the Code of Conduct (the rules and forms of cooperation) between religious organizations and public authorities with the participation of representatives of religious confessions.
At the same time the state can conduct a policy of cooperation with denominations in bringing the value religious system in addressing social problems, ensure inter-religious peace, spiritual and moral development of society and the education of new generations. And, perhaps the most important thing is that the state should abandon radical form of secularism as a means of conducting a policy of imposing certain ideological principles that contradict the traditional spiritual and religious values of the majority of citizens.
-May the state interfere in religious issues?
-State authorities don\'t have the right to interfere in the issues of religious organizations and their activities, religious educational process and personnel policy. But it can do it in case of threat. For example, the government has a policy to provide spiritual and information security and controls over the content of religious education, religious preaching in the media for the presence of extremist or destructive ideas. That is, it reserves the right to regulate interfaith relations and even interfere with the activities of religious organizations in the event of threats to public and state security.