Bishkek’s paranoia holds back chance at real development
In December, Kyrgyzstan announced that it was considering quitting its involvement of the China-Kyrgyzstan-Uzbekistan railway, a plan initiated by the three sides in 1998 but has been dragged on for almost 20 years.
Constructing transportation infrastructure is vital to Central Asian countries. The leaders of some Central Asian states have viewed it as a key national strategy.
Both Kyrgyzstan and Uzbekistan are landlocked countries, and it has been a dream since independence to have a route to the sea.
The Soviet railways connect the south with the north, mostly leading to Moscow. A road that links the east with the west will help Central Asian countries establish economic ties with more regions.
In recent years, the Shanghai Cooperation Organization has been dedicated to infrastructure construction in Central Asian states. In this important period when regional transportation is booming, it is regrettable that Kyrgyzstan may quit the joint railway project.
The country\'s analysts and some who oppose the project believe the key problem lies in lack of funds; even if China provides extra loans or funds, they will be far from the sum needed.
However, a large investment is undoubtedly worthwhile for a railway project that can bring huge economic benefits in the future, and China has proposed several plans to solve the funding issue.
The main reasons that hinder Kyrgyzstan\'s economic cooperation with other countries, including this China-Kyrgyzstan-Uzbekistan railway project, are the changing political situation in the country, the power alternation and the lack of consistent economic development strategies.
From 2005 to 2010, Kyrgyzstan experienced an abnormal change of regime twice. The central power had been busy with the political clashes between their opponents and supporters. Local areas are at odds with the leadership. The economic construction proceeded rather slowly with social problems mounting.
Moreover, since establishing the parliamentary system in 2010, Kyrgyzstan has been in a period of political transition. Discrepancies within the parliament make controversial bills difficult to pass.
The emergence of Kyrgyzstan\'s domestic protectionism in recent years has had a negative influence on the country\'s deepening economic relations with the outside.
The Kyrgyz people are strongly against foreign companies that sought to exploit the Kumtor gold mine that accounts for 15 percent of its national income. The waves of resistance have severely affected the country\'s economic development. Kyrgyz politician and former interim president Roza Otunbayeva has said that the Kumtor issue made the country\'s economy trapped in a bottleneck.
Against this backdrop, some claim the roadmap of the China-Kyrgyzstan-Uzbekistan is depressing because China may take the chance to exploit Kyrgyzstan\'s resources. Such views are obviously riven with factional fighting and reflect some Kyrgyz people\'s stubborn Cold War mentality and backward market concepts.
The changing geopolitical dynamics have made Kyrgyzstan adjust its foreign policies. It attaches more importance to the Russia-led Eurasian Union, and is more keen to cooperate with Russia and Kazakhstan. In addition, unsmooth ties with its neighboring countries are also one of Kyrgyzstan\'s concerns about the trilateral railway project.
Kyrgyzstan is in a particular historical moment. From a domestic perspective, the constant search for a development model brings about temporary political discrepancies. The economic reforms lack a systematic strategy and driving force.
Externally, Kyrgyzstan\'s political stability has to more and more rely on the support from big powers. Religious extremism from the Middle East and South Asia poses an increasing threat to national security.
Under these circumstances, the political elites of Kyrgyzstan attach more importance to their own needs, rather than national interests.
But from a long-term perspective, developing transportation facilities will undoubtedly stimulate the economy of Central Asian countries and benefit people of the region.
http://www.globaltimes.cn/content/844449.shtml#.UwwEqeN_vIc