Border.kg. Covering up tracks
The next border conflict occurred one of these days in Kyrgyzstan. This time the epicenter was located in Dzheti-Oguz district, Issyk-Kul province-on Pikertyk border section. A real massacre occurred 40 kilometers from the Kyrgyz-Chinese border on January 23. However, even today when the killed persons have been identified, the story itself remains obscure. The more actively the security officials try to throw light upon it, the more tangled it becomes. Who is covering up the tracks?
Event history
If the official chronicle of the State Border Service of Kyrgyzstan is to be trusted, the events developed as follows: on January 23, 2014 at about 08.30 a.m. the border authorized representative informed that an unknown group of 11 people was discovered nearby Pikertyk heating point. The head of Issyk-Kul Association of Hunters and Anglers Alexander Barykin reported him about that. After that the employee of the hunting union returned to the place and again met this unknown group. He tried to escort them to Pikertyk point. However, the men attacked Barykin, seized his Vepr carbine and brutally killed the man. During the attack Barykin has managed to kill two criminals.
Approximately at 10.30 a.m. a special group -7 servicemen of Ak-Shyirak border unit - arrived at the scene. They found the body of Alexander Barykin with the cut off head. \"The unknown men took shelter of Pikertyk heating point and set fire to one of the buildings. Criminals were surrounded and blocked by the special group. Karasay Border Service Department also sent 10 reserve soldiers to the scene. At this time, the Chinese side was immediately informed about the incident on the line of border representatives,\" SBS reported.
As it was noted, military men of Ak-Shyirak and Karasay border services, having received from the unknown their refusal to surrender, eliminated them. At least 11 bodies were found at the scene. One soldier also received a gunshot wound. One of Pikertyk buildings burned down.
As it was reported, the territory was immediately cordoned off. Officers of the regional GKNB department, Interior Department of the province and investigation group of the Military Prosecutor\'s Office of Balykchy garrison also arrived at the scene later on. Investigation was started at 20.40 p.m. It found out that the unknown men were similar to the Uyghur people, they were 25-30 years old, wore civilian clothes and sports shoes.
Odd findings
According to the State Border Service (SBS) of the Kyrgyz Republic, the investigation team found 11 bodies at the scene. Acting Chairman of SBS Raimberdi Duyshenbiyev told reporters the day before that all the killed men looked like the Uyghurs and spoke to the Kyrgyz border guards in their native language. \"Judging from their outfit, we found out that they belong to the Uyghur separatist organization. We immediately informed the Chinese side after finding their bodies. The Chinese side said they did not have data on the state border violation by a group of people. But the party noted that a village, which is populated by the Uyghurs, is located 90 kilometers of the border line in this area, and there are members of separatist organizations among them,\" he said.
Judging by the list of items that were found at the scene, it is difficult to guess intentions of the intruders. SBS noted that the investigation, having considered many versions, has chosen a single one. \"Uighur separatists came to seize guns of shepherds and hunters, commit a couple of terrorist acts and to return to their homeland - China. We exclude the version that they were poachers, smugglers or just refugees,\" Raimberdi Duyshenbiyev said confidently.
The investigation team, however, did not find firearms of the killed criminals, just only Vepr carbine, which belonged to Alexander Barykin, as well as 2 axes, knifes and masks. In addition, investigators also found inoperative camera without USB flash drive, as well as money (602 Chinese yuan and $ 546), a compass, topographic map made in China, 3 lorry tires, two pumps, pliers, 8 backpacks, special white cloth for wrapping of corpses for 11 people, prayer rugs, rosaries, Koran , keys, 11 pairs of shoes with socks, ropes, food (dates, pistachios, corn meal, 2 liters of honey), personal care items.
Doubtful heroism
After 8 hours of negotiations, Kyrgyz border guards (17 people) killed all 11 separatists by a grenade launcher. Raimberdi Duyshenbiyev reported about the heroic deed of his soldiers to the President. Almazbek Atambayev, in his turn, thanked the border guards involved in the operation and wished speedy recovery to the soldier, who was injured during the special operation.
\"Head of the state noted that timely response of the State Border Service troops to the situation and the exact performance of their duties show high professionalism of border guards of Kyrgyzstan,\" press service of the President reported.
Raimberdi Duyshenbiyev himself believes that the operation was successful. \"Separatists were killed because they brutally murdered our citizen and not complied with demands of the border guards,\" he said at a press conference.
However, the public perceived the behavior of border guards not so positively. Speech of the SBS acting head did not give exhaustive answers to the questions of citizens. The initially obscure story remained unclear. Experts also questioned heroism of border guards who killed the men without waiting for soldiers of special forces, who could take criminals alive and shed light on the aims and objectives of the state border violators.
Only heroism of Alexander Barykin, who showed his civic stance and courage defending the interests of Kyrgyzstan at the cost of his life, does not raise doubts. Being at the right time in the right place, he has managed to warn the guards about the impending threat. But this act cost him his life.
The President instructed to posthumously award Alexander Barykin who first offered armed resistance to violators of the state border, killing two criminals.
An eye for an eye
Exactly the cruelty of trespassers, according to acting head of the State Border Service, was the cause of their liquidation. \"The border guards could not allow the criminals to leave using nightfall and smokescreen of the burning heating point building,\" Raimberdi Duyshenbiyev said.
Does it worth to remind the main border guard of the country, that to respond with an eye for an eye, is at least outside the international law. Besides, as it turned out, the killed Chinese citizens had only one rifle. And the forces were clearly unequal: 17 armed soldiers against nine fanatics who had only knives and a carbine. Nobody argues that severe measures should be taken against the violators of the state border, who also cruelly killed our citizen. But it is also irrationally to liquidate them without knowing the reason and the purpose of their arrival. This is, at least, the opinion of experts.
\"If they really were the Uyghur separatists, terrorists or someone else, they have chosen a very original a way to sneak into the country. There are less extreme ways to penetrate into Kyrgyzstan. For example, they could officially cross the border with \"clean\" documents. And then - on a particular day and hour - they could meet at the appointed place and organize one or a series of terrorist attacks. Because the main condition for successful terrorist attack is the ability of a terrorist to blend into the surroundings. The fact is that a large number of the Uyghur arrives in the country from China to trade on our markets, so \"tourist trader\" is a perfect disguise,\" the expert Dmitry Orlov believes.
The story itself is odd enough to consider a version as the only true. And it\'s hard to disagree with it.
Political analyst Mars Sariyev also did not attempt to guess who and why. But he noted that \"the story is completely unprofitable for China.\" \"But the rest will derive benefit from it. Each of them- according to their intelligence and project approach. Silk Road project falls down. The expansion of China is primarily economic. They brutally suppress the Uyghur separatism as it is, but the trade losses could undermine their position in Kyrgyzstan. Global game is also possible. Do you remember Raiga Kadyr, who started Twitter revolution, while being in the United States. Separatism in Xinjiang is supported by Western intelligence agencies. According to another version, China and Russia have a chance to strengthen SCO taking advantage of the situation,\" he said.
The experts agree that the official version of the Kyrgyz side confuses the situation even more. And they cast doubts on the fact that \"the unarmed Uyghur, who crossed the border at a height of 4,500 meters, are really separatists.\"
The Chinese side is keeping silence so far. The Embassy of China refused to comment on the situation. It is known, that the diplomats of two countries have carried out a relevant meeting in Bishkek. If the local diplomatic mission of China begins to speak, it can shed light on this complicated story. However, everything depends on the notorious \"if...\"