Deputies.kg: Get lost in game?
Deputies\' interest in political games can cost dearly to Kyrgyzstan, which is in a difficult economic situation on top of everything else.
The Parliament still has the main theme for discussions - future of the budget- forming Kumtor enterprise. The press service of the Parliament tried to convince public that there isn\'t any delay in consideration of the complex question. Deputies just didn\'t have time to consider it in committees and factions. Nevertheless, it is planned to discuss the issue at a session on February 5. If only, of course, deputies will meet the deadline and, for all that, as required by regulations, blow off steam in committees and factions beforehand.
Prosecutor of oneself
Indeed, can we consider it as a delaying of decision, for example, when members of Ata Meken faction removed the question from agenda, because its leader Omurbek Tekebayev fell ill and couldn\'t be present at a session? How they can be without herdsman? However the position of the Socialists is clear and wasn\'t corrected. Ardent tribune Erkinbek Alymbekov insists on resignation of Zhantoro Satybaldiyev\'s Government and promises to initiate criminal cases against the top-manager of the company.
\"At first we will file a suit against Centerra for violations of environmental legislation ($3-5 billion) and initiate a criminal case against the management of Centerra and Ian Atkinson. Let Satybaldiyev then go to investigatory isolation ward to Atkinson for negotiations and beg him for mercy,\" the deputy promised his followers in social network on December 27, 2013.
Is Erkinbek Alymbekov entitled to initiate criminal proceedings, to prosecute, to conduct investigations, to determine degrees of criminal acts or corruption offenses? How can we assess such revelations of one of Ata Meken leaders? The associate of the \"father\" of Constitution, who has fought in opposition barricades for rigorous observance and respect of laws more than 20 years, shifted his feet on the party\'s chronicle. He demonstrated that nowadays the Socialists don\'t care of laws. They are prosecutors and judges in one...
Between two stools
Right after Ata Meken, Ar-Namys faction decided to reject the draft agreement worked out by officials. It didn\'t approve a new draft agreement of the Government on restructuring of Kumtor. Felix Kulov himself and his people believe that the Government didn\'t executed the decree of the Parliament where deputies charged to increase the Kyrgyz share in a joint venture on Kumtor up to 67 percent. Ar Namys faction members believe that the Government couldn\'t find admissible key factors of the mine\'s management.
\"All the problems and doubts of public on the development of Kumtor gold mine are connected with management issues, which are realized by the Canadian party for more than 19 years, and cause a lot of complaints, however the Kyrgyz party again lets the Canadian party to manage to project unconditionally,\" the faction explained.
Ar Namys believes that the agreement is quite formal. According to the faction\'s deputies, there is a proviso in a new project that Centerra Gold Inc. continues to be responsible for the operational management of the mine.
Despite the management by the Canadian party, Kumtor activities are supposed to be financed at the expense of means from operation of exactly joint with Kyrgyzstan venture. Thus, Centerra will virtually manage the company by itself at the expense of both shareholders.
But Felix Kulov wouldn\'t be Felix Kulov if he didn\'t insist on including a proviso in the faction\'s decision. It says that, in general the faction admits \"positive efforts of Government on increase of Kyrgyzstan\'s share in Kumtor project\". Well, just in case, what if...
Ata Zhurt faction took notice of the Government on work with Kumtor and enacted to submit the draft agreement with the Canadian investor for the Parliament\'s consideration.
Flies in cutlet
It becomes clear for everyone that the Parliament, except deputies, seems drove itself into a corner. But where did you see servants of the people admitting their mistakes? Moreover these mistakes are cherished by own arrogance and exaggerated self-assessment, multiplied on false sense of universal significance. Alas, all arguments against the government\'s efforts lead to such conclusions.
Those, who have more forcible arguments than decorated \"patriotism\" of certain people\'s deputies, spoke about mistakes within the whole period of parliamentary war against the Canadian investor. Scientists, experts, economists have a real right for discussing Kumtor, its advantages and disadvantages... The others, whom the deputies don\'t even want to listen to. But not for the reason that truth is more important, but because swaggering doesn\'t allow to admit mistakes. After all admission of mistakes is a destiny of wise people. Or clever ones.
It is enough to say that Ar Namys faction asked to write \"its own\" conclusion on a new draft agreement an outside person - a engineering specialist, who is studying electoral pre-election technologies now. Neither economist, nor scientist, but a former builder.
The fifth convocation, which is represented mainly by businessmen and other \"cash-boxes\", who are neatly called \"bazaarcoms\" (heads of bazaars) now, plays with the country like with a ball on children playground.
Who will hear them?
At the same time the expert community continues its attempts to evoke a response from the Parliament, to wake it up it and direct to more civilized way.
Business circles of the country don\'t hide the concerns about the current situation around the largest investment project - Kumtor. The Head of the International Business Council Aktilek Tungatarov once again had to announce opinion of the business community worrying that Kumtor problem hasn\'t resolved yet. \"Many investors don\'t come to Kyrgyzstan, because they wait for the decision of the Government and the Parliament. It is a pity that there are no deputies here,\" Aktilek Tungatarov said at the meeting of businessmen with the PM.
Also he believes that deputies, initiating a referendum on Kumtor issues, just trying to avoid responsibility for the decision.
The Prime Minister Zhantoro Satybaldiyev agreed with the position of businessmen, noting that he is against the referendum. Once again he recalled about the economic losses of Kyrgyzstan in case it doesn\'t approve the agreement between Kyrgyzstan and Centerra Gold Inc. \"Economic questions shouldn\'t be put to referendum and deputies must take a decision. The present agreement is possible, it is not the most preferable variant, but is the best of those which we can chose,\" the PM commented on.
The expert Maksat Mamyrkanov believes that authorities of Kyrgyzstan turned out to be hostages of Centerra. In fact, he didn\'t specified or didn\'t want to specify who made the situation critical.
Maksat Mamyrkanov has a long life before him. If he wishes he can become a professional. Many people heard the opinion of the competent scientist, the President of the Public Policy Institute President Muratbek Imanaliyev. \"Talks about Kumtor nationalization is just a speculative way of pressure on Centerra, with representatives of which we are holding negotiations now,\" he believes.
Muratbek Imanaliyev noted that not a single politician considers the variant of Kumtor nationalization seriously. \"There is an exaggeration of expert opinions with the help of which they press on the investor,\" he noted.
So it actually happened. The Parliament suddenly changed its \"anger\" to \"mercy\" and started to assure that they didn\'t speak about nationalization. Traditionally they were misunderstood...
Muratbek Imanaliyev believes that the problem isn\'t in Kumtor, but nobody knows how to stop degradation of the country. \"There is a hundred percent deindustrialization of the republic,\" he recalled. \"Agriculture production returned to subsistence production. As a result the economy of Kyrgyzstan consists of two markets and Kumtor.
I have told already that the Parliament is full of bazaarcoms...
Let people be responsible
Speaking at the \"National interests and political responsibility\" roundtable discussion, Muratbek Imanaliyev confessed: \"It seems to me sometimes that there are idiots in the Parliament, but it isn\'t so in real. In fact they don\'t speak about nationalization seriously. All these talks are aimed at getting more through bargaining with the Canadians.\"
The political scientist Marat Kazakpayev agreed with him. According to him many politicians, speaking about Kumtor issue, speculate and manipulate with this theme, pronouncing populist slogans.
The Head of the Polis Asia Analytical Center Elmira Nogoibayeva believes that Kumtor issue creates an opportunity to bargain for some preferences for certain factions. \"I have such a feeling that Kumtor is a cool cause to bargain. As for me it is obvious what bargaining is made for. Kumtor is a really good opportunity to bargain resources and preferences. I think that not a single deputy will use them. I can see less and less politicians in the Parliament. In my opinion, the Parliament now consists of political entrepreneurs, who carry rational, pragmatic game for themselves,\" Elmira Nogoibayeva said earlier.
Probably, nobody was surprised, guessing how the Parliament is going to find the way out from the deadlock, where it pushed itself to. Right. Deputies decided to push all the responsibility on people. Then the Parliament started speaking about the referendum. The Deputy Tynchtyk Shainazarov, for example, requires it. It seems that he is a lawyer. But he couldn\'t explain why strictly economic question should be resolved by common citizens of the country.
His colleagues say: we want to know the opinion of people about Kumtor. But wouldn\'t it be cheaper to conduct an opinion poll? And what has a shepherd or nurse to say, for example, on GDP percent and influence of the mine production on its formation if they don\'t have any idea about it?
A bit from new story
We should remember the events of the last months in the Parliament. The deputies didn\'t approve the first variant of the memorandum, suggested by the Government. The Parliament rejected the agreement with the Canadian party on creation of a joint venture with equal participation interest, which was made in autumn. The deputies demanded to hold repeated elections and increase Kyrgyzstan\'s share in Kumtor up to 67 percent. If the Government doesn\'t manage to achieve the assigned task the deputies stated that they would insist on the company\'s nationalization.
The Government started to develop a new draft agreement with the Canadian investor. But officials warned the Parliament at once that 67 percent is impossible and they won\'t be able to achieve such agreements.
At the same time the Parliament enacted to withdraw from all the agreements on Kumtor project unilaterally in case the Government doesn\'t achieve 67 percent of interest rate in a joint venture. The Government and the Prosecutor General\'s Office were charged with informing the Parliament on the process of implementation of the decree up to December 23, 2013. By tradition nobody met the deadline and along with New Year\'s presents the problem moved to 2014 year.
Kumtor is the largest gold deposit in Kyrgyzstan, which is developed by Centerra Gold Inc. Canadian Company within the industrial and investment project. At present the Kyrgyz Republic is the largest shareholder of the company holding 33 percent of its shares.
The question is still open and the country bears multimillion currency losses.