As Road map would have luck
The meeting of the Supreme Council of the Eurasian Economic Commission will be held in March and only then it will be clear whether the Road map for Kyrgyzstan\'s accession to the Customs Union is approved. The Advisor to the Prime Minister of the Kyrgyz Republic Oleg Pankratov told 24.kg news agency about new models of economy and settling of old problems.
- Road map wasn\'t adopted in December, what is the reason?
- There are two variants of the Road map: our and a variant of the Eurasian Economic Commission. They are similar. But our variant prescribes creation of safety cushion. Changes in the economic policy always cause definite shocks and that is exactly what our opponents of the accession to the CU are speaking about. There will be shocks. The other question is whether we will manage to overcome them. The question of signing the Road map was withdrawn, because our suggestions weren\'t considered. But there isn\'t anything terrible. It is a normal negotiation process. The Russian delegation accepted the position of Kyrgyzstan intelligently.
- Are negotiations going on?
- After the New Year we held meetings at the expert level, where we were informed about changed position of the Eurasian Economic Commission on further negotiation process. Essentially, the position is constructive and it implies discussion and acceptance of our suggestions, to some extent. The meeting of the Supreme Council of the Eurasian Economic Commission will be held in March and our Road map may be adopted there.
- Do experts of the Eurasian Economic Commission agree with those arguments, which the Kyrgyz party submitted?
- We were suggested to discuss many of the questions bilaterally but not within the integration processes. There is such a premise.
- Can we speak about terms of the accession now?
- In order to announce the terms, it is necessary to register them somewhere. The Road map could give answer to this question, but it hasn\'t been approved yet. We were always afraid that the term of its implementation is rather limited - just a year. Our experts said that it isn\'t possible. At present the position of our partners has changed a little and they don\'t set such strict terms on the accession. That is why we can\'t tell definitely when our country accesses the union will take place.
- Will positions of Kyrgyzstan in the Road map be corrected?
- Yes, the changes of positions led to the fact that some points from four will be taken away. A single-step restriction of markets\' activity caused fears. But not a word was said about the necessity of their closure. Re-export operates according to the principle that customs weight clearance is close to zero, it is necessary to cancel this order and get customs clearance by invoice. Then, of course, prime cost of goods will increase, but it won\'t be a considerable growth. If we cancel this procedure, competitiveness of our entrepreneurs will reduce.
- That is why we have such a difference with data of Chinese customs?
- Of course, their goods are valued at $5,000 and ours pass through customs at a price of $100. Of course the statistics is quite different. Nevertheless, markets formed a serious infrastructure with a great number of people engaged in. Restriction of their activities will create social tension. That is why the Government concerns about this question. There is a program of Dordoi market development. It is aimed at its reprofiling, including switching of a part of business to production.
Limited time of accession puts markets in a difficult situation, when we, haven\'t yet completed the development program, would stop their operation. Due to the fact that the terms of accession can be loyal enough, we can no longer put the question of markets before our partners.
- How problem with laboratories will be resolved?
- The Customs Union has strict requirements on compliance assessment and that is the argument on non-accession. But whether we access the union or not, this norm exists and those who are going to export goods to the territory of the CU will have to fulfill the requirements. That is why it isn\'t logical to say that we won\'t access the union due to this reason.
-What will happen in case of accession? Now, for example, I produce milk. But for its realization in Kazakhstan I will have to move there in order experts to give their opinion on the possibility of exports. Only after it a customer can buy my production. The single system of technical regulation implies that a laboratory, which is located here, will be able to issue a document of single sample.
But it is necessary to define such laboratories. There are not enough laboratories, that is why the Road map provides for coordination of our testing centers. We defined financing for it, i.e. $236 million. In this case accession to the CU substantially simplifies possibility of entrance to CU market for our exporters. Non-accession won\'t cancel these norms and barriers on border will only tighten up.
- What first shocks will Kyrgyzstan face in accession to CU?
- There is more or less adequate research, which clearly shows what will happen after the accession and non-accession. In general, there will be the following situation. There is a basic scenario of economy development. The approximate growth of economy amounts to 4.5 percent. We moved in such format for many years. International institutes say this is the most realistic prognosis for development of our economy. By mathematical modeling there were imposed changes as a result of joining the CU. The joining showed the following: next year we will get 2 points GDP growth, i.e. 6.5 instead of 4.5 percent. Then there is a sharp decline by 3-4 points and then there will be slow equalization. A common decline by 2018-2019 will amount to 0.5 percent.
- And what will happen in case of non-accession to CU?
- Non-accession to the CU on condition of introduction of restrictive measures against us, gives the following situation: there will be decline without raise at once, exactly the same equalization and we will get similar situation by 2017-2018. What is a political task? If we access it, we must be above the baseline by 2-2.5 percent. It becomes the subject of discussion with our CU partners. We should reach this level through stimulation of domestic consumption and attraction of investments. Non-accession isn\'t a terrible threat, but it hasn\'t any optimistic prospects too.
- Due to what will the first growth spurt occur?
- We will have increase in budget revenues due to increase of customs tariffs and deductions from the common pot. Money is transferred to budget and spent on consumption. Then inflation goes and these consequences need to be leveled and for these purposes we must attract investments. But it isn\'t possible to create such conditions in a moment. For example, it can be implemented by administrative methods: businessmen are said - go to Kyrgyzstan and construct hydropower stations. Exactly the creation of labor-intensive productions was discussed during the negotiations.
- How much will prices raise after joining the Customs Union?
- There are two preconditions for their growth, but there are also counterarguments, which make two premises incorrect. The argument of opponents: we change customs tariff, now we have 5.3 percent and it will be 10.5 that will lead to growth in prices. Tomorrow the tariff will be changed and this sum will be transferred to the budget and prices growth will be compensated by incomes increase. The second argument: prices in market are common, as prices in CU countries are higher, so our prices will grow too. Let\'s analyze what is cheaper in our country. Chinese goods may go up by 4 percent, but goods which we import from CU countries will not rise in prices. Goods produced in the Kyrgyz Republic will really rise in prices.
- Can strengthening of checkpoints on the border increase customs payments?
- It will happen not only due to improvement of management. How is CU budget formed? All payments are collected into a single treasury and then they are distributed in proportion to bids, which are defined in accordance with international statistics. That is calculations will be carried out according to Chinese statistics. The People\'s Republic of China says that trade turnover with Kyrgyzstan exceeds $6 billion. According to our statistics, there isn\'t even $1 billion. It means that we will get 6 times more from these dues.